April 5th, 2004

Index

Richard Earley on Jewish intellectuals

 

 

 

Susan Sontag Cynthia Ozick
Image28.gif Sontag1.jpg

 

 

 

 

Towering Jewish Intellectuals

 

 

Karen Heller

September 18, 2004

Philadelphia Inquirer

Editor

 

 

Karen Heller wrote on September 16 about Cynthia Ozick: "She is one of New York's two towering Jewish female intellectual novelists, essayists and critics, the other being Susan Sontag."

Sontag an intellectual ?

" Sontag qualifies as an intellectual only in the bizarre definitions of contemporary America and most especially New York City. Where else could somebody who wrote "the white race is the cancer of history" be so celebrated?

Would someone who wrote "Jews are the cancer of history" be so honored?

  She has commented "America is founded on genocide" and "the quality of American life is an insult to the possibilities of human growth.Sontag as one of the great American humanitarians was in the lead in advocating intervention in Bosnia during the Clinton administration. These noble creatures for the most part were ones who advocated American withdrawal from Vietnam.

Susan Sontag vists Hanoi

Image27.gif Susan Sontag during the war in Vietnam had gone to Hanoi in 1968 and had been impressed with an ethical society whose rulers loved their people. She had thought their only defect was that they were not "good enough haters". She professed admiration for their caring treatment of captured American pilots. She told the trade paper for New York intellectuals that one could only be happy about the victory of the communists in Vietnam.

Her behavior was identical with the French Communist Party which had worked for the certain defeat of the French army in Vietnam..

 

During the continuing crisis in Bosnia she felt inspired to help those besieged in Sarajevo. She produced plays. She must have felt her presence was such a positive one for morale it warranted importing extra food into that besieged city. One might have wanted to ask if at night she went out with a rifle and shot Serbs.

From Hollywood came an appeal that America must learn what the meaning of "never again" truly meant. To break the siege these late-blooming warmongers insisted Mr. Clinton must act unflinchingly. They demanded air strikes if necessary. These worthies insisted Mr. Clinton did not need Britain, France, Russia or the Pentagon. Their commander-in-chief, Mr. Clinton, must lead the world in decency and righteousness.

This emotional response was prompted by Elie Wiesel, a Nobel peace prize winner, professional concentration camp survivor and untitled leader of the Holocaust industry, who pointed out the slaughter was occurring while the United States was doing nothing.

For this country to regain sanity and a notion of decency Susan Sontag and her blinded friends must be confronted with their grotesque notions of morality. Quick to urge others to endanger themselves to satisfy her standards of virtue Sontag represents those who deny that communists killed far more people than Hitler ever did, but believes her secular sainthood entitles her to moral superiority.

Perhaps the Inquirer could take the lead in damning these pious frauds.

Respectfully,

Richard Earley

 

 

1. The Guardian, Jan 19, 2002

Wilson Quarterly, p106, Summer 1983

New York Review of Books, p24, Jun 12, 1975

NYT, Jul 18, 1952, p1