The Final Solution
02-02-2004, 10:17 AM
'No Gas Chambers' Says Influential Japanese Magazine
Jewish-Zionist Boycott Campaign Shuts Down Prominent Monthly
Under the provocative headline, "The Greatest Taboo of Postwar World
History:
There were no Nazi 'Gas Chambers'," a ten-page revisionist article
appeared
in the February 1995 issue of Marco Polo, an influential and reputable
Japanese
magazine.
Packed with advertising for luxury goods by major international firms,
and
sprinkled with photographs of pretty young women, Marco Polo is a
slick,
250,000-circulation monthly aimed at men in their 20s and 30s. Founded
in 1991, the
current affairs feature magazine is issued by the Bungei Shunju
company, one of
Japan's most prestigious publishing firms.
Besides Marco Polo, the company publishes nine weekly and monthly
magazines,
which are among the most influential in Japan. It is also the Japanese
publisher of the Anne Frank Diary, which has sold nearly five million
copies in that
country.
But this is a "good news, bad news" story. It wasn't long before the
publisher capitulated to an international Jewish-Zionist boycott and
pressure
campaign, and shut down the magazine for good.
The article, written by 38-year-old neurology physician Dr. Masanori
Nishioka, was published only after Marco Polo staff members spent five
months checking
the author's sources, conducting additional research, and carefully
editing
the text.
It appeared with an introductory endorsement by Marco Polo:
On January 27th, the Auschwitz concentration camp celebrates the 50th
anniversary of its 'liberation.' However, here the greatest taboo of
postwar history
is hiding. In fact the 'Holocaust' -- the idea that Jews were
slaughtered by
the Nazis -- has begun to be the subject of serious doubt. There is no
doubt
that many Jews died tragically. Since the war, it has been shown that
none of
the concentration camps in the west had gas chambers. Only those in the
East are
now said to have had them. However, these gas chambers are not sealed
properly. From a scientific point of view, the gas used could hardly
have been
adequate for large-scale killing. In fact, in Europe and the United
States questions
of this kind have generated considerable journalistic activity. Even a
number
of Jewish scholars themselves have doubts. Why is it that only Japan's
mass
media does not write about this problem? Astonishing history
investigated
single-handedly by a young physician!
Calling the Holocaust a "fabrication," Nishioka wrote that "the story
of 'gas
chambers' was used as propaganda for the purposes of psychological
warfare,"
and is "nothing more than a transformation, without verification, of
wartime
'gas chamber' stories into 'history'." He also wrote:
The "gas chambers" currently open to the public at the remains of the
Auschwitz concentration camp in Poland are a postwar fabrication built
either by the
Polish Communist regime or by the Soviet Union, which controlled the
country.
Neither at Auschwitz nor anywhere else in the territory controlled by
the
Germans during the Second World War was there even one "mass
extermination of
Jews" in "gas chambers."
Hundreds of thousands of Jews, affirms Nishioka, perished in the camps
as a
result of disease due to unhygienic conditions, but not as a
consequence of an
extermination policy. "Neither Hitler nor the Nazi leadership ever
planned the
'extermination' of the Jews," he wrote.
Nishioka points out that a chamber at the Dachau concentration camp,
which
American propagandists portrayed as a "gas chamber" used to kill
prisoners, was
actually a non-homicidal delousing chamber. He also presents
considerable
evidence to show that the "gas chamber" shown to tourists at Auschwitz
was built
by Communists after the war.
In support of his arguments, Nishioka cites a number of historians and
various scholarly books and articles. Among them are several published
by the IHR,
including Dr. Arthur Butz' classic, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century,
and Dr.
Wilhelm Stäglich's Auschwitz: A Judge Looks at the Evidence.
Nishioka also mentions American revisionist writers Mark Weber and Ted
O'Keefe.
In addition, last August Nishioka visited Poland to inspect the former
concentration camps of Auschwitz (including Birkenau) and Majdanek.
Among the
photographs accompanying the article are five taken by him during that
visit. Two
show the "crematory chimney" at the Auschwitz I camp. As these photos
make
clear, the free-standing chimney is an obvious dummy, not connected to
a crematory
or even a building.
Comparing the wartime fate of Europe's Jews with that of Chinese killed
by
Japanese troops, and the victims of American atomic bombings of
Japanese cities,
Nishioka concludes his article with an expression of sympathy for the
"tragic
deaths" of many European Jews.
Initial Resistance
Jewish-Zionist groups responded to the article with characteristic
speed and
ruthlessness. Through its embassy in Tokyo, the Israeli government
formally
protested to the Japanese government, while the Simon Wiesenthal Center
of Los
Angeles mounted a boycott campaign against the Bungei Shunju company.
The magazine's initial response was a statement defending the
provocative
article. In explaining his decision to publish it, Marco Polo editor
Kazuyoshi
Hanada -- one of Japan's most prominent journalists -- said that Dr.
Nishioka
had found evidence to show that standard views about gassings of Jews
are not
accurate. "We would not run an article we thought was wrong," Hanada
said on
Jan. 24.
"It's not good for everything about a certain subject to be taboo," he
added.
"Maybe Israelis and Japanese have different ways of thinking about
that."
Hanada even asked Nishioka to contribute additional articles to future
issues of
his magazine.
Hanada become editor of Marco Polo in April 1994, after having served
as ed
itor of Shukan Bunshun, another Bungei Shunju magazine. Under his
editorship,
Shukan Bunshun attained the highest circulation of any weekly magazine
in Japan.
In recent months, Hanada has appeared on television as a commentator.
Marco Polo also generously announced that it would welcome a rebuttal
of
Nishioka's article, offering both the Wiesenthal Center and the Israeli
embassy an
opportunity to respond with a ten-page article of its own. The offer
was
promptly and predictably rejected.
Rabbi Abraham Cooper, deputy chief of the Wiesenthal Center, said:
"Their
[revisionists'] goal is to get debate going. They're seeking to give
legitimacy
to their view." In a Jan. 25 letter, the Israeli embassy wrote to the
publisher: "If your magazine is going to take a neutral observer
position, that of a
courtroom trial, in which both sides' arguments and claims are to be
introduced,
we must decline."
The Wiesenthal Center mounted an international boycott campaign against
Marco
Polo advertisers, and quickly succeeded in persuading major firms -
including
Volkswagen, Cartier, Philip Morris, Mitsubishi Motors and Mitsubishi
Electric
-- to cancel their advertising.
Accompanying the economic arm-twisting was a propaganda barrage with
the
usual smears. The Wiesenthal Center put out the falsehood that Dr.
Nishioka never
visited the site of any wartime German concentration camp. This lie was
widely
repeated, such as in a Chicago Tribune report (Jan. 25) from its
Tokyo-based
staff writer Merrill Goozner.
As a result of the campaign, the Japanese government on Jan. 30 issued
a
statement calling the Marco Polo article "extremely improper." A
Foreign Ministry
official added that Japanese embassies and consulates around the world
would
be instructed about the government's "position on the Holocaust."
Capitulation
Under such pressure, it didn't take long for the publishing company to
capitulate. On Jan. 30 Bungei Shunju issued a statement of apology: "We
ran an
article that was not fair to the Nazi massacre of Jewish people, and by
running the
article, we caused deep sorrow and hardship for Jewish society and
related
people."
Marco Polo magazine didn't just surrender. It committed Hara Kiri.
At a packed news conference on Feb. 2 with Wiesenthal Center deputy
director
Rabbi Abraham Cooper, Bungei company president Kengo Tanaka formally
apologized for causing Jews "immeasurable pain" by publishing
Nishioka's article. To
atone for its grievous sin, Tanaka said he had closed down the
offending
magazine for good, and had relieved the responsible staff members of
their duties.
All remaining copies of the February issue were being recalled and
destroyed.
'Hit By a Steel Bat'
"We came to know of the very deep pain and agony inflicted by the Marco
Polo
article," said Tanaka, who acknowledged that the decision to shut down
the
magazine was made in response to protests from the Israeli government
and Jewish
organizations.
"I have realized how much anger and sorrow this article has caused
within
Jewish society. I feel like I've been woken up after being hit by a
steel bat. I
truly regret that we ran the article," said Tanaka. "As a country that
hopes
to become more international, Japan must recognize the plight of Jews."
Rabbi Cooper of the Wiesenthal Center praised Tanaka's action as
"serious and
unprecedented," and announced that the Center was calling off its
economic
boycott against Bungei.
Tanaka's craven repentance apparently was not enough, however. On Feb.
14, he
resigned as president of Bungei Shunju.
Jewish-Zionist Boycott Campaign Shuts Down Prominent Monthly
Under the provocative headline, "The Greatest Taboo of Postwar World
History:
There were no Nazi 'Gas Chambers'," a ten-page revisionist article
appeared
in the February 1995 issue of Marco Polo, an influential and reputable
Japanese
magazine.
Packed with advertising for luxury goods by major international firms,
and
sprinkled with photographs of pretty young women, Marco Polo is a
slick,
250,000-circulation monthly aimed at men in their 20s and 30s. Founded
in 1991, the
current affairs feature magazine is issued by the Bungei Shunju
company, one of
Japan's most prestigious publishing firms.
Besides Marco Polo, the company publishes nine weekly and monthly
magazines,
which are among the most influential in Japan. It is also the Japanese
publisher of the Anne Frank Diary, which has sold nearly five million
copies in that
country.
But this is a "good news, bad news" story. It wasn't long before the
publisher capitulated to an international Jewish-Zionist boycott and
pressure
campaign, and shut down the magazine for good.
The article, written by 38-year-old neurology physician Dr. Masanori
Nishioka, was published only after Marco Polo staff members spent five
months checking
the author's sources, conducting additional research, and carefully
editing
the text.
It appeared with an introductory endorsement by Marco Polo:
On January 27th, the Auschwitz concentration camp celebrates the 50th
anniversary of its 'liberation.' However, here the greatest taboo of
postwar history
is hiding. In fact the 'Holocaust' -- the idea that Jews were
slaughtered by
the Nazis -- has begun to be the subject of serious doubt. There is no
doubt
that many Jews died tragically. Since the war, it has been shown that
none of
the concentration camps in the west had gas chambers. Only those in the
East are
now said to have had them. However, these gas chambers are not sealed
properly. From a scientific point of view, the gas used could hardly
have been
adequate for large-scale killing. In fact, in Europe and the United
States questions
of this kind have generated considerable journalistic activity. Even a
number
of Jewish scholars themselves have doubts. Why is it that only Japan's
mass
media does not write about this problem? Astonishing history
investigated
single-handedly by a young physician!
Calling the Holocaust a "fabrication," Nishioka wrote that "the story
of 'gas
chambers' was used as propaganda for the purposes of psychological
warfare,"
and is "nothing more than a transformation, without verification, of
wartime
'gas chamber' stories into 'history'." He also wrote:
The "gas chambers" currently open to the public at the remains of the
Auschwitz concentration camp in Poland are a postwar fabrication built
either by the
Polish Communist regime or by the Soviet Union, which controlled the
country.
Neither at Auschwitz nor anywhere else in the territory controlled by
the
Germans during the Second World War was there even one "mass
extermination of
Jews" in "gas chambers."
Hundreds of thousands of Jews, affirms Nishioka, perished in the camps
as a
result of disease due to unhygienic conditions, but not as a
consequence of an
extermination policy. "Neither Hitler nor the Nazi leadership ever
planned the
'extermination' of the Jews," he wrote.
Nishioka points out that a chamber at the Dachau concentration camp,
which
American propagandists portrayed as a "gas chamber" used to kill
prisoners, was
actually a non-homicidal delousing chamber. He also presents
considerable
evidence to show that the "gas chamber" shown to tourists at Auschwitz
was built
by Communists after the war.
In support of his arguments, Nishioka cites a number of historians and
various scholarly books and articles. Among them are several published
by the IHR,
including Dr. Arthur Butz' classic, The Hoax of the Twentieth Century,
and Dr.
Wilhelm Stäglich's Auschwitz: A Judge Looks at the Evidence.
Nishioka also mentions American revisionist writers Mark Weber and Ted
O'Keefe.
In addition, last August Nishioka visited Poland to inspect the former
concentration camps of Auschwitz (including Birkenau) and Majdanek.
Among the
photographs accompanying the article are five taken by him during that
visit. Two
show the "crematory chimney" at the Auschwitz I camp. As these photos
make
clear, the free-standing chimney is an obvious dummy, not connected to
a crematory
or even a building.
Comparing the wartime fate of Europe's Jews with that of Chinese killed
by
Japanese troops, and the victims of American atomic bombings of
Japanese cities,
Nishioka concludes his article with an expression of sympathy for the
"tragic
deaths" of many European Jews.
Initial Resistance
Jewish-Zionist groups responded to the article with characteristic
speed and
ruthlessness. Through its embassy in Tokyo, the Israeli government
formally
protested to the Japanese government, while the Simon Wiesenthal Center
of Los
Angeles mounted a boycott campaign against the Bungei Shunju company.
The magazine's initial response was a statement defending the
provocative
article. In explaining his decision to publish it, Marco Polo editor
Kazuyoshi
Hanada -- one of Japan's most prominent journalists -- said that Dr.
Nishioka
had found evidence to show that standard views about gassings of Jews
are not
accurate. "We would not run an article we thought was wrong," Hanada
said on
Jan. 24.
"It's not good for everything about a certain subject to be taboo," he
added.
"Maybe Israelis and Japanese have different ways of thinking about
that."
Hanada even asked Nishioka to contribute additional articles to future
issues of
his magazine.
Hanada become editor of Marco Polo in April 1994, after having served
as ed
itor of Shukan Bunshun, another Bungei Shunju magazine. Under his
editorship,
Shukan Bunshun attained the highest circulation of any weekly magazine
in Japan.
In recent months, Hanada has appeared on television as a commentator.
Marco Polo also generously announced that it would welcome a rebuttal
of
Nishioka's article, offering both the Wiesenthal Center and the Israeli
embassy an
opportunity to respond with a ten-page article of its own. The offer
was
promptly and predictably rejected.
Rabbi Abraham Cooper, deputy chief of the Wiesenthal Center, said:
"Their
[revisionists'] goal is to get debate going. They're seeking to give
legitimacy
to their view." In a Jan. 25 letter, the Israeli embassy wrote to the
publisher: "If your magazine is going to take a neutral observer
position, that of a
courtroom trial, in which both sides' arguments and claims are to be
introduced,
we must decline."
The Wiesenthal Center mounted an international boycott campaign against
Marco
Polo advertisers, and quickly succeeded in persuading major firms -
including
Volkswagen, Cartier, Philip Morris, Mitsubishi Motors and Mitsubishi
Electric
-- to cancel their advertising.
Accompanying the economic arm-twisting was a propaganda barrage with
the
usual smears. The Wiesenthal Center put out the falsehood that Dr.
Nishioka never
visited the site of any wartime German concentration camp. This lie was
widely
repeated, such as in a Chicago Tribune report (Jan. 25) from its
Tokyo-based
staff writer Merrill Goozner.
As a result of the campaign, the Japanese government on Jan. 30 issued
a
statement calling the Marco Polo article "extremely improper." A
Foreign Ministry
official added that Japanese embassies and consulates around the world
would
be instructed about the government's "position on the Holocaust."
Capitulation
Under such pressure, it didn't take long for the publishing company to
capitulate. On Jan. 30 Bungei Shunju issued a statement of apology: "We
ran an
article that was not fair to the Nazi massacre of Jewish people, and by
running the
article, we caused deep sorrow and hardship for Jewish society and
related
people."
Marco Polo magazine didn't just surrender. It committed Hara Kiri.
At a packed news conference on Feb. 2 with Wiesenthal Center deputy
director
Rabbi Abraham Cooper, Bungei company president Kengo Tanaka formally
apologized for causing Jews "immeasurable pain" by publishing
Nishioka's article. To
atone for its grievous sin, Tanaka said he had closed down the
offending
magazine for good, and had relieved the responsible staff members of
their duties.
All remaining copies of the February issue were being recalled and
destroyed.
'Hit By a Steel Bat'
"We came to know of the very deep pain and agony inflicted by the Marco
Polo
article," said Tanaka, who acknowledged that the decision to shut down
the
magazine was made in response to protests from the Israeli government
and Jewish
organizations.
"I have realized how much anger and sorrow this article has caused
within
Jewish society. I feel like I've been woken up after being hit by a
steel bat. I
truly regret that we ran the article," said Tanaka. "As a country that
hopes
to become more international, Japan must recognize the plight of Jews."
Rabbi Cooper of the Wiesenthal Center praised Tanaka's action as
"serious and
unprecedented," and announced that the Center was calling off its
economic
boycott against Bungei.
Tanaka's craven repentance apparently was not enough, however. On Feb.
14, he
resigned as president of Bungei Shunju.