View Full Version : Ernst Zundel
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:24 PM
I am going to take the opportunity of this forum to give Ernst Zundel, the so-called 'political prisoner', some of the ridicule that he rightly deserves. In addition to denying the holocaust, Stormfront tries to deny the lunacy of Zundel, these items were quickly deleted from Stormfront when they were posted there. The thing is, with Zundel, all one must do to ridicule him is to repeat him. So here it goes:
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/z/zundel-ernst/images/zundel-lemire.jpg
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-001.gif
TELEPHONE (416) 922-9850
ACHTUNG! SAMISDAT NEWS BULLETIN
SAMISDAT HOLLOW EARTH EXPEDITION $9999.00
IN SEARCH OF HOLES IN THE POLES
SEARCH FOR HITLER'S ANTARCTIC U.F.O. BASES
Due to an overwhelming number of letters and telephone calls requesting
details about our new books, new products, speaking tours, psychic research
projects and our intensive experimental UFO-construction programs, we have to
use this less personal form of keeping in touch with our many friends and
collaborators around the world.
Your response to our most recent mailout and activities has been most
encouraging! We have received orders and enquiries from as far away as Noumea
in the south Pacific, Easter Island, Chile, Argentina, Brazil, Venezuela,
Panama, Mexico, Soviet Satellite countries, China, South Africa, Persia, the
Congo, Australia, Japan, as well as from every country in Western Europe and
almost every state in the U.S.A. Not only is this response extensive, it is
massive--a clear indication on the part of knowledgeable UFO researchers and
members of the public that they are tired of the 'Junk food' being served up
by old-line UFO groups and publications who expound the official CIA-KGB alibi
that all UFOs are extraterrestrial. What the UFO-watching world wants now is
the real meat of the matter--a serious investigation of UFOs whose origins are
terrestrial.
SAMISDAT is the only organization making such an effort, but we are not
alone, for we have thousands of supporters like yourself who want to know the
truth which the saucer-charlatans have for 30 years tried to cover up with
fairy tale fantasies of 'little green men'. It is people like yourself who
have made SAMISDAT the most active UFO Organization and publisher on Planet
Earth!
Certainly we can be proud of this achievement which is the result, not
only of our own herculean efforts and sacrifices, but of your faithful support
during this 5 year long struggle against the forces of vested interest, deceit
and prejudice which have attempted to hide the UFO story under a cloak of
childish nonsense and outright lies. For many years we have determinedly
pursued this new course of investigation, firm in the knowledge that man is
able to achieve that which he perceives.
Our researchers' keen sense of direction and perception has guided them
unerringly in their discovery of seemingly insignificant clues and the
derivation of meaningful patterns therefrom. Only such devoted and painstaking
research could succeed in unearthing the present array of facts which indicate
the earthly origin of most flying saucers. As one vital discovery has led to
another, we have reached certain conclusions which are logical and
inescapable, however unpopular they may be today.
Our discoveries have led us into the production of a number of currently
suppressed and sometimes vilified books which are now underground bestsellers.
"UFOs--NAZI SECRET WEAPON?" was our first title, now sold out in 5 complete
editions. Our second book, "SECRET NAZI POLAR EXPEDITIONS", is coming up fast
and has sold out 2 full editions. Foreign language translations of these books
are selling briskly, and it is becoming obvious to everyone that the
media-enforced blockade of the truth has now been broken. Three additional
books are currently under production and these will round out our Phase I
Publishing Program: "THE CIA-KGB-UFO COVERUP", "THE ANTARCTICA THEORY" and
"THE LAST BATTALION".
During the course of our research, we have discovered some of the original
German flying saucer scientists who are still alive! These space pioneers are,
of course, old men now in their 70s and 80s. Our interviews with them will be
incorporated into our regular lecture program as well as into our future
books.
We have also been able to establish research teams in Canada, the U.S.A.
and in particular, Germany, whose task it is to rediscover basic wingless
flight which brought the original Nazi UFOs into being. Already, these teams
have designed and constructed small scale models, some using conventional
power and others which have propulsion systems unprecedented in today's
aerospace technology. With additional research, we hope to make available
several different models in kit form for hobby-builders. Any contributions to
these research projects, whether of ideas or money, will be very much
appreciated. Checks should be made out to SAMISDAT with the notation "For
SAMPROJ R-1".
Very popular among UFO fans and researchers, young and old, is our
currently avaluable working model of the first German design incorporating the
"Flügelrad" or 'winged-wheel' principle. This model was the big
crowd-drawing attraction of our recent Star Trek Convention display in New
York City. For a scientific demonstration of the inherent inflight stability
of disc-like aircraft--or for just good fun--indoors or outdoors, SAMISDAT
MODEL I is a safe, exciting, entertaining and educational introduction to the
world of flying saucers. Model I is smokeless, odorless and requires no
electric cords or batteries. Rising from its launcher in free flight, it soars
as high as 100 feet, hovers and is capable of traveling 200 feet or more
outdoors, making a beautiful takeoff and landing which any UFO pilot could be
proud of! Indoors, the model ascends rapidly to the ceiling and hovers at
maximum altitude for sometime [sic], before performing a graceful and
controlled descent. Model I is available for $6.95 + $1.00 for postage &
handling--a perfect gift for a boy or girl, whatever age he may be! The price
includes launching unit.Or, buy a SAMISDAT SAUCER-FRISBEE for $3.70,all
inclusive.
Cont.................
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:25 PM
For the truly dedicated UFO researcher, SAMISDAT is embarking upon a
magnificent and awe-inspiring experience! We are negotiating with several
international airlines and chartered air carriers in regard to our planned
investigation of the "Inner Earth Theory" coupled with our search for
"Hitler's Flying Saucer Bases in Antarctica." Our 'launching pad' for which we
are also negotiating will be located in Rio de Janeiro or Buenos Aires. This
site will be the gathering place for an International UFO Convention which is
scheduled to take place some time in 1979 or 1980. From this convention site,
those who are interested and financially able may join Christof Friedrich and
members of a specially-selected SAMISDAT research team on the Antarctic
Expedition who will not only search for Hitler's Saucer Bases in German
Antarctica, but who will further attempt to settle the controversy about
Admiral Byrd's "Flight into the Polar Opening" by actually flying over the
South Pole! Our tentative flight path is here shown. It is anticipated that a
specially-prepared, long-range jet will be available for the Antarctic
Expedition's polar flight.
This is the most daring scientific operation ever launched by any UFO
organization and publisher. The estimated cost for the Antarctic Expedition is
well in excess of $2,000,000.00--from which at least $500,000.00 is required
for allocation toward the charter deposit fee and modifications on the special
aircraft. A fantastic sum? Certainly, and it is just as certain to be worth
every dollar in terms of the knowledge to be gained.
SAMISDAT's Antarctic Expedition in Search of Hitler's Flying Saucer Bases
and the South Polar Opening into Inner Earth will be the unique event of a
lifetime. As only a very limited number of people can be accommodated, our
selection standards are of necessity rigorous. The approximate cost per person
on this expedition may be as high as $9,999.00. However, the cost could be
reduced considerably, provided we are able to raise money from our SAMISDAT
SERIES of lectures, tapes, conventions, UFO models and book sales in this
interim period. You can help to realize this dream of a lifetime in several
ways: (1) You can become one of our book distrlbutors by buying SAMISDAT books
and other items at wholesale dealers' prices and then retailing them to
friends, colleagues, UFO conventioneers, and visitors to county fairs, psychic
fairs and flea markets. By purchasing SAMISDAT titles in bulk, you could
easily realize almost a 100% profit on each item sold. This money you could
then apply toward your share in the Expeditlon or use as you see fit. (2) You
can organize a UFO club and hold your own UFO conventions on a profit-sharing
basis with SAMISDAT. (3) You can help us find sponsors for the Expedition. (4)
If you are rich and conscientious, you can underwrite the whole or part of the
Expedition and realize our goal of a lifetime much, much faster. But empty
promises and other hot-air products from windbags and do-nothings, however
well off, will not serve to waft the Expedition to Antarctica and back. The
only thing capable of doing that is cold, hard cash up front. If you've got
what it takes and want to put your money to work right away, then please
contact us! (5) You can set up your own fund-raising campaign for the
Expedition. For details and assistance in regard to these and other ideas, do
not hesitate to contact us.
These are but a few of the ways in which we can hasten that glorious day
when we board our sleek, silvery aircraft and wing our way to Antarctica and
beyond--to our rendezvous with history. When we return, we shall have
unearthed Inner Earth and/or found evidence of Hitler's UFO Bases--or we shall
have gone a long way toward dispelling two of the most tenaciously persistent
mysteries of our Scientific Era. Will you join us and help?
NOW TO THE BAD NEWS!
As of this mailing, all those who do not respond to this letter or who have
not ordered SAMISDAT items in the last year will be removed from our mailing
list. We are sorry that such a policy is necessary, but it must be if we are
to remain as an active forward-moving organization in this field of
multi-faceted research. To maintain our headway, we must have rowers on the
oars, not idle passengers in the boat. We therefor [sic] request your understanding
and support. Overhead costs for labor, printing and postage are going up
rapidly and steadily. Thus, we cannot carry thousands of inactives on our
mailout list. We shall miss you, for we were happy to have you as a friend and
reader.
If you do not fill out the attached form and return it to us with a token
of support--whatever you can afford--this will be our last communication to
you. I am sorry that we will not be able to send you further bulletins
concerning the progress of our UFO research and development program in Germany
and North America. Nor will you ever know when the Antarctic Expedition takes
off nor what we have seen and discovered. Too bad.
But for you, the active Samisdat Supporter, who continue to show interest,
loyalty and diligence, I extend my most hearty greeting and sincerest
gratitude. Welcome aboard the Adventure of a Lifetime!
Yours Truly, [signed] Christof Friedrich
Note that "Christof Friedrich" is a pseudonym for Ernst Zündel himself
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:28 PM
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-002.gif
INNER CIRCLE
Samisdat Supporter and Financial Contributor:
Please cut out and return this card, properly
filled out and completed, in order to quality
as an active Samisdat Supporter.
I enclose a donation of $_____ in order to
receive subsequent issues of The Samisdat
Insiders' Report. Please keep me up to date on
Samisdat Activities.
I enclose a donation of $_____ toward SAMPROJ
R-1 for research & development of flying disc
aircraft. When model kits are available, please
notify me.
Type Qty
I enclose $_____ for: SAMISDAT SAUCER-FRISBEE___
SAMISDAT MODEL I ___
I would like to take part in SAMISDAT's proposed
UFO CONVENTION in South America. I understand
that the costs could be as high as $2500.00 for
transportation & accommodation. Yes No
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:35 PM
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-003.gif
WHAT'S NEW AT SAMISDAT?
Sensational Revelation: U.F.O.'s are real, they exist!
Definite proof, solid evidence, in factual report by South American author, richly illustrated with drawings and photographs.
Read how the Nazis sent a top secret expedition to Antarctica before the war. How the Nazis discovered near-tropical, ice-free islands and holes, some 300 miles wide, in the icy waters of the last unknown frontier.
Over 400,000 square miles of Antarctica were claimed by that Nazi expeditionary force, an area larger than all of Germany. Were bases established?
Were they expanded during the war? Did a huge convoy of the latest, most sophisticated German submarines with a range of 15,000 miles leave Norway in 1945? Did a Nazi submarine flotilla, using incredible new, secret weapons, totally destroy an attacking Allied force? Was Hitler and Eva Braun on board? Was Wernher von Braun and his group of conventional rocket scientists deliberately sacrificed to the Americans and Soviets in order to hide the greatest breakthrough in weapons technology of the century?
[following text appears above three photographs]
German flying boat used during secret Nazi expedition. Part of Nazi expeditionary force to Antarctica. [Following text appears below these same photographs]U-Boat 530 surrendered to Argentina with a load of cigarettes on board, two months after the war ended. Nothing else on board. What was their ultimate destination?
When did the allied poweres discover that Hitler and his last battalion of elite troops and the Reich's top inventors and researchers and geniuses might have gotten away? Was Admiral Byrd, with 40 ships and 4,000 troops sent to Antarctica in 1947 to try and capture this last contingent of the New Order?
Why did Byrd's expedition flee Antarctica without the mission accomplished. What happened to Byrd? Why was it rumoured that he had been put into a mental hospital after his return?
Did the Nazis, with their secret weapons, "buzz" the Capitol in Washington in order to intimidate the U.S. government?
[Saucer photographs]
Engineer's drawing of Nazi U.F.O. Test flown Feb. 14, 1945.
Where are "they" now? Are they operating U.F.O.'s? How do these "ships" function and what do they look like?
These and many other exciting queries answered and documented with Hitler's own words, taken from top secret conferences and private talks with only a handful of initiates in attendance. This is definitely one of the most captivating, thought provoking and stimulating books ever compiled. [Photos of two books] The German version: Many different photos and deeper more philosophic political-historical text. Same size and number of pages.
[Photos of missiles and rockets - tiny text describing same illegible]
U.F.O.'s - NAZI SECRET WEAPON?
This sensational, underground best seller is now in its 5th edition in English and its 2nd edition in German. French, Spanish and Italian editions are now in the planning stages. This is the most talked-about U.F.O. book of the decade! As the center of controversy, its author, Christof Friedrich, has become the subject of much attention and has been a frequently-invited guest on many internationally broadcast TV and radio talkshows which SAMISDAT technicians have recorded on tape cassettes for sale to the UFOlogers and intrigued members of the public. This book is certainly intriguing, for it reveals for the first time amazing plans for Nazi Germany's ultimate secret weapon: the Flying Disc! 145 photographs, 74 engineering drawings and illustrations, 5 maps revealing the location of secret U.F.O. bases, 63 photographically reproduced documents and actual U.F.O. sightings. Uncensored! $4.95 + 75 cents postage & handling. Please send an additional $1 IF YOU WISH TO HAVE THE BOOK AUTOGRAPHED BY THE AUTHOR AND DEDICATED TO YOU OR A FRIEND - a tremendous gift idea!
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:38 PM
Page two:
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-004.gif
SECRET NAZI POLAR EXPEDITIONS
Now in its second, enlarged edition, with many newly-discovered photos and illustrations. This is our latest best-seller. Read for the first time information which has been suppressed by Allied Censorship for over 40 years.
Author Christof Friedrich tears away the veils of wartime secrecy which surround Nazi Germany's Arctic and Antarctic activities. Read how the secret Thule Society aided Hitler's plans for Germany's future. Discover the truth about Rudolf Hess and the secret knowledge which the Allies fear he will tell the world. Delve deeply into Hitler's hidden teenage years. Discover Hitler's submarine strategy and his postwar plans. Study the amazing pictures taken from NATO archives which reveal mystery submarines, U-boat designs and secret production facilities. A truly unique book! Exciting, colorful cover, 130 pages, 140 photos from official Nazi, U.S. and British sources, many published for the first time. 22 maps, charts and diagrams, 12 illustrations, actual excerpts from the Nazi expeditions' logs, flight reports, etc. A complete roster of Nazi Polar Expedition members, revealing their names and ranks! a real historical find: Goering's letter of congratulation to the Nazi expedition! Plus many important newspaper reports which throw light on this amazing subject. $4.95 + 75 cents postage and handling.
THE 1st GERMAN EDITION
Hitler am Süt;dpol:
Focuses on the personal account of one of the leading members of the Nazi Antarctic Expedition of 1935-1939. The deep, philosophical bases of this polar exploration are revealed to those who wish to see beyond the veil of anti-German propaganda in order to perceive the wonderful realities of being and becoming which were the primary motivations for Germany's quest upon a frozen continent. Approx. 200 pages, $10.00 + $1 postage and handling. [drawing of book]
165 LITTLE KNOWN UFO SIGHTINGS FROM AROUND THE WORLD
An information-packed booklet containing over 30 years of unabridged news reports of eyewitness interviews from the far corners of the world. An amazing little book of U.F.O. fact, not fantasy. Read the actual statements of scientists, policemen, military personnel, commercial airline pilots, trained observers and just ordinary people.
Thousands of copies of this useful booklet have sold already and supplies are running out. 90 photos and illustrations, including 2 maps showing U.F.O. bases and locations of sightings. To assist the U.F.O. researcher, German experts have indicated with arrows U.F.O. sightings in which the "Flying saucer" shows the flying characteristics and configuration of known Nazi Saucers produced toward the end of the Second World War! $2.95 + 75 cents postage & handling.
Books now in the planning stage.
THE ANTARCTICA THEORY
Incredibly detailed star maps and diagrams disclose the cosmic dimensions of the Nazi "World Ice Theory" researched by Hitler's favorite scientists, Paul Höbiger. Revealed now, for the first time to the English-speaking world -- confidential documents from the files of a recently-deceased member of Hitler's inner circle. A mind-expanding profusion of maps, charts, star system diagrams and drawings which few eyes have seen, except for Hitler, Hess and Hörbiger himself! Huge caverns. Space age machines. Many rare maps, drawings and photographs...........$4.95
THE CI.A.-K.G.B. U.F.O. COVERUP
A totally new concept showing the Soviet-American collaboration in keeping secret the actual origin of U.F.O.'s. Exposes many instances of U.F.O. scares being manipulated to serve both the Soviet's and the C.I.A.'s plan for a worldwide superdictatorship. Maps, drawing and photographs, Underground factories....$4.95
The Last Battalion
A book that pieces together a puzzle of worldwide dimensions. Where are Hitler's most dedicated and loyal-to-death followers? Where is the immense Nazi wealth, invested by the Third Reich before and during W.W. II? Photos, Maps, etc...........................$4.95
Please indicate if you are interested in any of these titles. We rely on this information to establish an order of priority, also it helps us in our allocation of advertising funds. Thank you! SAMISDAT 206 Carlton Street, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M5A 2L1
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:53 PM
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-006.gif
OFFICIAL UFO INVESTIGATOR PASS
The most frequently observed shapes of U.F.O.'s, as reported from around the world. Note similarity to actual German Flying Saucers.
"SS" emblem indicates known NAZI saucer shapes similar to W.W. II designs.
(67 pictures of saucers shown, 42 of which are labelled "SS.")
QUESTIONS TO ASK U.F.O. CREW?
WHAT IS YOUR NAME?
WIE HEISSEN SIE?
WHERE ARE YOU FROM?
WO SIND SIE HER?
WHAT IS YOUR MISSION?
WAS WOLLEN SIE?
DO YOU HAVE A MESSAGE?
HABEN SIE EINE NACHRICHT?
MAY I VISIT THE INTERIOR OF YOUR CRAFT?
DARF ICH DAS INNERE IHRER MASCHINE BESICHTIGEN?
WHAT IS YOUR METHOD OF PROPULSION?
WAS IST IHR ANTRIEB?
WHAT IS YOUR TOP SPEED AND RANGE?
WAS IST IHRE HÖCHSTGESCHWINDIGKEIT UND REICHWEITE?
IS YOUR CRAFT ARMED?
SIND SIE BEWAFFNET?
WITH WHAT TYPE OF WEAPON?
MIT WELCHER ART WAFFEN?
Investigator's Name ___________________________________
Address _______________________________________________
City __________________________________________________
State/Province ________________________________________
Country _______________________________________________
Phone No. ______________ Nationality __________________
Show this pass to U.F.O. occupants or authorities, when conducting an investigation.
PHOTO OF INVESTIGATOR
(blank space for photo)
Did you get your spotter chart? $1.00 from Samisdat Publishers, 206 Carleton St., Toronto, Can
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 9th, 2003, 12:58 PM
http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/people/z/zundel.ernst/flying-saucers/saucers-007.gif
Some of the better known German U.F.O. prototypes.
When spotting a U.F.O. note: date, time, direction of travel or location, speed, angle, shape, size, distance, construction and propulsion of craft.
Compare to shape on spotter chart. Describe details, include photo or drawings and send copies to: Your local F.B.I. office; Center for U.F.O. Studies, Allen Hynek, Director, P.O. Box 11, Northfield, Ill. 60093 U.S.A.; Flying Saucers, Palmer Publications, Amherst, Wisc. 54406, U.S.A.; Samisdat Publishers, 206 Carlton St., Toronto, Canada.
If you want to be on our mailing list for future books, please drop us a line: Samisdat Publishers, 206 Carlton St. East, Toronto, Canada.
Gott
December 9th, 2003, 01:51 PM
So this stuff you've posted is why the thread took so long to load. SO FUCKING WHAT. Lots of people (on this forum, for instance) go crawling around on their hands and knees worshiping a non existent sand-nigger as 'god.' What the fuck are Ernst Zundel's obsessions next to that?
And, Ernest Zundel is in prison, in solitary confinement, denied bail, or even a fucking pillow in his cell - and not for believing in UFOs, the National Socialist variety or any other.
FIATLUX
December 9th, 2003, 02:26 PM
I am going to take the opportunity of this forum to give Ernst Zundel, the so-called 'political prisoner', some of the ridicule that he rightly deserves. In addition to denying the holocaust, Stormfront tries to deny the lunacy of Zundel, these items were quickly deleted from Stormfront when they were posted there. The thing is, with Zundel, all one must do to ridicule him is to repeat him. So here it goes:
I am sorry - I just don't get it - your point I mean.....
Now a days very many Americans believe in the Roswell phenomenon and probably more believe that the U.S. got flying saucers at Area51 .
Had you seen the German produced TV-production "Geheimnisse der dritte Reich" , that dealt with German UFO tech amongst other things , you would maybe have found things less ridiculous - and with respect to the "Hollow earth" Theory then there is Americans for that too...
I've just about had it with the ever cheap shots and the ever lasting ridicule at the industrious and skilled German people- I might start a seperate post on this....
FIAT LUX
luhwind
December 9th, 2003, 11:50 PM
Ernst Zundel has long exploited the mind of the American media-induced conspiracy theorist with such things... I have read interviews in which he has said as much... for example, I can't quote verbatim but he's said something to the effect of "Look, there's a question mark at the end"
From the perspective of those who oppose the social trends current in the West, do you think it matters very much that he uses these kind of tactics to tap into the minds of the judaized "conspiracy theorists"? Many of the people attracted to this kind of thing would likely (without their brains having been sucked dry) been open to intelligent and constructive conversation about issues that matter. If he can save a few souls this way, why not? The more informed minds after the fall, the better. When the time comes, Nazi UFOS won't matter... but the other things he's got to say most certainly will.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 11:41 AM
I am sorry - I just don't get it - your point I mean.....
Zundel is full of shit.
Now a days very many Americans believe in the Roswell phenomenon and probably more believe that the U.S. got flying saucers at Area51 .
They are full of shit as well.
Had you seen the German produced TV-production "Geheimnisse der dritte Reich" , that dealt with German UFO tech amongst other things ,
German UFO tech? I think not. They tried to make a few round aircraft but they did not work.
you would maybe have found things less ridiculous - and with respect to the "Hollow earth" Theory then there is Americans for that too...
They are full of shit. No real field of inquiry would accept a proponent of hollow earth theory into their fold. But holocaust denial is not a legitimate feild of inquiry, and their inclusion of Zundel into their midst is but one of many clues to this.
I've just about had it with the ever cheap shots and the ever lasting ridicule at the industrious and skilled German people-
LOL this is not Hogan's Heros. I am ridiculing Zundel not Germany. It is funny, as I was posting this a friend came over and we started talking about Germany/Holocaust/white power movement and I said to him that about the only thing I agreed with you on was the fact that it was long past the time to stop equating 'Germany' with 'Hitler' and 'The Holocaust'. But Zundel has nothing to do with the industriousness and skill of Germans. This reminds me of the (relatively few) scapegoating blacks who will cry racism if one thinks Micheal Jackson like little boys or OJ Simpsons is a murderer.
I might start a seperate post on this....
About German technological accomplishments? It will be a long post. Here is one of my favorites from modern times:
http://www.aerospace-technology.com/projects/cargolifter/
They are in financial trouble at the moment, hopefully that will be straightened out because the cargo-lifter is just dam cool, it will change cargo transport forever if they ever get a good network going.
Reminder: Anti Zundel does not equal anti-German. Anti-Hitler does not equal anti-German, anti-holocaust denial does not equal anti-German.
FIATLUX
December 10th, 2003, 01:44 PM
Zundel is full of shit.
They are full of shit as well.
...............
But holocaust denial is not a legitimate feild of inquiry, and their inclusion of Zundel into their midst is but one of many clues to this.
...............
LOL this is not Hogan's Heros. I am ridiculing Zundel not Germany. It is funny, as I was posting this a friend came over and we started talking about Germany/Holocaust/white power movement and I said to him that about the only thing I agreed with you on was the fact that it was long past the time to stop equating 'Germany' with 'Hitler' and 'The Holocaust'. But Zundel has nothing to do with the industriousness and skill of Germans. This reminds me of the (relatively few) scapegoating blacks who will cry racism if one thinks Micheal Jackson like little boys or OJ Simpsons is a murderer.
Sorry - I don't watch Hogan's Heros so the reference is somewhat wasted on me....
But lets see if what I deducted is accurate (usually is)...
You don't like Zundel because he is a socalled Revisionist - right ?
And because you do not like him for that you use general ridicule as political tool - like they do on the crazy-box (TV) - not very constructive criticism and not very informative with respect to your real dislikes...
I know's only little about Zundel - but I can deduct that he is in prison and in any case they probably threw him there for political reasons rather than for whatever else he did (no matter what they say - modern goverments lie constantly to their own people)....
If all you need is to ridicule him by repeating his own words - like you say - then I do not understand the seemingly general necessity for having him jailed - see my point ????
I can't say I agree completely with socalled revisionists myself but I got a somewhat different angle to all of this....
You see - I've understood that labeling - like using the word racist - is just another way of gaining power over peoples lives and making it easy for the Feds to ruining peoples lives if they don't like them - You know general name calling and labeling is always a good way when creating public opinions.... So that what's they do....
So You think Revisionists are ridiculous (?) well.. the problem here is not so much if someone like Zundel (who is probably in hard denial) is ridiculous - the real problem is that "revisionist" is also a label applied at will by media and goverments all over the world and that to people also that is a lot different from Zundel.
So you'll have to excuse me but I'll still object to your ridicule....
Your pictures and text were reasonably informative about the UFO stuff I just object to the context...
About German technological accomplishments? It will be a long post.
My sentiment exactly....
FIAT LUX
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 03:52 PM
The first Holocaust Revisionists were not Germans. The first important Holocaust Revisionist was the Frenchman Paul Rassinier, a French history-teacher who had spent time as an inmate in Dora and Buchenwald, and maintained that, contrary to the Allied postwar propaganda, nobody had been gassed at Buchenwald. Since then it has been generally accepted among scholars that there were no gassings in Germany proper, but Rassinier was saying this when it was still very controversial; this means that Rassinier was a Revisionist who was proven right.
Dr. Robert Faurisson was already a famous French scholar of literature, who had taught at the Sorbonne and at the University of Lyon, so that in 1977 when he decided to publish his findings about "The Rumor of Auschwitz," i.e. that there was no evidence that anyone had been gassed there, it was carried as an article (not an op-ed) by France's leading newspaper Le Monde. As of 1999 the Auschwitz Museum has been claiming that Krema I, the brick structure that was shown to tourists since WWII as an authentic homicidal gas-chamber, is a "reconstruction," which means that Faurisson's claim that nobody was gassed in that structure has been accepted, although he rejects that it could be a reconstruction. (Krema I was built as a morgue and is unsuitable as a gas-chamber.)
At about the same time, in the late 70s, Arthur Butz, an American professor of engineering at Northwestern University, published his seminal work The Hoax of the Twentieth Century.
Ernst Zündel, who was following all of these developments, did not become a key figure in Revisionism until the early 80s when he decided to reprint and distribute to people all across Canada the booklet Did Six Million Really Die?, written by an English graduate-student of history, Richard Verrall. Zündel became a central figure in Revisionism of course because he was dragged through a ten-year long series of trials over this booklet, at the insistence of some Canadian Jews. Of course, this kneejerk reaction by those Jews backfired, because Zündel was able to muster expert witnesses who testified that nearly all of the content of Did Six Million Really Die? was accurate.
Subsequently Zündel added an index of errata at the back of his Canadian edition of the booklet, and now the original publisher is offering a new edition that simply has removed the errors from the text, with no adverse effect on the central thesis.
That Hays guy who said that Holocaust Revisionism was not a serious field of scholarly inquiry was just repeating something that some person told him in school. He obviously doesn't know much about the matter or he wouldn't be saying something like that. The fact that Ernst Zündel has no credentials as a scholar is beside the point; his main role has been as a promoter of the works of others, some of whom have credentials that are very impressive indeed.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 04:30 PM
The first Holocaust Revisionists were not Germans. The first important Holocaust Revisionist was the Frenchman Paul Rassinier, a French history-teacher who had spent time as an inmate in Dora and Buchenwald, and maintained that, contrary to the Allied postwar propaganda, nobody had been gassed at Buchenwald. Since then it has been generally accepted among scholars that there were no gassings in Germany proper, but Rassinier was saying this when it was still very controversial; this means that Rassinier was a Revisionist who was proven right.
Dr. Robert Faurisson was already a famous French scholar of literature, who had taught at the Sorbonne and at the University of Lyon, so that in 1977 when he decided to publish his findings about "The Rumor of Auschwitz," i.e. that there was no evidence that anyone had been gassed there, it was carried as an article (not an op-ed) by France's leading newspaper Le Monde. As of 1999 the Auschwitz Museum has been claiming that Krema I, the brick structure that was shown to tourists since WWII as an authentic homicidal gas-chamber, is a "reconstruction," which means that Faurisson's claim that nobody was gassed in that structure has been accepted, although he rejects that it could be a reconstruction. (Krema I was built as a morgue and is unsuitable as a gas-chamber.)
At about the same time, in the late 70s, Arthur Butz, an American professor of engineering at Northwestern University, published his seminal work The Hoax of the Twentieth Century.
Ernst Zündel, who was following all of these developments, did not become a key figure in Revisionism until the early 80s when he decided to reprint and distribute to people all across Canada the booklet Did Six Million Really Die?, written by an English graduate-student of history, Richard Verrall. Zündel became a central figure in Revisionism of course because he was dragged through a ten-year long series of trials over this booklet, at the insistence of some Canadian Jews. Of course, this kneejerk reaction by those Jews backfired, because Zündel was able to muster expert witnesses who testified that nearly all of the content of Did Six Million Really Die? was accurate.
Subsequently Zündel added an index of errata at the back of his Canadian edition of the booklet, and now the original publisher is offering a new edition that simply has removed the errors from the text, with no adverse effect on the central thesis.
That Hays guy who said that Holocaust Revisionism was not a serious field of scholarly inquiry was just repeating something that some person told him in school. He obviously doesn't know much about the matter or he wouldn't be saying something like that. The fact that Ernst Zündel has no credentials as a scholar is beside the point; his main role has been as a promoter of the works of others, some of whom have credentials that are very impressive indeed.
I actually do know quite a bit about holocaust "revisionism". I only apply the term "holocaust denier" to those who repeat absurd and unfounded claims. EZ fits this definition very well. And as for the credentials of the people he cites, there are 10X the credentials in the area of creationist biology, but that does not mean that there is any truth to it, it is a denial feild and the parallels to holocaust denial are obvious. The fact is that there were gas chambers, the Nazis did kill millions of people. Even the Grandaddy of denial himself, David Irving, has abandoned any attempt to stand by his former absurd claims. Take a look at the subjects of the last IHR conference if you do not believe me. I can also show you a quote where he gave his estimates of Jewish deaths at 4 million, which is on the low edge of estimates by real holocaust historians.
I am "Descendant" and "QualifiedEngineer" from Stormfront. Take a look at this thread and you will get an idea of the current state of the holocaust denial movement:
http://www.stormfront.org/forum/showthread.php?t=89577&highlight=holohoax
My posting abilities were blocked on both of those names, effectively banning me, but even after I requested that they ban, they did not. According to JohnJoyTree they took a vote and decided not to. This is obviously to create the illusion that I walked away from the debate. But after you read the thread it will be obvious to you which side walked away due to inability to back up there claims.
luhwind
December 10th, 2003, 05:20 PM
And as for the credentials of the people he cites, there are 10X the credentials in the area of creationist biology, but that does not mean that there is any truth to it, it is a denial feild and the parallels to holocaust denial are obvious.
Creationist biology is, surely, much more popular than jewish holocaust revisionism, and 10x the credentials is probably an understatement. My question is though, can you the muster 10x the credentials for:
The fact is that there were gas chambers,
Factual credentials, naturally, not ADL articles and confessional transcripts...
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 06:07 PM
Creationist biology is, surely, much more popular than jewish holocaust revisionism, and 10x the credentials is probably an understatement. My question is though, can you the muster 10x the credentials for:
Factual credentials, naturally, not ADL articles and confessional transcripts...
Read this for a start:
http://www.stormfront.org/forum/showthread.php?t=89577&highlight=holohoax
Then head over here:
http://www.holocaust-history.org/
See you in six months!
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 07:41 PM
HenryHaysExecutioner fails to deal with the point that I have made, which is that Holocaust Revisionism is indeed a serious field of scholarly enquiry, which is apparent in (1) the scholarly credentials of some leading Revisionists, and (2) the fact that many positions once considered Revisionist are now embraced by mainstream Holocaust scholarship.
HenryHaysExecutioner brings up Creationism, claiming that there are "10x the credentials in the area of creationist biology," compared to the Holocaust Revisionists Rassinier, Faurisson, Verrall, and Butz (who are only a small sampling of notable Revisionist scholars). I do not know the name of any such creationist biologist, nor does HHE name any. I can observe however that there is no effort to persecute and silence creationist biologists (assuming that any such a person exists) whereas an intense persecution of Holocaust Revisionists has been going on for about 25 years. Undoubtedly there would be a lot more people of importance who would endorse the Revisionist position if they could do so without fear for their lives or their careers. No doubt Christopher Hitchens' private acknowledgement a few years ago that the gas-chamber story was a fraud, which Hitchens denied when the statement became public, is only the tip of a very large iceberg of clandestine enlightenment in this subject.
HHE says: "I only apply the term "holocaust denier" to those who repeat absurd and unfounded claims. EZ fits this definition very well." HHE fails to identify any absurd and unfounded claims, nor does he consider that what was absurd and unfounded in 1945 is today accepted as fact. Furthermore, how is it credible to acknowledge the credentials of Professor Faurisson, Professor Butz, etc., but to say that the man carrying their message, Ernst Zündel, is making claims that are absurd and unfounded? You cannot attack the main body of Ernst Zündel's message without ipso facto attacking the findings of Faurisson and Butz. I think it would be difficult to find any important claim about the so-called Holocaust that was made by Ernst Zündel on his own authority. I note again, HHE does not identify any such claim.
HHE proceeds to make a number of assertions which are precisely the claims that are in dispute: "The fact is that there were gas chambers, the Nazis did kill millions of people." Would HHE care to say what evidence there is for those claims? He provides none. While HenryHaysExecutioner throws around the term "holocaust denier," he himself is a baldfaced holocaust asserter, making "absurd and unfounded claims."
HenryHaysExecutioner then uses the common Jewish tactic of dragging in David Irving as an easy target, in spite of the fact that I did not mention Irving as an important Revisionist scholar. To facilitate the use of Irving as a strawman representing all of Holocaust Revisionism, HHE exaggerates Irving's importance, calling him "the Grandaddy of denial himself." David Irving is not the granddaddy of anything. Irving was a latecomer to Revisionism, only concluding after reading the Leuchter Report, which was commissioned on the advice of Professor Robert Faurisson, that indeed the gas-chamber story was a myth. Rassinier was a Revisionist in the 40s and 50s. Professor Faurisson and Professor Butz went public with Revisionist views in the late 70s. David Irving did not recognize that they were correct until the late 80s. So who is the "granddaddy" here? Certainly not David Irving. Irving is built up as the symbol of Revisionism precisely because his commitment to Revisionism is soft and he has tried to back away from some things that he has said in hopes of regaining his career as it once was. In fact Irving has stated that he is not a Revisionist.
Finally, in case David Irving the non-Revisionist was not an adequate strawman, HHE refers me to some no doubt ill-informed posts on Stormfront that are supposed to represent "the current state of the holocaust denial movement." How about if I refer you to some histrionic Jews who claim that they saw soap and lampshades made out of Jews as representing the current state of holocaust assertion? Would that be fair? It would be equivalent.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 08:29 PM
HenryHaysExecutioner fails to deal with the point that I have made, which is that Holocaust Revisionism is indeed a serious field of scholarly enquiry, which is apparent in (1) the scholarly credentials of some leading Revisionists, and (2) the fact that many positions once considered Revisionist are now embraced by mainstream Holocaust scholarship.
This is just simple sematics. The word revisionism has been hijacked by holocaust deniers. Call them what you want. Here is a link that does a good job of explaining the distinction:
http://www.holocaust-history.org/revisionism-isnt/
HenryHaysExecutioner brings up Creationism, claiming that there are "10x the credentials in the area of creationist biology," compared to the Holocaust Revisionists Rassinier, Faurisson, Verrall, and Butz (who are only a small sampling of notable Revisionist scholars). I do not know the name of any such creationist biologist, nor does HHE name any.
Here are the educational qualifications of people associated with the Intelligent Design think-tank Access Research Network.
ARN board of directors:
Dennis Wagner - (?)
Mike Hartwing - Ph.D. Educational Psychology
Steve Meyer - Ph. D. History and Philosophy of Science
Paul Nelson - Ph.D in the Philosophy of Science
ARN Staff:
Dennis Wagner - (?)
Nancy Pearcey - graduate work in History of Philosophy
Mary York Wolter - B.S. Early Childhood Education
Elton G. Wolter - B.S. Earth Science
Eddie Olson (?)
Friends of ARN:
Michael Behe - Ph.D. Biochemistry
David Berlinski - Ph.D. Mathematics
John Angus Campbell - Ph.D. Rhetoric
William Lane Craig - Ph.D. Philosophy and Theology
William Dembski - Ph.D. Mathematics and Philosophy
James R. Hofmann - Ph.D. History and Philosophy of Science
Phil Johnson - J.D.
Eric Larson - B.S. Mathematics and Philosophy
Gregg Wilkerson - Ph.D. Geology
Alvin Plantinga - Ph.D. Philosophy
Richard Weikart - Ph.D. History
Jonathan Wells - Ph.D. Religious Studies and Molecular & Cell Biology
Hubert P. Yockey - Ph.D. Physics
The Institute for Creation Research
So who are the people associated with the ICR? Well, here is the Resident Faculty:
Austin, Steven A. - Professor of Geology
B.S., University of Washington, Seattle, WA,1970
M.S., San Jose State University, San Jose, CA, 1971
Ph.D., Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, 1979
Cumming, Kenneth B. - Professor of Biology
B.S., Tufts University, Medford, MA, 1956
M.A., Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, 1959
Ph.D., Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, 1965
DeYoung, Donald B. - Professor of Astrophysics
B.S., Michigan Technological University, Houghton, Ml, 1966
M.S., Michigan Technological University, Houghton, Ml, 1968
Ph.D., Iowa State University, Ames, IA, 1972
Franks, Robert H. - Associate Professor of Biology
B.A., San Diego State University, San Diego, CA, 1956
M.D., University of California Los Angeles, CA, 1960
Gish, Duane T. - Professor of Biochemistry
B.S., University of California, Los Angeles, CA, 1949
Ph.D., University of California, Berkeley, CA, 1953
Morris, Henry M. - Professor of Hydrogeology
B.S., Rice University, Houston, TX, 1939
M.S., University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, 1948
Ph.D., University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, 1950
Morris, John D. - Professor of Geology
B.S., Virginia Tech., Blacksburg, VA, 1969
M.S., University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK, 1977
Ph.D.. University of Oklahoma, Norman, OK, 1980
Snelling, Andrew - Professor of Geology
B.Sc., University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia, 1975
Ph.D., University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, 1982
Vardiman, Larry - Professor of Atmospheric Science
B.S., University of Missouri, Rolla, MO, 1965
B.S., St. Louis University, St. Louis, MO, 1967
M.S., Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, 1972
Ph.D., Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO, 1974
Here is the Adjunct Faculty:
Baumgardner, John R. - Associate Professor of Geophysics
B.S., Texas Tech University, Lubbock, 1968
M.S., Electrical Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 1970
M.S., Geophysics and Space Physics, University of California, Los Angeles,1981
Ph.D., Geophysics and Space Physics, University of California, Los Angeles, 1983
Carothers, Linn E. - Associate Professor of Statistics
B.S., University of Southern California, University Park, 1973
M.S., California State University, Northridge, 1979
Ph.D., University of Southern California, University Park, 1987
Chaffin, Eugene F. - Professor of Physics
B.S., Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, 1970
M.S., Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, 1972
Ph.D., Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, 1974
Chittick, Donald E. - Professor of Physical Chemistry
B.S., Willamette University, Salem, OR, 1954
Ph.D., Oregon State University, Corvalis, OR, 1960
Deckard, Stephen W. - Assistant Professor of Education
B.A., McKendree College, Lebanon, IL, 1975
M.S., University of Illinois, Champaign, IL, 1979
Ed.D., University of Sarasota, Sarasota, FL, 1986
Englin, Dennis L. - Professor of Geophysics
B.A., Westmont College, Santa Barbara, CA, 1968
M.Sc., California State University, Northridge, CA, 1970
Ed.D., University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, 1975
Faulkner, Danny R. - Associate Professor of Astronomy
B.S., Bob Jones University, Greenville, SC, 1976
M.S., Clemson University, Clemson, SC, 1979
M.A., Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, 1983
Ph.D., Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, 1989
Fliermans, Carl B. - Professor of Biology
B.S., Asbury College, Wilmore, KY, 1966
M.Sc., University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY, 1969
Ph.D., Indiana University, Bloomington, IN, 1972
Humphreys, D. Russell - Associate Professor of Physics
B.S., Duke University, Durham, NC, 1963
Ph.D., Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, 1972
Lindsey, George D. - Associate Professor of Science Education
B.S., East Texas State University, Commerce, TX,1967
M.S., East Texas State University, Commerce, TX, 1968
Ed.D., East Texas State University, Commerce, TX, 1981
Meyer, John R. - Professor of Biology
B.A., Kearney State College, Kearney, NE, 1962
Ph.D., University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA, 1969
Phillips, Doug, Esq. - Professor of Apolgetics
Osborne, Chris D. - Assistant Professor of Biology
B.A., California State University, Fullerton, CA, 1976
M.S., Institute for Creation Research, Santee, CA., 1985
Ph.D., Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA., 1989
Parker, Gary E. - Professor of Biology
B.A., Wabash College, Crawfordville, IN, 1962
M.S., Ball State University, Muncie, IN, 1965
Ed.D., Ball State University, Muncie, IN, 1973
Stark, James - Assistant Professor of Science Education
B.S., San Diego State University, 1959
M.S., University of Southern California, University Park, 1964
Ed.D., United States International University, San Diego, 1983
More here: http://www.icr.org/creationscientists.html
(post too long continued on next post)
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 08:32 PM
I can observe however that there is no effort to persecute and silence creationist biologists (assuming that any such a person exists) whereas an intense persecution of Holocaust Revisionists has been going on for about 25 years.
Baclk to the semantic problem. Do you know of anyone jailed for publication in an academic journal? I don't.
Undoubtedly there would be a lot more people of importance who would endorse the Revisionist position if they could do so without fear for their lives or their careers. No doubt Christopher Hitchens' private acknowledgement a few years ago that the gas-chamber story was a fraud, which Hitchens denied when the statement became public, is only the tip of a very large iceberg of clandestine enlightenment in this subject.
the gas-chamber story was a fraud, Give me a break. I will give you some links. You will find that there is evidence. Forensic, documentary, and testimony from people who were there. You are just repeating denier drivel.
HHE says: "I only apply the term "holocaust denier" to those who repeat absurd and unfounded claims. EZ fits this definition very well." HHE fails to identify any absurd and unfounded claims, nor does he consider that what was absurd and unfounded in 1945 is today accepted as fact. Furthermore, how is it credible to acknowledge the credentials of Professor Faurisson, Professor Butz, etc., but to say that the man carrying their message, Ernst Zündel, is making claims that are absurd and unfounded? You cannot attack the main body of Ernst Zündel's message without ipso facto attacking the findings of Faurisson and Butz. I think it would be difficult to find any important claim about the so-called Holocaust that was made by Ernst Zündel on his own authority. I note again, HHE does not identify any such claim.
Here is a link to a video where he claims that <20,000 Jews died at Auschwitz:
http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/z/zundel-ernst/Zundel-Tsadok-008.html
He cites Irving but Irving himself put his estimate at 4 million BEFORE Zundel made that rediculous comment.
HHE proceeds to make a number of assertions which are precisely the claims that are in dispute: "The fact is that there were gas chambers, the Nazis did kill millions of people." Would HHE care to say what evidence there is for those claims? He provides none. While HenryHaysExecutioner throws around the term "holocaust denier," he himself is a baldfaced holocaust asserter, making "absurd and unfounded claims."
HenryHaysExecutioner then uses the common Jewish tactic of dragging in David Irving as an easy target, in spite of the fact that I did not mention Irving as an important Revisionist scholar.
LOL well you use the common racialist tactic of calling everything Jewish.
To facilitate the use of Irving as a strawman representing all of Holocaust Revisionism, HHE exaggerates Irving's importance, calling him "the Grandaddy of denial himself." David Irving is not the granddaddy of anything. Irving was a latecomer to Revisionism, only concluding after reading the Leuchter Report, which was commissioned on the advice of Professor Robert Faurisson, that indeed the gas-chamber story was a myth. Rassinier was a Revisionist in the 40s and 50s. Professor Faurisson and Professor Butz went public with Revisionist views in the late 70s. David Irving did not recognize that they were correct until the late 80s. So who is the "granddaddy" here? Certainly not David Irving. Irving is built up as the symbol of Revisionism precisely because his commitment to Revisionism is soft and he has tried to back away from some things that he has said in hopes of regaining his career as it once was. In fact Irving has stated that he is not a Revisionist.
I call him the grandaddy because he is almost always the first person that people cite when I strart these discussions with them. You are right that he was not the first. But I think he is the most well known, and that is what I meant, poor choice of words I guess. And Luetcher is a fraud. He does not know what the hell he is doing and he represented himself as someone who does:
http://www.holocaust-history.org/auschwitz/chemistry/blue/
Finally, in case David Irving the non-Revisionist was not an adequate strawman, HHE refers me to some no doubt ill-informed posts on Stormfront that are supposed to represent "the current state of the holocaust denial movement." How about if I refer you to some histrionic Jews who claim that they saw soap and lampshades made out of Jews as representing the current state of holocaust assertion? Would that be fair? It would be equivalent.
What I meant by that is that as far as I know there isn't really much 'work' going on in the denier circles, and the earlier works have been refuted, but people continue to cite them again and again. On SF Jackboot was very eager to debate me, he even took me off of moderation to do so, saying that he thought of himself as "somewhat of a revisionist", then, after I made him look stupid, he or another moderator locked the thread and disabled my posting.
Here read this part carefully I think it will clear up some misunderstandings we have:
First I am not Jewish. Second the holocaust is not holy to me, meaning it is not untouchable. When I first (about a year ago) saw the assertions on Stormfront and elsewhere that the gas chambers were a hoax, that the numbers of victims had been exagerated greatly, I was nuetral on the issue, I went to look for myself. There was no reason in my mind that these assertions could not be true. I was nuetral on the issue but I was also a skeptic, in general, about everything, so I had some familiarity with denial tactics, the art of the half truth. The same tactics are used to deny everything from the moon landing to the round Earth. But I was not even thinking in those terms at first, I THOUGHT I was reading credible historians.
What I am saying is that every link, every bit of so-called evidence that I was given, set off alarm bells fairly quickly in my skeptical mind. Red flags everywhere. The deniers pointed out small things that were incorrect in suvivor testimony, or mistakes that historians had made as much as 60 years before. This was their so-called evidence. But when I looked into their own claims I found that they were changing them from day to day practically. In short, they had invented an entire new standard of proof and were applying it ONLY to the holocaust. They did not apply it to themselves even. They were free to make mistakes or change their story but whenever a historian or survivor did the same it was 'proof' of some big conspiracy. In short the whole movement was completely deviod of intellectual honesty, the most important quality of a scientist.
So I do not consider someone a holocaust denier because of their conclusions. If you give me a link to someone who's work I have not examined I will judge it for the work and not assume that it is wrong based on the conclusions. But you have to understand that I HAVE developed a bit of a prejudice, that is just human nature. If the person you cite claims that only 500,000 Jews died in WWII I will naturally prejudge that, because of what I have already seen. But I try my best to keep MY intellectual honesty, I will review the material just as I did Irving and Zundel and Luetcher and John Ball and Carlos Porter and David Cole and all of the others I have found to be full of it. But I have done ALOT of reading on this, and every single person I have read who is called a denier by holocaust historians I have found to be deserving of the title.
http://www.holocaust-history.org/
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 08:39 PM
None of that UFO stuff that Zündel published in the 70s under a pseudonym has any bearing on the validity of Holocaust Revisionism.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 09:02 PM
None of that UFO stuff that Zündel published in the 70s under a pseudonym has any bearing on the validity of Holocaust Revisionism.
Sure it does, it shows that he is full of it and it shows that those that include him in their feild are including somone who is full of it. It is simple: no legitimate feild of inquiry would accept a proponent of hollow earth theory or Nazi UFO's into their midst. Not a problem for Holocaust denial because it does not look for any kind of credibility, it looks for follower, believers. Their contentions are ones that have to be believed to be seen.
And it isn't like this is some stuff that Zundel just published in the 70's, go to Rense.com and search for Zundel+UFO, you should find an Zundel interview from the last year or two about his UFO nonsense.
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 09:17 PM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I said: HenryHaysExecutioner then uses the common Jewish tactic of dragging in David Irving as an easy target, in spite of the fact that I did not mention Irving as an important Revisionist scholar.
HHE said: LOL well you use the common racialist tactic of calling everything Jewish.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
It happens to be a form of propaganda that I have seen before, used by Jews. This business of exaggerating the importance of David Irving within Revisionism is rooted in the fact that Irving waffled on the facts when he sued Deborah Lipstadt a few years ago. Irving refused assistance from solid Revisionists like Professor Faurisson because he did not wish to appear as a Revisionist himself. Nonetheless you and every other Holocaust Assertor find it useful to make Irving the favorite whipping boy and to make him into the very symbol of an intellectual movement in which he never had more than one foot.
It's dishonest.
By the way, I looked briefly at that thread on Stormfront, and MuadDib was right, there was no reason to believe that a photo showing emaciated children was an authentic representation of children subjected to medical experiments at Auschwitz. There is indeed nothing in the photo that indicates medical experiments, only emaciation. I doubt that the photo was even taken at Auschwitz as the caption claims. There are no photos of emaciated people at Auschwitz as far as I know; more likely the photo was taken at one of the concentration camps in Germany proper, to which inmates were evacuated from Auschwitz, and where there was terrible overcrowding and a typhus epidemic (which causes emaciation) at the very end of the war.
If you have never seen any exposition of photographs that have been altered to support the Holohoax I suggest that you visit http://www.air-photo.com where John Ball exposes a number of such photos.
I don't have time right now to wade through all the BS that you pretend to want me to look at. Suffice it to say that the Holocaust asserters have been retreating, retreating, retreating. Nobody is claimed to have been gassed in Germany proper as was claimed in 1945, and since 1999 the alleged homicidal gas-chamber shown to tourists at Auschwitz is no longer claimed to be authentic. If indeed anything is currently left of this Jewish genocide-fable, its past does not bode well for its future.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 09:41 PM
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I said: HenryHaysExecutioner then uses the common Jewish tactic of dragging in David Irving as an easy target, in spite of the fact that I did not mention Irving as an important Revisionist scholar.
HHE said: LOL well you use the common racialist tactic of calling everything Jewish.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
It happens to be a form of propaganda that I have seen before, used by Jews. This business of exaggerating the importance of David Irving within Revisionism is rooted in the fact that Irving waffled on the facts when he sued Deborah Lipstadt a few years ago. Irving refused assistance from solid Revisionists like Professor Faurisson because he did not wish to appear as a Revisionist himself. Nonetheless you and every other Holocaust Assertor find it useful to make Irving the favorite whipping boy and to make him into the very symbol of an intellectual movement in which he never had more than one foot.
It's dishonest.
By the way, I looked briefly at that thread on Stormfront, and MuadDib was right, there was no reason to believe that a photo showing emaciated children was an authentic representation of children subjected to medical experiments at Auschwitz. There is indeed nothing in the photo that indicates medical experiments, only emaciation. I doubt that the photo was even taken at Auschwitz as the caption claims. There are no photos of emaciated people at Auschwitz as far as I know; more likely the photo was taken at one of the concentration camps in Germany proper, to which inmates were evacuated from Auschwitz, and where there was terrible overcrowding and a typhus epidemic (which causes emaciation) at the very end of the war.
If you have never seen any exposition of photographs that have been altered to support the Holohoax I suggest that you visit http://www.air-photo.com where John Ball exposes a number of such photos.
I don't have time right now to wade through all the BS that you pretend to want me to look at. Suffice it to say that the Holocaust asserters have been retreating, retreating, retreating. Nobody is claimed to have been gassed in Germany proper as was claimed in 1945, and since 1999 the alleged homicidal gas-chamber shown to tourists at Auschwitz is no longer claimed to be authentic. If indeed anything is currently left of this Jewish genocide-fable, its past does not bode well for its future.
Jon Ball is probably the biggest joke in the holocaust denial indusry besides Zundel (and maybe Luetcher)
http://www.holocaust-history.org/auschwitz/john-ball/
Some of his claims have been looked at by a REAL air photo expert from the JPL, which was a bad day from John Ball. The funniest is when Ball was testifying in court one time. He had the very bad luck to get a judge that had overseen a trial where a real air photo analysist had testified. Being a good smart judge, the judge familiarised himself with the feild of air photo analysis. He actually knew far more about the feild that John Ball. The judge was pissed that Ball was trying to pull the wool over his eyes and messed with him from the bench a bit:
Ball was finally rejected as a witness by Judge Thomas after he testified on the voir dire. Thomas agreed that the aerial photos were proper evidence for the defense to introduce, but concluded, after some reflection, that Ball was not sufficiently qualified as an expert to do the job.
Ball had the remarkably bad luck to be cross-examined not only by Pearson [the prosecuting attorney] but (informally) by a judge who admitted that he once tried a case where, for two months, the finer points of aerial photography were debated. Before admitting this, however, Thomas had a little fun with Ball (and the rest of the court) by suddenly peppering him with questions like, "Have you ever presented or formulated a horizontal model? In the horizontal plane?" and "Have you developed a computer-assisted vertical plane with the benefit of photogrammetry?" So sophisticated and assured was this technical questioning that it looked like Toronto had an unsung Leonardo da Vinci in robes until Thomas's explanation was forthcoming.
As Christie tried to save his witness, he jettisoned one line of potential questioning after another until there was little left for poor Ball to have said. [...]
Ball was finally stripped almost bare, but it was not enough to save him. Judge Thomas, flaunting his knowledge, was especially concerned that Ball had indicated several times that "as far as he is concerned [a micro-stereoscope and a stereoscope] are the same thing. They aren't the same."
These are common denier tactics that they are using here, whether unwittingly or not: You expect all historians to agree throughout all time, even right after the war in 1945, but you conveniently overlook the mistakes and ommisions of those who's conclusion you want to see.
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 09:49 PM
Sure it does, it shows that he is full of it and it shows that those that include him in their feild are including somone who is full of it. It is simple: no legitimate feild of inquiry would accept a proponent of hollow earth theory or Nazi UFO's into their midst. Not a problem for Holocaust denial because it does not look for any kind of credibility, it looks for follower, believers. Their contentions are ones that have to be believed to be seen.
And it isn't like this is some stuff that Zundel just published in the 70's, go to Rense.com and search for Zundel+UFO, you should find an Zundel interview from the last year or two about his UFO nonsense.
Does this mean that Isaac Newton was not a good physicist because he believed in astrology? The truth is that if such standards prevailed in the world, no Holocaust-believer would be accepted among reputable scholars of any kind. The Holocaust is the crackpot notion par excellence of our age.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 10th, 2003, 09:53 PM
Does this mean that Isaac Newton was not a good physicist because he believed in astrology? The truth is that if such standards prevailed in the world, no Holocaust-believer would be accepted among reputable scholars of any kind. The Holocaust is the crackpot notion par excellence of our age.
Shining example of circular logic.
Hadding
December 10th, 2003, 10:23 PM
If I recall correctly, Jamie McCarthy, who wrote that piece which purports to debunk John Ball's credentials, lives in British Columbia where, at least a few years ago, the telephone-number through which one was supposed to be able to contact him actually belonged to a synagogue.
I browsed at the piece quickly. What it seems to show mostly is the bias of Judge Thomas, who boasts of having read Michael Shermer's attack on John Ball. John Ball's training as an air-photo analyst is also mentioned in that piece.
In any case, John Ball's expertise is not especially relevant. I was not citing him as an authority, just referring you to some doctored Holocaust-propaganda photos that happen to be conveniently displayed on his website. It does not require a lot of faith in Ball's expertise to look at those photos and see that they are doctored.
For example, a few years ago Ball's website showed a doctored photo from the Simon Wiesenthal website alongside the original undoctored version. The doctored photo contained an enormous cloud of smoke billowing out of ... a fencepost, which, well, was in the background and sort of looked like a smokestack. Why don't you have a look and see if Ball is still showing that one?
Brock Landers
December 10th, 2003, 10:39 PM
Hadding is kicking mucho ass!
Brock
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
The REAL holocaust was:
The historic growth rate of the Christian population of 1.5% per year means that the 682,400,000 Christians in the world in 1933 would have been 853,158,362 by 1948. Instead, mostly due to WWII, the actual population was 592,406,542, a loss of 260,751,820 Christians. Even at a more conservative growth rate of Christians of 1% per year, there were 199,838,673 fewer Christians in 1948 than there would have been without WWII.
What about the population of jews? Per World Almanac figures, it INCREASED by 412,279 between 1940 and 1949!
Meyers Handlexicon, Germany 1921 -- 11,600,000
World Almanac, 1925, pg. 752 -- 15,630,000, "In 1925 a census of Palestine gave a total of 115,151 Jews"
World Almanac, 1929, pg. 727 -- 15,630,000
National Council of Churches 1930 -- 15,600 ,000
March 24, 1933, jewish newspaper Daily Express -- 14,000,000 jews worldwide
World Almanac, 1933, pg. 419 -- 15,316,359, ["The estimate for Jews in the above table is for 1933, and is by the American Jewish Committee"
American Jewish Committee Bureau of the Synagogue Council, 1939 -- 15,600,000
World Almanac, 1936, pg. 748 -- 15,753,633
World Almanac, 1940, pg. 129: World Jewish Population -- 15,319,359
World Almanac, 1941, pg. 510: World Jewish Population -- 15,748,091
World Almanac, 1942, pg. -- 15,192,089, "Jews include Jews by race not necessarily by religion"
World Almanac USA, 1947, pg. 748: World Jewish Population -- 15,690,000
World Almanac, 1949, pg. 289: World Jewish Population -- 15,713,638
Statistical Handbook of Council of Churches USA 1951 -- 15,300,000
Encyclopedia Britannica's 1955 Book of the Year -- 11,627,450, "Jewish figures include all Jews whether members of a synagogue or not"
World Almanac, US News & World Report, 1983 population of jews -- 16,820,850
World Almanac, 1996, pg. 646: World Jewish Population -- 14,117,000
World Almanac & Book of Facts, 1989: World Jewish Population --18,080,000
World Almanac & Book of Facts, 2001: World Jewish Population -- 13,200,000
Roy Batty
December 10th, 2003, 10:53 PM
Ignore jewish population numbers furnished by jews. There are probably twice as many of them in the world than is claimed.
As far as the Holohoax goes, that story is losing its strength as a pillar of jewish power anyway. Whether people believe in the fairy tale or not, they are starting to wonder out loud why crap from 60 years ago should give jews preference in so many areas. That's what bothers the zhids more than revisionism or outright denial. It's interesting that several times in my life jews have told me that they knew that 6 million didn't die in the "Holocaust(tm)". The first time this happened, I was young and "unaware", suprised that someone, especially a jew would say such a thing. Years later, I was totally aware of the fraud perpetrated on the West, and a jew where I used to work said the same thing. That time I just nodded in agreement. Of course, since this jew would remark on the hypocrisy of "jewish law", he would be explained away as a "self hating jew" by ... hateful jews.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 11th, 2003, 05:20 AM
If I recall correctly, Jamie McCarthy, who wrote that piece which purports to debunk John Ball's credentials, lives in British Columbia where, at least a few years ago, the telephone-number through which one was supposed to be able to contact him actually belonged to a synagogue.
So what?
I browsed at the piece quickly. What it seems to show mostly is the bias of Judge Thomas, who boasts of having read Michael Shermer's attack on John Ball. John Ball's training as an air-photo analyst is also mentioned in that piece.
In any case, John Ball's expertise is not especially relevant. I was not citing him as an authority, just referring you to some doctored Holocaust-propaganda photos that happen to be conveniently displayed on his website. It does not require a lot of faith in Ball's expertise to look at those photos and see that they are doctored.
For example, a few years ago Ball's website showed a doctored photo from the Simon Wiesenthal website alongside the original undoctored version.
The doctored photo contained an enormous cloud of smoke billowing out of ... a fencepost, which, well, was in the background and sort of looked like a smokestack. Why don't you have a look and see if Ball is still showing that one?
I have seen the photo you are talking about and I just found it again. First of all I see no evidence that John Ball himself did not alter that photo. The one on the S.W. site now is the original one. If it was indeed altered it is obvious it was done by a flunky because that does not even look like smoke. My first impression is a water stain or something. If that photo was indeed doctored and then displayed by Simon Wiesenthal website, your contention is then what? What does that prove is someone airbrushed some smoke into a picture and then published that picture on a website? Any kind of patern here? Any other doctored photos? None that I know of. And I have been through John Ball's 'work' end to end. Like I said a JPL scientist reviewed Ball's analysis of the fences supposedly drawn in by the CIA and found that they were not doctored. Like Luetcher he made uninformed assumtions. He saw what looked like a fence in two different places on two photos that the CIA had doctored the photos at the behest of the Grand Jewish Conspiracy. To him, for some reason, that was a more reasonable conclusion than the idea that the fences could have been moved. (They were not for any other reason than to obscure vision so they did not need to be sunk into the ground, just some sticks and brush) If the photo was doctored all it proves is the need to be more skeptical of the SW website. Historians don't use the SW website.
Ball's qualifications ARE important. Yes if his work is up to the standards of the pros then that is more important than any paper credintials, but it is not up to any kind of standards. So unless you want to hire a REAL photo anylist to confirm his newest contentions, the only reasonable conclusion is that he has been shown to be unreliable and unqualified in the area of air photo analysis, and there is no reason to expect that what he prints is of any value. And yes you need to pay for it, because historians do not owe John Ball any more of an explanation than NASA owes the Moon Hoax crowd.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 11th, 2003, 05:34 AM
What about the population of jews? Per World Almanac figures, it INCREASED by 412,279 between 1940 and 1949!
Meyers Handlexicon, Germany 1921 -- 11,600,000
World Almanac, 1925, pg. 752 -- 15,630,000, "In 1925 a census of Palestine gave a total of 115,151 Jews"
World Almanac, 1929, pg. 727 -- 15,630,000
National Council of Churches 1930 -- 15,600 ,000
March 24, 1933, jewish newspaper Daily Express -- 14,000,000 jews worldwide
World Almanac, 1933, pg. 419 -- 15,316,359, ["The estimate for Jews in the above table is for 1933, and is by the American Jewish Committee"
American Jewish Committee Bureau of the Synagogue Council, 1939 -- 15,600,000
World Almanac, 1936, pg. 748 -- 15,753,633
World Almanac, 1940, pg. 129: World Jewish Population -- 15,319,359
World Almanac, 1941, pg. 510: World Jewish Population -- 15,748,091
World Almanac, 1942, pg. -- 15,192,089, "Jews include Jews by race not necessarily by religion"
World Almanac USA, 1947, pg. 748: World Jewish Population -- 15,690,000
World Almanac, 1949, pg. 289: World Jewish Population -- 15,713,638
Statistical Handbook of Council of Churches USA 1951 -- 15,300,000
Encyclopedia Britannica's 1955 Book of the Year -- 11,627,450, "Jewish figures include all Jews whether members of a synagogue or not"
World Almanac, US News & World Report, 1983 population of jews -- 16,820,850
World Almanac, 1996, pg. 646: World Jewish Population -- 14,117,000
World Almanac & Book of Facts, 1989: World Jewish Population --18,080,000
World Almanac & Book of Facts, 2001: World Jewish Population -- 13,200,000
I bet if you think real hard to can think of the reason that many Jews hid the fact that they were Jewsih in the years leading up to WWII and were not counted as Jews. Hint, his initials are AH. I bet you can also think of a reason many who did not even consider themselves to be Jews might have identified themselves as Jews post WWII. Hint: $. Hint: respect gained from being a 'survivor'. The figures of roughly 4-7 million are based on the Nazi's own deportation records added to the deaths of those killed by the Eisengruppen.
ophiuroid
December 11th, 2003, 08:26 AM
Shining example of circular logic.
You have ignored Mr Hadding's question - "Does this mean that Isaac Newton was not a good physicist because he believed in astrology"?
If Zundel's claims about flying saucers means that "it shows that he is full of it", then what about Isaac Newton?
Hadding
December 11th, 2003, 11:56 AM
The altered photograph, which shows a billowing cloud of smoke coming out of a fencepost (that sort of looks like a distant smokestack) was posted on the Simon Wiesenthal website circa 1998.
A water stain? And it just happened to be a water-stain billowing out of something vaguely resembling a smokestack? And you mean to telll me that the experts at the Simon Wesenthal Center couldn't tell that a photo that they were goig to post on their website had a huge "water stain" on it? You are out of your flaming mind.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 11th, 2003, 02:38 PM
The altered photograph, which shows a billowing cloud of smoke coming out of a fencepost (that sort of looks like a distant smokestack) was posted on the Simon Wiesenthal website circa 1998.
Any proof other than "John Ball said so"?
A water stain? And it just happened to be a water-stain billowing out of something vaguely resembling a smokestack?
It sure doesnt look like smoke, if it was a doctor job it was a piss poor one.
And you mean to telll me that the experts at the Simon Wesenthal Center couldn't tell that a photo that they were goig to post on their website had a huge "water stain" on it? You are out of your flaming mind.
Who says that they posted it other than John Ball? It doesn't seem very plausible that the SW center leaders ordered a photo to be altered and published when the original was in a book that was avaiable to so many people. If it was altered (and I see no proof of this) it was probly some overeager flunky that they were using to build the website.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 11th, 2003, 02:44 PM
You have ignored Mr Hadding's question - "Does this mean that Isaac Newton was not a good physicist because he believed in astrology"?
If Zundel's claims about flying saucers means that "it shows that he is full of it", then what about Isaac Newton?
It was Newton's theories that eventaully led to the demise of Astrology as an accepted "science". In that day it was not well known that Astrology was a load of crap. Today it is well known that Nazi UFO's and hollow earth theories are bullshit. Science has advanced a bit since Newton's time in case you hadn't noticed.
Hadding
December 11th, 2003, 08:33 PM
Ernst Zündel is a great man beloved by many people, and one day his sacrifice for the sake of his people's honor and historical truth will be much more widely and openly appreciated than it is today.
I don't feel the need to answer Henry Hays Executioner anymore. He is too damned silly!
Hadding
December 11th, 2003, 08:35 PM
It was Newton's theories that eventaully led to the demise of Astrology as an accepted "science". In that day it was not well known that Astrology was a load of crap. Today it is well known that Nazi UFO's and hollow earth theories are bullshit. Science has advanced a bit since Newton's time in case you hadn't noticed.
Ernst doesn't believe in any hollow earth theory. (fyi to the readers.)
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 11th, 2003, 10:07 PM
Ernst Zündel is a great man beloved by many people, and one day his sacrifice for the sake of his people's honor and historical truth will be much more widely and openly appreciated than it is today.
I don't feel the need to answer Henry Hays Executioner anymore. He is too damned silly!
What has he done that makes him so great? Lie to people and play the victim role for every cent that it is worth?
Ernst doesn't believe in any hollow earth theory. (fyi to the readers.)
He doesn't? So he was basically lying and taking advantage of gullible people to make a few bucks when he published that crap? That sounds about right. Ditto with his holocaust "work".
ophiuroid
December 11th, 2003, 11:55 PM
It was Newton's theories that eventaully led to the demise of Astrology as an accepted "science". In that day it was not well known that Astrology was a load of crap. Today it is well known that Nazi UFO's and hollow earth theories are bullshit. Science has advanced a bit since Newton's time in case you hadn't noticed.
You are not answering the question.
Does a belief in astrology make Newton a bad physicist?
If not, then what you are saying is illogical.
Claims about Nazi UFOs have nothing to do with the "holocaust".
Hadding
December 12th, 2003, 02:41 AM
What has he done that makes him so great? Lie to people and play the victim role for every cent that it is worth?
He doesn't? So he was basically lying and taking advantage of gullible people to make a few bucks when he published that crap? That sounds about right. Ditto with his holocaust "work".
The UFO stuff was tongue-in-cheek. Does that really need to be explained, for crying out loud? I mean, he was selling UFO-frisbees with swastikas on them: how seriously would any reasonable person take that?
I had a conversation with Zündel about that book once. He told me that it although people were buying the book for the UFO angle, when they read it they got a good dose of history about the NSDAP. The UFO angle was a gimmick.
Hadding
December 12th, 2003, 02:49 PM
I bet if you think real hard to can think of the reason that many Jews hid the fact that they were Jewsih in the years leading up to WWII and were not counted as Jews. Hint, his initials are AH. I bet you can also think of a reason many who did not even consider themselves to be Jews might have identified themselves as Jews post WWII. Hint: $. Hint: respect gained from being a 'survivor'. The figures of roughly 4-7 million are based on the Nazi's own deportation records added to the deaths of those killed by the Eisengruppen.
Many Jews hid the fact that they were Jews after the war. There is a documentary called In Our Own Hands: The Hidden Story of the Jewish Brigade in World War II. In this documentary, about a group of Jews from Palestine who were allowed to form a special all-Jewish unit in the British Army, there is talk about looking for Jewish survivors after WWII. According to the documentary, members of the Jewish Brigade who went to displaced-person camps asking for Jews were told that they were none, but when they went inside, the place was full of Jews. Why? Because they were not listed as Jews; they were only listed according to their country of citizenship.
It is also true that Jews behind the Iron Curtain had a strong incentive to play down their Jewishness, because it was hard to reconcile with the Communist pretense that all are simply human beings, and because it was better to conceal the disproportionate presence of Jews in positions of power under Communism. John Sack, in An Eye for an Eye, reveals that the people whom Stalin put in power in Poland were Jews calling themselves Polish.
This HenryHaysExecutioner nut is the first one that I have seen to suggest that more Jews were concealing their ethnicity before the war than after, which seems to presuppose widespread foreknowledge, years before it happened, that Hitler was going to overrun nearly all of Europe, and that his policy toward the Jews would then become substantially more hostile than it had been.
Incidentally the biggest concentration of Jews in Europe was in territory under Soviet control from 1939-1941, especially in eastern Poland. After war broke out between Germany and the USSR most of those Jews were evacuated deep inside the Soviet Union. Walter Sanning's book The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry discusses this, but the fact that the heaviest concentration of European Jews was in the Soviet-controlled half of Poland is a demographic fact that you can get from many sources. Why would all those Jews stay behind in eastern Poland waiting for Hitler's forces if as HenryHaysExecutioner claims, they knew years in advance that it would be very bad for them?
The longer HenryHaysExecutioner tries to uphold the Holohoax the more absurdities he creates. This is no doubt the real reason why Deborah Lipstadt urges her fellow Jews not to tolerate debate on the subject.
Hadding
December 12th, 2003, 03:06 PM
Our resident Holocaust-propagandist, HenryHaysExecutioner, wrote: "The figures of roughly 4-7 million are based on the Nazi's own deportation records added to the deaths of those killed by the Eisengruppen."
My simple answer:
1. Deportation records are not death-records.
2. The Einsatzgruppen, if that's what the he means by "Eisengruppen," were assigned to suppress guerrilla activity behind the German lines on the Eastern Front, which was primarily coming from Jews, perhaps the only ethnic group in eastern Europe that did not generally regard the German advance as a liberation. It is not reasonable to refer to these efforts to suppress guerrilla activity as acts genocide per se.
I expect that this HenryHaysExecutioner guy will keep this up ad infinitum until everybody gets tired of telling him obvious facts, like "Deportation records are not death-records," and then when everybody is too bored to argue with him anymore he will go into another forum telling people how he beat us all in this debate.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 13th, 2003, 01:56 AM
Our resident Holocaust-propagandist, HenryHaysExecutioner, wrote: "The figures of roughly 4-7 million are based on the Nazi's own deportation records added to the deaths of those killed by the Eisengruppen."
My simple answer:
1. Deportation records are not death-records.
2. The Einsatzgruppen, if that's what the he means by "Eisengruppen," were assigned to suppress guerrilla activity behind the German lines on the Eastern Front, which was primarily coming from Jews, perhaps the only ethnic group in eastern Europe that did not generally regard the German advance as a liberation. It is not reasonable to refer to these efforts to suppress guerrilla activity as acts genocide per se.
I expect that this HenryHaysExecutioner guy will keep this up ad infinitum until everybody gets tired of telling him obvious facts, like "Deportation records are not death-records," and then when everybody is too bored to argue with him anymore he will go into another forum telling people how he beat us all in this debate.
Call it what you want the Einsatzgruppen killed 1.5 million Jews. And just because Jews were not listed as Jews at one or the other displaced persons camp does not mean that they were not counted in this or that factbook. No-one ever said all the Jews in Poland were killed but about 2.5 million were:
Lukas, Richard C., Forgotten Holocaust: The Poles Under German Occupation 1939-1944., Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, (1986), pp. 38-39. (The source that Lukas cites for those figures is
Nurowski, Roman, 1939-1945: War Losses in Poland., Poznan: Wydawnictwo Zachodnie, 1960, p. 44ff.)
Of course the demographics are not perfect. They may have well overcounted Jews. But I have yet to see an honest attempt by the revisionist crowd to refute these works and give numbers of their own. (Irving tackled the question once in an interview, and gave a number of 4 million in the concentration camps alone)
It all adds up Hadding. No matter how long you hunt for small inconsistencies and misrepresentations. The evidence stands and I have reviewed much of it. Motive and method it is all there. The Einsatzgruppen sent back reports, you know, there are plans for the gas chambers you know. You know all those SS men in the trials never spoke about some big Jewish conspiracy to make up stories of gas chambers. It is just too hard to believe that every last one of those men went to their graves without once exposing this grand conspiracy. To think this is a big hoax you really have to give Jews omnipotent powers or something, make them the pilots of Zundels UFO's so they can go around abducting people and altering their memories.
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 09:02 AM
Call it what you want the Einsatzgruppen killed 1.5 million Jews. And just because Jews were not listed as Jews at one or the other displaced persons camp does not mean that they were not counted in this or that factbook. No-one ever said all the Jews in Poland were killed but about 2.5 million were:
Lukas, Richard C., Forgotten Holocaust: The Poles Under German Occupation 1939-1944., Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, (1986), pp. 38-39. (The source that Lukas cites for those figures is
Nurowski, Roman, 1939-1945: War Losses in Poland., Poznan: Wydawnictwo Zachodnie, 1960, p. 44ff.)
Of course the demographics are not perfect. They may have well overcounted Jews. But I have yet to see an honest attempt by the revisionist crowd to refute these works and give numbers of their own. (Irving tackled the question once in an interview, and gave a number of 4 million in the concentration camps alone)
It all adds up Hadding. No matter how long you hunt for small inconsistencies and misrepresentations. The evidence stands and I have reviewed much of it. Motive and method it is all there. The Einsatzgruppen sent back reports, you know, Yothere are plans for the gas chambers you know. know all those SS men in the trials never spoke about some big Jewish conspiracy to make up stories of gas chambers. It is just too hard to believe that every last one of those men went to their graves without once exposing this grand conspiracy. To think this is a big hoax you really have to give Jews omnipotent powers or something, make them the pilots of Zundels UFO's so they can go around abducting people and altering their memories.
This HenryHaysExecutioner guy cannot seem to get away from using David Irving as a source. Incidentally, HenryHaysExecutioner is misrepresenting David Irving by attributing the figure of "4 million in the concentration camps alone." This is from Irving's own website:
Mr Rampton asked him: "Do you accept that the Nazis killed by one means or another - murdered, hanged, put to death - millions of people during World War II?" "Yes," Mr Irving said. "I hesitate to speculate. It was certainly more than one million, certainly less than four million." Mr Rampton: "Do you deny the Nazis killed millions of Jews in gas chambers in purpose-built establishments?"
Mr Irving: "Yes, it's logistically impossible." He added: "One million people weigh 100,000 tonnes - it's a major logistical problem. I deny that it was possible to liquidate millions of people in gas chambers as presented by historians so far."
("Irving says Holocaust 'logistically impossible'" BY MICHAEL HORSNELL
http://fpp.co.uk/docs/press/items/Times130100.html
There have been a number of people who were present in concentration camps during World War II who have said that the stories told about them were not true. For example: Paul Rassinier, Thies Christopherson.
And by the way, it doesn't "all add up." Sure it all adds up if you make up the numbers as you go. That is essentially what has been done. Circa 1989 Yehuda Bauer of the Yad Vachem Holohoax Museum in Yisrael complained that the death-figures claimed at various sites in Europe were grossly exaggerated and did not add up to the magic 6 million figure. (You can find that in the New York Times.) Subsequently the numbers claimed to have been killed in various locations were drastically reduced. The official death-toll for Auschwitz was reduced from 4 million to somewhere over one-million in 1992. This means that the 4 million figure claimed for Auschwitz was based on what? So how is the new figure more reliable?
Show me an alleged plan for a homicidal gas-chamber that has been posted online. Let's have a look at it and see if the representation is credible.
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 09:16 AM
[QUOTE=HenryHaysExecutioner]Call it what you want the Einsatzgruppen killed 1.5 million Jews. And just because Jews were not listed as Jews at one or the other displaced persons camp does not mean that they were not counted in this or that factbook. No-one ever said all the Jews in Poland were killed but about 2.5 million were:
Lukas, Richard C., Forgotten Holocaust: The Poles Under German Occupation 1939-1944., Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, (1986), pp. 38-39. (The source that Lukas cites for those figures is
Nurowski, Roman, 1939-1945: War Losses in Poland., Poznan: Wydawnictwo Zachodnie, 1960, p. 44ff.)
QUOTE]
So then your source is ultimately Communist. More importantly, the source used by a mainstream historian is Communist. That kind of credulity toward Communist sources should go a long way toward explaining how the Holohoax as a hoax has been able to survive.
The Communists benefited greatly from the Holohoax because it allowed their system to look more tolerable by comparison.
jack_boot
December 13th, 2003, 09:00 PM
On the SF thread that HHE constantly alludes to, you will find that he claims three separate times that David Irving was the author of the Nazi UFO book, in an effort to discredit Mr. Irving.
He didn't back off until I called him on it.
As Hadding has pointed out here, HHE does not hesitate to misrepresent Mr. Irving's actual testimony at the Lipstadt trial, not to mention the historian's actual involvement in the Revisionist field, which is practically nil. Mr. Irving simply states that the available evidence contradicts the Six Million story, and that said story is bunko.
Even the most conservative skeptic has to admit that the Holocaust story has more holes than a Swiss cheese, and as Finkelstein notes with bitter sarcasm in his book The Holocaust Industry, as the holo-historians correct themselves again and again and again, as they readjust their estimates, as they equivocate, as they withdraw allegations such as famously done concerning Dachau, their numbers are rapidly converging on the Revisionists' numbers. And while we're on the subject of Dachau HHE here also claimed that Dachau was a death camp, where 200 thousand jews were done in...until I called him on it.
As for Nazi UFO's, Ernst Zundel has always been a lot of fun, with a weird sense of humor by all accounts (note the trademark blue hardhat); but if he's full of it, he sure as hell ain't the only one, HHE.
jack_boot
December 13th, 2003, 09:23 PM
Call it what you want the Einsatzgruppen killed 1.5 million Jews.
That is ridiculous. The Einsatzgruppen were commissioned to execute the commissars in occupied Soviet territory. No way they machine-gunned 1.5 million people.
Of course the demographics are not perfect. They may have well overcounted Jews.
You can say that again.
But I have yet to see an honest attempt by the revisionist crowd to refute these works and give numbers of their own.
Right, there's maybe one revisionist scholar for every thousand orthodox believers, claimants, and propagandists scribing away in the Holocaust Industry - hereinafter referred to as Shoah Business.
It all adds up Hadding. No matter how long you hunt for small inconsistencies and misrepresentations.
Small inconsistencies like, for example, no human remains at Treblinka? Misrepresentations like, for example, one holo-historian claiming the post-war site was littered with carnage while another claimed Treblinka had been obliterated and disguised as a farm? While yet a third, the famous Polish commission including "historian" Rachel Auerbach, made both claims?
What did all those jews at Treblinka die of, HHE? What was the murder weapon? Have you decided yet? What was the ruling of the judge at Nuremberg as to the manner of execution? I'll give you a hint: his name was Musmano. Look it up.
Steam chambers, HHE? Electric plates? Vacuum chambers? Zyklon gas? Exhaust gas? All of the above? Because ALL the above was somberly accounted in sworn testimony to the berobed kangaroos presiding at Nuremburg, and duly recorded.
Hey - if I believe in the steam chambers, does that make me a Denier? If I believe in the electric plates, do I get five years in prison? What's legal to believe in Germany these days?
The evidence stands and I have reviewed much of it.
Your evidence is assertion. Your testimony is crap. Your court was a travesty and a blight on jurisprudence. Your confessions were forced under duress. Your numbers are utter fabrication. You have 4.5 million jews dying at Auschwitz one day, 1.5 million the next. Dachau is a death camp one day, not a death camp the next.
Only a credulous boob would not be skeptical about the whole yarn.
jack_boot
December 13th, 2003, 09:27 PM
Oy Vey Jack Boot! The six million story has holes in it because the Germans didn't do a good job at keeping books. It was more like 600 000 000!
Why ze hatred though? Ve are white too!
No, it was 600 000 000 at the World Trade Center.
Try to keep up.
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 09:38 PM
When will you all learn to love us as Jared Taylor has? I ask you, why the hatred?
Jared Taylor talks out of both sides of his mouth regardign the Jews. This hypocrisy made it easy for Phil Donahue to make him look ridiculous a few months back.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 13th, 2003, 09:46 PM
That is ridiculous. The Einsatzgruppen were commissioned to execute the commissars in occupied Soviet territory. No way they machine-gunned 1.5 million people.
You can say that again.
Right, there's maybe one revisionist scholar for every thousand orthodox believers, claimants, and propagandists scribing away in the Holocaust Industry - hereinafter referred to as Shoah Business.
Small inconsistencies like, for example, no human remains at Treblinka? Misrepresentations like, for example, one holo-historian claiming the post-war site was littered with carnage while another claimed Treblinka had been obliterated and disguised as a farm? While yet a third, the famous Polish commission including "historian" Rachel Auerbach, made both claims?
What did all those jews at Treblinka die of, HHE? What was the murder weapon? Have you decided yet? What was the ruling of the judge at Nuremberg as to the manner of execution? I'll give you a hint: his name was Musmano. Look it up.
Steam chambers, HHE? Electric plates? Vacuum chambers? Zyklon gas? Exhaust gas? All of the above? Because ALL the above was somberly accounted in sworn testimony to the berobed kangaroos presiding at Nuremburg, and duly recorded.
Hey - if I believe in the steam chambers, does that make me a Denier? If I believe in the electric plates, do I get five years in prison? What's legal to believe in Germany these days?
Your evidence is assertion. Your testimony is crap. Your court was a travesty and a blight on jurisprudence. Your confessions were forced under duress. Your numbers are utter fabrication. You have 4.5 million jews dying at Auschwitz one day, 1.5 million the next. Dachau is a death camp one day, not a death camp the next.
Only a credulous boob would not be skeptical about the whole yarn.
There isn't a whole lot of evidence at Treblinka because it was destroyed. And that is why you are so intent to argue Treblinka. If it was really some conspiracy you were uncovering you would focus on an area like Auswich where there was more of this supposedly faked evidence. If Treblinka was the only camp I WOULD have my doubts but it is like a serial killer that is known to have killed many people, where ample evidence HAS been found. If a person who was last seen with him is missing it is only logical to assume that they were his victim. Even if Treblinka was the only camp, however, there would still be the very troubling question of just what WERE the Nazi's so intent on hiding that they would so thoroughly destroy a "transit camp"?
Your feeble kindergarden historical postulative wanderings insult the memory of ALL the victims of WWII boot. I have never seen you question Irvings numbers on Dresden. Where are all the bodies? Many were never discovered. What about all of those victims of the war in the Pacific that were buried at sea, Hmm? "revisionists" have invented an entire new standard of proof and apply it ONLY to the holocaust, it is as simple as that.
If you insist on being so hyper-critical there is only one place for you and that is
The Mad Revisionist (http://www.reptiles.org/~madrev/The-Mad-Revisionist.htm)
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 10:12 PM
As for Nazi UFO's, Ernst Zundel has always been a lot of fun, with a weird sense of humor by all accounts (note the trademark blue hardhat); but if he's full of it, he sure as hell ain't the only one, HHE.
I don't think the hardhats were for fun. When Zündel had to go to court in his series of trials in the 80s and early 90s, it meant running a gauntlet of extremely hostile lunatic Jews, who did physically attack them, throwing batteries, slapping them, trying to knock them down and kick them (which happened to Ernst once). Zündel and his supporters, who gathered around him and Doug Christie like a phalanx, wore those hardhats to protect their skulls. The construction-worker's hardhat was chosen because it was something that was seen often in the city and was thus difficult to construe as provocative, (although one judge did call them a provocation) and it also had the fortunate aspect of being associated with common working people.
Now, during Sabina Citroen's second attempt to sue Ernst Zündel in 1996, he did go to court wearing a kangaroo suit, if I recall correctly. This was over Doug Christie's protest.
I had a conversation with Ernst about the UFO book last time I was at his Toronto house, and he does believe that UFOs exist (which is not a far-out opinion) but the Nazi UFO book was essentially a tongue-in-cheek way of getting people to look at the Third Reich in a non-hostile manner. The entire program of the NSDAP was inside that UFO book, he told me. The UFO theme was a bit like the stone in stone soup, a tricky way of getting people to do something that they otherwise might not do. The UFO theme also brought in a lot more free publicity and interview-offers than a straight book on the Third Reich would have gotten. He used the publicity and the response to that book to build his mailing list (from which, of course, those interested only in UFOs and not in the Third Reich per se dropped out quickly).
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 10:38 PM
I have never seen you question Irvings numbers on Dresden. Where are all the bodies? Many were never discovered. What about all of those victims of the war in the Pacific that were buried at sea, Hmm? "revisionists" have invented an entire new standard of proof and apply it ONLY to the holocaust, it is as simple as that.
]
I think this guy is a Deborah Lipstadt fan. He can't leave David Irving alone. I don't know what David Irving's death-toll figures for Dresden are, but I recall that contemporary American news-reports of the fire-bombing (which I researched some years ago) were in the tens of thousands although well below 100,000. I understand that Irving (decades before accepting that the gas-chamber story was a fraud) gave a much higher estimate, based on the consideration that the city was packed with refugees fleeing the Red Army. I think the number of identifiable remains was in the vicinity of 100,000. That's already quite a calamity, but there are reasons why not everyone who perished in the firestorm would have left identifiable remains, including, as I have understood, temperatures high enough to vaporize bone, and the fact that the firestorm was in effect a giant cyclone (as it was intended to be) which like all cyclones tended to suck people up into its vortex and scatter whatever was left.
If you want to say that you are skeptical that many more than 100,000 people died in the firebombing of Dresden, I won't attack you for it. Nobody that I know is getting any reparations based on the number who died there.
Don't forget to show me an online plan of a homicidal mass-gassing chamber. You (HenryHaysExecutioner) say that such a plan exists, so we need to look at it.
jack_boot
December 13th, 2003, 10:47 PM
There isn't a whole lot of evidence at Treblinka because it was destroyed. And that is why you are so intent to argue Treblinka.
I only dabble in revisionism, so I work with the obvious. I have no pretensions whatsoever of historical scholarship; but I know a snow job when I see one.
If it was really some conspiracy you were uncovering you would focus on an area like Auswich where there was more of this supposedly faked evidence. If Treblinka was the only camp I WOULD have my doubts...
Really? Why?
...but it is like a serial killer that is known to have killed many people, where ample evidence HAS been found.
Auschwitz was pretty thoroughly destroyed, too. Weren't your supposed "gas chambers", in fact, blown to smithereens? Isn't the main attraction there, Krema I, a fake built after the war, according to direction from those who made the allegations in the first place? Yes, as a matter of fact, it is. That's your evidence? Are you trying to make me laugh?
If a person who was last seen with him is missing it is only logical to assume that they were his victim.
Once you've assassinated a fellow's character, screaming loud and long that he's a serial killer, based on a reconstructed gas chamber and an empty cow pasture in Poland, defamed him with reams of wild-eyed and hysterical testimony, forced a confession out of him with a billy club and a cattle prod, then you can make the claim that any person gone missing during a cataclysmic world war must have been killed by your "known" serial killer? That's a logical assumption for you? Don't even need a body? Do you have any respect at all for the rules of evidence?
Even if Treblinka was the only camp, however, there would still be the very troubling question of just what WERE the Nazi's so intent on hiding that they would so thoroughly destroy a "transit camp"?
The Wehrmacht had a scorched earth policy. Look at the aerial photos, however, and you'll see the foundations of at least three major buildings, and the outline of the camp, rail spur intact. Not so thorough, after all; but no matter how thorough, no way can the detritus of a million burned corpses be disposed of without a trace. It's just impossible. It would still be there. Just one bucketful of ash, bone fragments, and charred teeth, taken from the area said to be the burn pit, would close your case, HHE. But you ain't got that.
Your feeble kindergarden historical postulative wanderings insult the memory of ALL the victims of WWII boot. []..."revisionists" have invented an entire new standard of proof and apply it ONLY to the holocaust, it is as simple as that.
Just a little tactic we like to call Critical Theory. Don't like it? I bet you don't.
Hadding
December 13th, 2003, 11:10 PM
From "Churchill's dark deeds," Marcus Gee, The Globe and Mail, Toronto, Wednesday, February 16, 2000:
British and American bombers attacked Dresden on the night of Feb. 13-14, 1945. The city was crammed with German refugees, doubling its original population of 600,000. The Allies dropped 650,000 incendiary bombs, setting off a firestorm that engulfed 20 square kilometres of the ancient city and killed 135,000 men, women and children. http://fpp.co.uk/online/00/02/Globe180200.html
That figure, 135,000, is apparently from David Irving, because someone wrote to Irving in 2001 asking if the estimate of 135,000 should perhaps be reduced and David Irving concurred:
[I]n "Apocalypse 1945: the Destruction of Dresden" I allow that new publications and documents suggest the figure should be revised downwards.
We can only speculate on how much. When Cambridge professor Richard Evans (the highly paid defence witness in the Lipstadt trial) suggested the figure should be "only" twenty or thirty thousand killed in two hours by the British that night, i.e., burned alive, I asked him how the police authorities in March 1945 had managed to count all the bodies, when all that was left of the victims in hundreds of shelters and cellars was a pile of ash or slime, several inches thick. He dodged the question http://fpp.co.uk/Letters/History/Dresden2.html
I wanted to get cite some authoritative numbers because I felt that citing numbers from memory as I had, on a question that does not concern me very often, was not a good way to proceed. Anyway, it's perfectly fine with me to dispute the number of dead at Dresden and evidently it's okay with David Irving too. ;-D
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 14th, 2003, 05:42 AM
I only dabble in revisionism, so I work with the obvious. I have no pretensions whatsoever of historical scholarship;
Posted by Boot on Stormfront:
I'm vain enough to re-post some of my own work on the Treblinka question, which you will find originally in the Stormburg Trial thread in this forum. You will also find an amazingly similar, though more detailed, treatment published on Mr. Irving's site, a treatise I was unaware of at the time, and presumably, that author was unaware of mine.
I'm something of an engineer myself. What do you think of my numbers?
http://www.stormfront.org/forum/showpost.php?p=693600&postcount=297
Sounds pretty pretentious to me, especially considering the D grade high school science project level postulations you went on to post as your "work".
Auschwitz was pretty thoroughly destroyed, too. Weren't your supposed "gas chambers", in fact, blown to smithereens? Isn't the main attraction there, Krema I, a fake built after the war, according to direction from those who made the allegations in the first place? Yes, as a matter of fact, it is. That's your evidence? Are you trying to make me laugh?
If you were arguing with a palentologist would you use evidence from the gift shop of a natural history museum Boot? I bet you would.
Once you've assassinated a fellow's character, screaming loud and long that he's a serial killer, based on a reconstructed gas chamber and an empty cow pasture in Poland, defamed him with reams of wild-eyed and hysterical testimony, forced a confession out of him with a billy club and a cattle prod, then you can make the claim that any person gone missing during a cataclysmic world war must have been killed by your "known" serial killer? That's a logical assumption for you? Don't even need a body? Do you have any respect at all for the rules of evidence?
This is not a video game, you don't get to unplug and start over every time you feel like it. If you want to challenge claims cite them. The only thing wild-eyed and hysterical is you. People get convicted without bodies when they destroy the bodies.
The Wehrmacht had a scorched earth policy. Look at the aerial photos, however, and you'll see the foundations of at least three major buildings, and the outline of the camp, rail spur intact. Not so thorough, after all; but no matter how thorough, no way can the detritus of a million burned corpses be disposed of without a trace. It's just impossible. It would still be there. Just one bucketful of ash, bone fragments, and charred teeth, taken from the area said to be the burn pit, would close your case, HHE. But you ain't got that.
You don't have any evidence that it isn't there. Gonna go back to Rich Krege Boot? You only start with 3 Zundelcraft in this game. One down two left, use them up and game over since you will get dizzy and fall down from going in circles.
Just a little tactic we like to call Critical Theory.
Ok, I have some work a friend of mine did on the Great Irish Potato Hoax I will post in another thread. Please lend your revisionist skills to the noble cause of exposing this deception if you will, we have Protestants to save Boot, the Pope rules America, we haven't much time.
----------------------------------
http://www.holocaust-history.org/
http://www.nizkor.org
jack_boot
December 14th, 2003, 10:16 AM
Sounds pretty pretentious to me, especially considering the D grade high school science project level postulations you went on to post as your "work".
Anyone can review my high school science project; anyone can cut the numbers I used in half, and still be unable to demonstrate viable throughput - as you were unable to do. And my numbers were conservative in the first place. You are reduced to sputtering and scoffing.
One cannot disinter and vaporize 860,000 human corpses in three months with 500 slaves, one steam shovel, and no fuel, leaving no trace of the deed, in the wilds of northern Poland, during the upheaval of a total war. It is not possible. Yet that is your story. Well, I'm not buying it, and only a fool would, after looking at the record.
If you were arguing with a palentologist would you use evidence from the gift shop of a natural history museum Boot? I bet you would.
Oh, ho! That is exactly what you are trying to pull! It is not I pointing to this carnival show at Auschwitz as evidence, but you.
You don't have any evidence that it isn't there. Gonna go back to Rich Krege Boot? You only start with 3 Zundelcraft in this game. One down two left, use them up and game over since you will get dizzy and fall down from going in circles.
The problem with argument is that the other fellow simply gets stubborn; in this case, pathetically so. Coincidentally, that's a problem with fraud, too.
Krege calls for further examination of the site; I call for further examination of the site; any fair-minded sober citizen trying a murder case would demand an examination of the site. You are the one insisting there is no need to examine the crime scene. You are the one lacking forensic evidence. You are the one hawking a tale of woe and enormity - your motive: money, moral leverage, money, political leverage, money.
I'd say you are the one with something to hide, pal. I'd say a crime has indeed been committed, but a very different crime than YOU want us to think.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 14th, 2003, 02:14 PM
Anyone can review my high school science project; anyone can cut the numbers I used in half, and still be unable to demonstrate viable throughput -
your numberrs were 99% air dumbass
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 14th, 2003, 02:17 PM
Krege calls for further examination of the site;
I call for the disinterment of the Dresden victims, and the retrieval of the Pacific war dead from the bottom of the ocean, and the Irish Potato hoax victims, who cares..
Face it Boot Krege is a nobody and so are you no one is listening to what you call for.
Hadding
December 14th, 2003, 02:21 PM
There's not really much point in arguing wth HenryHaysExecutioner at this point. He has been pretty thoroughly discredited, and the application of redundant arguments of secondary importance (e.g. about Treblinka) just allows him to keep the argument alive when in fact it is over and he lost.
We have shown HenryHaysExecutioner all that we needed to show him, if he were a reasonable person interested in the truth, to prove that he really did not know what he was talking about. It is time for him to show us something, i.e. the alleged plan of a German mass-gassing chamber. Let's see it.
HenryHaysExecutioner
December 14th, 2003, 03:55 PM
There's not really much point in arguing wth HenryHaysExecutioner at this point. He has been pretty thoroughly discredited, and the application of redundant arguments of secondary importance (e.g. about Treblinka) just allows him to keep the argument alive when in fact it is over and he lost.
We have shown HenryHaysExecutioner all that we needed to show him, if he were a reasonable person interested in the truth, to prove that he really did not know what he was talking about. It is time for him to show us something, i.e. the alleged plan of a German mass-gassing chamber. Let's see it.
Already posted hadding.
HenryHaysExecutioner
January 8th, 2004, 01:54 PM
There's not really much point in arguing wth HenryHaysExecutioner at this point. He has been pretty thoroughly discredited, and the application of redundant arguments of secondary importance (e.g. about Treblinka) just allows him to keep the argument alive when in fact it is over and he lost.
LOL yes and Irving "won" his case too right?
Hadding
January 8th, 2004, 05:59 PM
LOL yes and Irving "won" his case too right?
"LOL" Why is HHE talking about David Irving in his Ernst Zundel thread? Has the muddlehead confused them with each other again?
vBulletin® v3.8.6, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.