Gladius
12-10-2003, 11:34 AM
The website under scrutiny is here [size=1][color=#0000ff]http://www.ukar.org[/color][/size] (http://www.ukar.org)
The following in the process under way of shutting down the website the canadian jewish congress finds offensive (gee, what don't they find offensive?) PART I
Dear Free Speech Supporter:
We've long identified the Canadian Jewish Congress as one of the most
fanatically anti-free speech lobbies in Canada. From promoting the "hate
law" over 35 yeara ago, to relentlessly pressing for people to be charged
by the police or human rights commissions, the CJC is one of Canada's most
strident censorship groups.
One might think that, being in the business of representing -- or, at
least, purporting to represent -- Canadian Jews, the CJC might seek the
respect the freedoms of others. With the deservedly bad image Zionists have
today in light of the occupation of Palestine and the treatment of the
indigenous inhabitants, one might think that the CJC would seek to portray
a kinder gentler image.
No way! The latest target is Ukrainian scholar and civil rights activist
Lubomir Prytulak of Vancouver. The CJC's answer to concerns raised by Mr.
Prytulak on behalf of many Ukrainians is "shut him up."
Paul Fromm
Director
CANADIAN ASSOCIATION FOR FREE EXPRESSION
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Canadian Jewish Congress Complaint
THIS IS: Searchable, Links-Added Text Version GO TO: Non-Searchable
Photocopy Version
Red @s inserted below can be clicked to view the origin of a quoted UKAR
statement,
following which the reader will be able to return to his place by clicking
BACK on his browser.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----
CANADIAN
HUMAN RIGHTS
COMMISSION
Intake Services
COMMISSION
CANADIENNE DES
DROITS DE LA PERSONNE
Service de l'accueil
Si vous désirez obtenir une copie de cette lettre en français, veuillez
communiquer avec la Commission à l'adresse ou au numéro de téléphone
indiqués en bas de page.
File no. 20031527 NOV 27 2003
PROTECTED PRIORITY POST - SIGNATUR REQUIRED
Mr. Lubomyr Prytulak
4165 West 11th Avenue
Vancouver, BC V6R 2L5
Dear Mr. Prytulak:
The Canadian Human Rights Commission has received a complaint from
Len Rudner alleging that your website (the Ukrainian Archive) is
discriminating against persons or groups of persons because of religion and
national or ethnic origin by communicating messages to Internet newsgroups
which would likely expose individuals who are of the Jewish faith, and
segments of the Jewish faith identified by their national or ethnic origin
to hatred and/or contempt contrary to section 13(1) of the Canadian Human
Rights Act.
Under Part III of the Canadian Human Right Act, the Commission is
required to address any complaint that alleges a violation of the Act. Ms.
Hannya Rizk is the investigator designated to gather the evidence in
relation to the complainant's allegations and, once the investigation is
complete, to report on the findings to the Members of the Commission. You
can reach her at (613) 943-9061 or by fax at (613) 947-7279.
The report to the Commission will include a recommendation for the
disposition of the complaint. The investigator can recommend that a
conciliator or a Human Rights Tribunal be appointed, if the evidence
supports the allegations in the complaint, or that the complaint be
dismissed, if the allegations are not supported by the evidence. The
investigator can also recommend to the Commission that a settlement be
approved if the parties reach an agreement during the course of the
investigation.
At this time, I would appreciate receiving by December 23, 2003 your
position regarding the allegations including, but not limited to, the
following:
Do you own and/or control the Ukrainian Archive website? If not, who own's
and/or controls this website? What is the Ukrainian Archive website's
present Internet address (URL)?
.../2
344 Slater Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 1E1
344, rue Slater, Ottawa (Ontario) K1A 1E1
Toll-free / Sans frais 1-888-214-1090, TTY / ATS 1-888-643-3304, Fax /
téléc. (613) 947-7279
www.chrc-ccdp.ca
- 2 -
What is the purpose of the Ukrainian Archive website?
What is the intent of the information/documentation posted on the website?
Who is responsible for editing and/or posting the content of the
information/documentation on the website?
How are the documents being posted on the Ukrainian Archive website?
Who is your present Internet Service Provider (ISP)? Where is it located?
Please provide a copy of the ISP's arrangement. Please provide a copy of
the agreement with ISP.
If someone other than yourself will be representing your organisation
in this matter, please let us know at your earliest opportunity. Also,
please be advised that you are required to preserve any material related to
the complaint, including information in electronic formats, until the final
disposition of the matter.
Yours sincerely,
[S. Best signature]
Suzanne Best
A/Manager
Att.
c.c. Mr. Len Rudner
CANADIAN
HUMAN RIGHTS
COMMISSION COMMISSION
CANADIENNE DES
DROITS DE LA PERSONNE
COMPLAINT SUMMARY
FILE NUMBER
2003 1527
DATE COMPLAINT RECEIVED
November 7, 2003
NAME OF COMPLAINANT
Len Rudner
NAME AND ADDRESS OF RESPONDENT
Lubomyr Prytulak
4165 West 11th Avenue
Vancouver, BC V6R 2L5
DATE OF ALLEGED CONDUCT
Ongoing
ADDRESS WHERE INCIDENT OCCURRED (if different from the above)
RELEVANT PROHIBITED GROUNDS
Race, religion and
national or ethnic origin
APPLICABLE SECTIONS OF THE CHRA
13
PRACTICES (e.g., termination of employment, harassment, etc.)
Hate messaging
COMPLAINT FORM
YOUR NAME NAME OF ORGANIZATION OR INDIVIDUAL YOUR
COMPLAINT IS AGAINST
Len Rudner
Lubomyr Prytulak
I have reasonable grounds for believing that I have been discriminated against
in employment
in the provision of services
contrary to section(s) _____13_____of the Canadian Human Rights Act. I
declare that the following information is true to the best of my knowledge.
[Len Rudner left the area provided here blank because he supplied the
requested "information" in the four pages attached.]
I consent to the release to the Canadian Human Rights Commission of all
information and documents concerning me that the Commission considers
necessary for its investigation, such as personnel records, documents,
data, medical or hospital records which relate to the complaint. I also
authorize the Commission to have such information examined by any person it
retains to provide advice and assistance in dealing with my complaint.
Signature: [Len Rudner signature] Date: November 6, 2003
The following in the process under way of shutting down the website the canadian jewish congress finds offensive (gee, what don't they find offensive?) PART I
Dear Free Speech Supporter:
We've long identified the Canadian Jewish Congress as one of the most
fanatically anti-free speech lobbies in Canada. From promoting the "hate
law" over 35 yeara ago, to relentlessly pressing for people to be charged
by the police or human rights commissions, the CJC is one of Canada's most
strident censorship groups.
One might think that, being in the business of representing -- or, at
least, purporting to represent -- Canadian Jews, the CJC might seek the
respect the freedoms of others. With the deservedly bad image Zionists have
today in light of the occupation of Palestine and the treatment of the
indigenous inhabitants, one might think that the CJC would seek to portray
a kinder gentler image.
No way! The latest target is Ukrainian scholar and civil rights activist
Lubomir Prytulak of Vancouver. The CJC's answer to concerns raised by Mr.
Prytulak on behalf of many Ukrainians is "shut him up."
Paul Fromm
Director
CANADIAN ASSOCIATION FOR FREE EXPRESSION
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Canadian Jewish Congress Complaint
THIS IS: Searchable, Links-Added Text Version GO TO: Non-Searchable
Photocopy Version
Red @s inserted below can be clicked to view the origin of a quoted UKAR
statement,
following which the reader will be able to return to his place by clicking
BACK on his browser.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----
CANADIAN
HUMAN RIGHTS
COMMISSION
Intake Services
COMMISSION
CANADIENNE DES
DROITS DE LA PERSONNE
Service de l'accueil
Si vous désirez obtenir une copie de cette lettre en français, veuillez
communiquer avec la Commission à l'adresse ou au numéro de téléphone
indiqués en bas de page.
File no. 20031527 NOV 27 2003
PROTECTED PRIORITY POST - SIGNATUR REQUIRED
Mr. Lubomyr Prytulak
4165 West 11th Avenue
Vancouver, BC V6R 2L5
Dear Mr. Prytulak:
The Canadian Human Rights Commission has received a complaint from
Len Rudner alleging that your website (the Ukrainian Archive) is
discriminating against persons or groups of persons because of religion and
national or ethnic origin by communicating messages to Internet newsgroups
which would likely expose individuals who are of the Jewish faith, and
segments of the Jewish faith identified by their national or ethnic origin
to hatred and/or contempt contrary to section 13(1) of the Canadian Human
Rights Act.
Under Part III of the Canadian Human Right Act, the Commission is
required to address any complaint that alleges a violation of the Act. Ms.
Hannya Rizk is the investigator designated to gather the evidence in
relation to the complainant's allegations and, once the investigation is
complete, to report on the findings to the Members of the Commission. You
can reach her at (613) 943-9061 or by fax at (613) 947-7279.
The report to the Commission will include a recommendation for the
disposition of the complaint. The investigator can recommend that a
conciliator or a Human Rights Tribunal be appointed, if the evidence
supports the allegations in the complaint, or that the complaint be
dismissed, if the allegations are not supported by the evidence. The
investigator can also recommend to the Commission that a settlement be
approved if the parties reach an agreement during the course of the
investigation.
At this time, I would appreciate receiving by December 23, 2003 your
position regarding the allegations including, but not limited to, the
following:
Do you own and/or control the Ukrainian Archive website? If not, who own's
and/or controls this website? What is the Ukrainian Archive website's
present Internet address (URL)?
.../2
344 Slater Street, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 1E1
344, rue Slater, Ottawa (Ontario) K1A 1E1
Toll-free / Sans frais 1-888-214-1090, TTY / ATS 1-888-643-3304, Fax /
téléc. (613) 947-7279
www.chrc-ccdp.ca
- 2 -
What is the purpose of the Ukrainian Archive website?
What is the intent of the information/documentation posted on the website?
Who is responsible for editing and/or posting the content of the
information/documentation on the website?
How are the documents being posted on the Ukrainian Archive website?
Who is your present Internet Service Provider (ISP)? Where is it located?
Please provide a copy of the ISP's arrangement. Please provide a copy of
the agreement with ISP.
If someone other than yourself will be representing your organisation
in this matter, please let us know at your earliest opportunity. Also,
please be advised that you are required to preserve any material related to
the complaint, including information in electronic formats, until the final
disposition of the matter.
Yours sincerely,
[S. Best signature]
Suzanne Best
A/Manager
Att.
c.c. Mr. Len Rudner
CANADIAN
HUMAN RIGHTS
COMMISSION COMMISSION
CANADIENNE DES
DROITS DE LA PERSONNE
COMPLAINT SUMMARY
FILE NUMBER
2003 1527
DATE COMPLAINT RECEIVED
November 7, 2003
NAME OF COMPLAINANT
Len Rudner
NAME AND ADDRESS OF RESPONDENT
Lubomyr Prytulak
4165 West 11th Avenue
Vancouver, BC V6R 2L5
DATE OF ALLEGED CONDUCT
Ongoing
ADDRESS WHERE INCIDENT OCCURRED (if different from the above)
RELEVANT PROHIBITED GROUNDS
Race, religion and
national or ethnic origin
APPLICABLE SECTIONS OF THE CHRA
13
PRACTICES (e.g., termination of employment, harassment, etc.)
Hate messaging
COMPLAINT FORM
YOUR NAME NAME OF ORGANIZATION OR INDIVIDUAL YOUR
COMPLAINT IS AGAINST
Len Rudner
Lubomyr Prytulak
I have reasonable grounds for believing that I have been discriminated against
in employment
in the provision of services
contrary to section(s) _____13_____of the Canadian Human Rights Act. I
declare that the following information is true to the best of my knowledge.
[Len Rudner left the area provided here blank because he supplied the
requested "information" in the four pages attached.]
I consent to the release to the Canadian Human Rights Commission of all
information and documents concerning me that the Commission considers
necessary for its investigation, such as personnel records, documents,
data, medical or hospital records which relate to the complaint. I also
authorize the Commission to have such information examined by any person it
retains to provide advice and assistance in dealing with my complaint.
Signature: [Len Rudner signature] Date: November 6, 2003