View Full Version : Question For A Jew About Israel
Franco
June 23rd, 2004, 03:01 AM
Question for any Jew:
Why does Israel not give back the large, important West Bank that it stole from the Arabs -- i.e. stole in a war that Israel started -- in 1967? Is such giving back of land not the first step to peace in the Middle East? Would that not show the Arab world that Israel is serious about peace?
Please answer using clear language with no emotional features.
------
Yihudi
June 23rd, 2004, 08:04 AM
Ok-
First of all, Israel did not start the 6 day war. According to the Americans and Europeans, when Egypt closed the straits of Tehran in early June 1967,
that was an act of war. Those straits were essential for Israeli shipping, and according to all Western governments, that was the first salvo in the 6 day war. Prior to that, Egypt had evicted the UN troops in Sinai, that had served as a buffer between Egypt and Israel, and had done many other things that clerarly displayed its' intentions. But, again, according to all, Egypt's closing the straits of Tehran was the first salvo of the 6 day war.
Israel never stole anything. Jews returned to their ancient homeland.The West Bank did not belong to any country. It was administered by the jordanians, but only 2 countries, (Brittain and Pakistan, I believe) recognized
Jordanian control of it. The UN had designated much of the West Bank to be Palestinian, but the Palestinians rejected it in 1947. So the land was as much Israel's as anybody elses, by international law. Historically, the only people who made this area of land their homeland was the Jews. Both Jews and Christians believe that God promised this land to the Jews as well.
Having said all of that, if Israel decides in the name of peace, to cede part of the territory to let the Palestinians have their own country, then Israel deserves all the more respect. There is certainly no international precedent for a country to behave so generously.
MOMUS
June 23rd, 2004, 08:44 AM
There is no point in debating someone who could say such as this. Who can blame the Pals for trying to remove such criminals?
Having said all of that, if Israel decides in the name of peace, to cede part of the territory to let the Palestinians have their own country, then Israel deserves all the more respect. There is certainly no international precedent for a country to behave so generously.[/QUOTE]To paraphrase: Jews should receive praise for returning a small portion of what they have stolen. Non-Jews should be grateful for anything the jews leave them.
sixpakistan
June 23rd, 2004, 08:49 AM
Ok-
First of all, Israel did not start the 6 day war. According to the Americans and Europeans, when Egypt closed the straits of Tehran in early June 1967, that was an act of war.
Nothing else needs to be said there. According to America, Egypt started it! Duhh. According to the American Secretary of Defense, when Israel attacked an American ship, it was an "accident."
Israel never stole anything. Jews returned to their ancient homeland.
Actually, if you really want to dredge up ancient history that has no bearing on anything, the Philistines and Canaanites (ancestors of Palestinians) had it before the Jews.
Then, (this is from the Torah) God expelled Jews from their "homeland" for breaking their covenant - and ordered them "go live peacefully amongst other nations" and to not to attempt to return to Israel by any military or worldly means, for it would result in strife. This was why the Agudath Israel opposed zionism (an atheist doctrine) from its inception until 1948 (when it became politically impractical to do so).
In the interest of brevity, I'll stop there with the history lesson & won't go into how the Muslims took Jerusalem from the Romans, when they lost it and when they regained it etc. I'll just note that all 3 conquests of Jerusalem by Muslims were entirely bloodless.
In any event, I'm willing to bet your "ancestral homeland" isn't Israel, but somewhere in Eastern Europe (like most "Israelis" today). The Jews for whom Israel was actually an "ancient homeland" mostly already lived in the area (peacefully) amongst Muslims. These are the same Jews that are treated as second-class citizens in Israel today for not being "white."
The West Bank did not belong to any country. It was administered by the jordanians, but only 2 countries, (Brittain and Pakistan, I believe) recognized
Jordanian control of it.
Hilarious. "Only" Britain recognized Jordanian control of it. Britain controlled a portion of the rest of the land (although it was no more "British" than India was), dimwit. Their recognition was the only relevant recognition in the region at the time. Israel didn't exist then.
The UN had designated much of the West Bank to be Palestinian, but the Palestinians rejected it in 1947. So the land was as much Israel's as anybody elses, by international law.
Spoken like a true kike. No, the UN designated a large portion of Palestinian land to be Israeli, and then designated "much of the West Bank" to be Palestinian (which it already was). What they rejected was their land being divided and split.
Historically, the only people who made this area of land their homeland was the Jews. Both Jews and Christians believe that God promised this land to the Jews as well.
We already debunked your 'history,' which also conveniently ignores the past 2000 years.
Both the Jews and the Christians believe that the Jews broke their covenant with God & are required to live as a diaspora.
Having said all of that, if Israel decides in the name of peace, to cede part of the territory to let the Palestinians have their own country, then Israel deserves all the more respect. There is certainly no international precedent for a country to behave so generously.
So you agree that there was no reason Palestine should've ceded half of its territory to the Israelis so they could have their own country in 1948?
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 10:40 AM
Yahoodit performs as expected, issuing for the the standard Israeli propaganda. Yahoodit, you can drop the act dude. You're not talking to little kids here or stupid "holy land tour" schmucks.
Let me say what Henry Kissenger said in an interview with Charlie Rose: "The Israelis do not wish to trade the West Bank for peace because they regard the 1967 borders as untenable from a military perspective." The 1967 borders made Israel look like a dumb-bell, narrow in the middle. I'm not sure how wide but very narrow. They want to stage their front line defenses to the next Arab invasion at the River Jordan not behind it. That's the bottom line with the West Bank. Gaza is a different story.
But consider this. Iraq was the second biggest threat after Egypt which is for now mollified with a fat diet of American foreign aid and investment. As is Jordan. Iraq is now emasculated and Syria is too small to pose a credible threat on its own. So what's the objection to peace then? People hoped the Iraq thing would bring about an advance in the peace process. It hasnt. So naive people have learned that Jews only take they do not give. And if they give it is because they expect to be in a better position to take later on.
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 10:51 AM
Question for any Jew:
Why does Israel not give back the large, important West Bank that it stole from the Arabs -- i.e. stole in a war that Israel started -- in 1967? Is such giving back of land not the first step to peace in the Middle East? Would that not show the Arab world that Israel is serious about peace?
Please answer using clear language with no emotional features.
------
cause we don't wanna, waaa, waaa waaaaa. :mad:
I have a question for you?
WHY THE DOUBLE STANDARD?
SHOULD ALL COUNTRIES, NATIONS GIVE BACK LAND THEY CONQUERED IN WAR (OR BY FORCE?)
WHY DO YOU NOT OBJECT TO OTHER STUFF GOING ON IN THE WORLD SUCH AS THE BEHEADING OF A SOUTH KOREAN CIVILIAN? WHERE ARE YOUR CRIES OF OUTRAGE? WHY IS IT THAT THE ISLAMIC WORLD IS HOLDING THE WORLD HOSTAGE AND THE UNITED NATIONS SIT ON THEIR ASSES, BOWING IN COWARDICE?
When you answer those questons, then I will attempt to respond to your ludicrous, ridiculous question.
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 11:01 AM
Ok-
First of all, Israel did not start the 6 day war. According to the Americans and Europeans, when Egypt closed the straits of Tehran in early June 1967,
that was an act of war. Those straits were essential for Israeli shipping, and according to all Western governments, that was the first salvo in the 6 day war. Prior to that, Egypt had evicted the UN troops in Sinai, that had served as a buffer between Egypt and Israel, and had done many other things that clerarly displayed its' intentions. But, again, according to all, Egypt's closing the straits of Tehran was the first salvo of the 6 day war.
Israel never stole anything. Jews returned to their ancient homeland.The West Bank did not belong to any country. It was administered by the jordanians, but only 2 countries, (Brittain and Pakistan, I believe) recognized
Jordanian control of it. The UN had designated much of the West Bank to be Palestinian, but the Palestinians rejected it in 1947. So the land was as much Israel's as anybody elses, by international law. Historically, the only people who made this area of land their homeland was the Jews. Both Jews and Christians believe that God promised this land to the Jews as well.
Having said all of that, if Israel decides in the name of peace, to cede part of the territory to let the Palestinians have their own country, then Israel deserves all the more respect. There is certainly no international precedent for a country to behave so generously.
Yidudi, why are you bothering with these assholes? Do you honestly think that you can get through to them in a decent and kind way? They don't want the truth. They cannot handle the truth. They yearn to keep believing that the jews are responsible for everything that goes wrong in the world. So be it. Why should we care what they think? Do you think they give a rats arse that jews are dying in the streets via homicide bombings? The revel in the thought.
My objection to Israel, is why THEY bow THEIR heads in cowardice and allow their citizens to be butchered while the world says nada. Jews for Jews, that is the way it's always been and will be. You are a heck of a lot nicer to them than I am. You see, i tried appealing to them to at least see both side of the issue. They cannot becasue of their hatred. Especially this forum.
many of these people are athiests or onanists. they do NOT believe in the old testament, so do not even go there with them.
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 11:45 AM
Retard said: "WHY THE DOUBLE STANDARD?..SHOULD ALL COUNTRIES, NATIONS GIVE BACK LAND THEY CONQUERED IN WAR (OR BY FORCE?)..."
good point. When the Jews were previously a landless people afflicted by FORCE, such as various explusions including the recent German incident, they whined and cried. Then they got their own patch of land and not two years had passed and Jews had ethnically cleansed over 700,000 Arabs from within Israel, acccording to Norman Finkelstein. Today the double standard continues. Israel perpetrates "genocide" but no "Nuremberg" is called to hold wicked murderers like Sharon to account.
If Jew want Lex Talionem that's fine. Jack London called that the "White Man's Law, red of tooth and claw"
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 11:50 AM
Ok-....... Historically, the only people who made this area of land their homeland was the Jews. ........
Liar. Arabs made it their home since they took it from the Byzantine Greeks in 500 AD or whenever. Throughout most of the next 1500 years it was a mostly Arab population incuding throughout the many centuries in which it was part of the Ottoman caliphate. In 1900 there were less than a million Jews in Palestine. The other four or five million Jews have come mostly from Europe. You think I'm off here just show it. What was the exact percentage of jews native born to Palestine in 1947?
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 12:02 PM
Ok-..... Both Jews and Christians believe that God promised this land to the Jews as well. ......
Shut up Christ Killer. You dont speak for Christians.
Do the nearly 1/3 of the Palestianian and Israeli Arab population which are Christians (Orthodox or Catholic) believe this? I seriously doubt it.
Did my ancestors believe this? No. They believe the Abrahamic promise was negated by the Jews rejecting Christ as Messiah. Thereafter they were cursed to wander the Earth as a landless people for their wickedness. That is what Europeans used to believe though Jews have been successful rewriting history in this regard.
Who believes this? I will tell you. A small minority, a handfull, of idiotic "Christian dispensationalists" who emanate from a thoroughly judaized type of fundamentalist Christianty that does not even deserve the name. They are a species of British foolishness related to BI and Lloyd George was one of them not coincidentally. They are a contemporary continuance of the Jew-loving utopian fanatic Cromwell. They are mostly American and are usually feckless dolts of the most pathetic kind.
But for all that their "zionism" is still a recent phenomenon as in the sixties most of them still understood the curse on the Jews. But in the 1970s you had the rise of evangelic television ministries. Licensed by: the FCC, which is staffed by numerous Jews. Then in the Reagan era you had the renewal of the feckless evangelical dolt cum Jew strategist alliance a la new Cromwell which continues with Bush. One of the schemes of this era was the "Holy Land Tour."
The Holy Land Tour is a scheme whereby an evangelical leader sends his flock to Israel where they spend money and "oohh and ahh" over the sights with Jeiwsh tour guides who regale them with bullshit. Generally the evangelical leadership gets kickbacks of course; and when they set up a new such endeavor, they visit Izzyland themselves where I suspect they are subject to the usual Jewish attempts to corrupt and blackmail gentiles via sexual indiscretion. Of course evangelical preachers are known for their tawdry indulgence in sexual indiscretion which as Ostrovsky described is an expertise of the Israelis. In an aside, that is how the Mossad bagged Mordechai Vannunu. But I digress. So now the zhids have blackmail material on the preacher getting his freak on with a moldovan whore, plus the preacher is getting kickbacks, plus the FCC jews will yank his televitz license if he strays. The lock is in on the evangelicals, and that is why. No "Bible" or "OLD TESTAMENT" is relevant here.
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 12:10 PM
Yidudi, ....... they do NOT believe in the old testament, so do not even go there with them.
Doublehook, check this out. More proof Retard is not a Jewess. Since when to Jews call the Hebrew scriptures the "OLD TESTAMENT?" They dont.
sixpakistan
June 23rd, 2004, 12:12 PM
WHY DO YOU NOT OBJECT TO OTHER STUFF GOING ON IN THE WORLD SUCH AS THE BEHEADING OF A SOUTH KOREAN CIVILIAN? WHERE ARE YOUR CRIES OF OUTRAGE? WHY IS IT THAT THE ISLAMIC WORLD IS HOLDING THE WORLD HOSTAGE AND THE UNITED NATIONS SIT ON THEIR ASSES, BOWING IN COWARDICE?
When you answer those questons, then I will attempt to respond to your ludicrous, ridiculous question.
A single South Korean civilian that was in Iraq as a result of and in support of an occupying force is killed by Iraqi resistance, and that's a bigger outrage than what Israel does to Palestinian children - in their own land - every single day?
I have a feeling you weren't shouting about how all's fair in war when Iraq "conquered" Kuwait (a country that Iraq has a FAR stronger claim to historically than Jews do Israel, considering it was part of Iraq not long ago). You were probably one of the many clamoring for the US to send troops to the Gulf, and criticizing Saddam for not obeying the UN (criticism which is undoubtedly muted when it comes to Israel's invasion of Lebanon).
You know what VNN says. "One standard for Jews.."
Abzug Hoffman
June 23rd, 2004, 12:32 PM
All Jews Return to Zion and Kill Yourselves.
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 23rd, 2004, 01:23 PM
note that only a FIFTH of the 80% of the Israeli Jewish non-Arab population were actually born in Israel. The nation is MAJORITY immigrant.
http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/is.html#People
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 02:07 PM
A single South Korean civilian that was in Iraq as a result of and in support of an occupying force is killed by Iraqi resistance, and that's a bigger outrage than what Israel does to Palestinian children - in their own land - every single day?
I have a feeling you weren't shouting about how all's fair in war when Iraq "conquered" Kuwait (a country that Iraq has a FAR stronger claim to historically than Jews do Israel, considering it was part of Iraq not long ago). You were probably one of the many clamoring for the US to send troops to the Gulf, and criticizing Saddam for not obeying the UN (criticism which is undoubtedly muted when it comes to Israel's invasion of Lebanon).
You know what VNN says. "One standard for Jews.."
You get me sources, reliable legitimate sources (not some biased arab site) that states that instead of blanket uncorroborated statements.
Did you also know that the fucking muslim websites post pics of killed children that are doctored? or OLD or NOT KILLED BY ISRAELI SOLDIERS? Too bad Israel is not clever enough to do that. You know, post photos of kids killed by other jews (if such a thing exists). But you know what, there is no arguing with you.
btw, i never said that there are bad eggs among jews. never. the arab propaganda machine is very efficient. AND btw, when they start caring for our children, we jews will start caring for theirs. There are many Jews who cry out against innocent civilians getting killed but you show me a single arab nation that says "enough with the killings of innocents".
Also, a question for you. How do YOU feel about the bombings targeted SPECIFICALLY AND DELIBERATELY in civilian areas in israel? Why have you never shed a single tear for a jewish child? I would like to know.
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 02:11 PM
(although our men get more feminized, i.e. irrational and emotional everyday).
Wha? OUR men? Oops, was that a freudian slip, doppel? Or are YOU a self-loathing jew in disguise perhaps?
The bitch? 'scuse me? You don't know me well enough to call me a bich, goychik. Not that I give a damn, but just so you know.
and as far as my NOT being a Jew, I am so glad I've got you baffled. Is she, isn't she, only God will tell. (i suppose you are thinking Jews spell God, G-d, right?) Do I have you figured out or what.
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 03:01 PM
Nothing else needs to be said there. According to America, Egypt started it! Duhh. According to the American Secretary of Defense, when Israel attacked an American ship, it was an "accident."
Actually, if you really want to dredge up ancient history that has no bearing on anything, the Philistines and Canaanites (ancestors of Palestinians) had it before the Jews.
Then, (this is from the Torah) God expelled Jews from their "homeland" for breaking their covenant - and ordered them "go live peacefully amongst other nations" and to not to attempt to return to Israel by any military or worldly means, for it would result in strife. This was why the Agudath Israel opposed zionism (an atheist doctrine) from its inception until 1948 (when it became politically impractical to do so).
In the interest of brevity, I'll stop there with the history lesson & won't go into how the Muslims took Jerusalem from the Romans, when they lost it and when they regained it etc. I'll just note that all 3 conquests of Jerusalem by Muslims were entirely bloodless.
In any event, I'm willing to bet your "ancestral homeland" isn't Israel, but somewhere in Eastern Europe (like most "Israelis" today). The Jews for whom Israel was actually an "ancient homeland" mostly already lived in the area (peacefully) amongst Muslims. These are the same Jews that are treated as second-class citizens in Israel today for not being "white."
Hilarious. "Only" Britain recognized Jordanian control of it. Britain controlled a portion of the rest of the land (although it was no more "British" than India was), dimwit. Their recognition was the only relevant recognition in the region at the time. Israel didn't exist then.
Spoken like a true kike. No, the UN designated a large portion of Palestinian land to be Israeli, and then designated "much of the West Bank" to be Palestinian (which it already was). What they rejected was their land being divided and split.
We already debunked your 'history,' which also conveniently ignores the past 2000 years.
Both the Jews and the Christians believe that the Jews broke their covenant with God & are required to live as a diaspora.
So you agree that there was no reason Palestine should've ceded half of its
territory to the Israelis so they could have their own country in 1948?
stop calling jews kikes and we will stop calling you raghead, okay? You would love it if all whites hated jews, wouldn'tcha? Just a little reading for you. Do you honestly think i will let you get away with your shit?
http://www.newsfilter.org/articles/hatred.htm
http://hnn.us/articles/743.html
http://www.townhall.com/bookclub/timmerman.html#
ReturnToZion
June 23rd, 2004, 03:19 PM
Nothing else needs to be said there. According to America, Egypt started it! Duhh. According to the American Secretary of Defense, when Israel attacked an American ship, it was an "accident."
Actually, if you really want to dredge up ancient history that has no bearing on anything, the Philistines and Canaanites (ancestors of Palestinians) had it before the Jews.
Then, (this is from the Torah) God expelled Jews from their "homeland" for breaking their covenant - and ordered them "go live peacefully amongst other nations" and to not to attempt to return to Israel by any military or worldly means, for it would result in strife. This was why the Agudath Israel opposed zionism (an atheist doctrine) from its inception until 1948 (when it became politically impractical to do so).
In the interest of brevity, I'll stop there with the history lesson & won't go into how the Muslims took Jerusalem from the Romans, when they lost it and when they regained it etc. I'll just note that all 3 conquests of Jerusalem by Muslims were entirely bloodless.
In any event, I'm willing to bet your "ancestral homeland" isn't Israel, but somewhere in Eastern Europe (like most "Israelis" today). The Jews for whom Israel was actually an "ancient homeland" mostly already lived in the area (peacefully) amongst Muslims. These are the same Jews that are treated as second-class citizens in Israel today for not being "white."
Hilarious. "Only" Britain recognized Jordanian control of it. Britain controlled a portion of the rest of the land (although it was no more "British" than India was), dimwit. Their recognition was the only relevant recognition in the region at the time. Israel didn't exist then.
Spoken like a true kike. No, the UN designated a large portion of Palestinian land to be Israeli, and then designated "much of the West Bank" to be Palestinian (which it already was). What they rejected was their land being divided and split.
We already debunked your 'history,' which also conveniently ignores the past 2000 years.
Both the Jews and the Christians believe that the Jews broke their covenant with God & are required to live as a diaspora.
So you agree that there was no reason Palestine should've ceded half of its territory to the Israelis so they could have their own country in 1948?
http://wordofmessiah.org/from_terrorist_to_zionist.htm
what do you think of this?
sixpakistan
June 23rd, 2004, 03:25 PM
You get me sources, reliable legitimate sources (not some biased arab site) that states that instead of blanket uncorroborated statements.
Try www.cnn.com, which will tell you that close to 1800 Palestinian civilians have been killed in the past 3 years. That's more than the total # of Israelis killed altogether.
Did you also know that the fucking muslim websites post pics of killed children that are doctored? or OLD or NOT KILLED BY ISRAELI SOLDIERS? Too bad Israel is not clever enough to do that. You know, post photos of kids killed by other jews (if such a thing exists).
You get me sources, reliable legitimate sources (not some biased kike site) that states that instead of blanket uncorroborated statements.
But you know what, there is no arguing with you.
Not when you're a dull kike, there isn't.
btw, i never said that there are bad eggs among jews. never. the arab propaganda machine is very efficient.
Yeah, the Arab propaganda machine is really as efficient as the thousands of evangelical Christian & zionist websites, Jew-dominated Hollywood, and the Jew dominated American press.
AND btw, when they start caring for our children, we jews will start caring for theirs. There are many Jews who cry out against innocent civilians getting killed but you show me a single arab nation that says "enough with the killings of innocents".
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/library/news/2004/01/mil-040129-voa03.htm
"The Palestinian Authority condemned the killings, saying it is part of what it called a cycle of violence."
Just one example. That's Voice of America News, by the way.
Also, a question for you. How do YOU feel about the bombings targeted SPECIFICALLY AND DELIBERATELY in civilian areas in israel? Why have you never shed a single tear for a jewish child? I would like to know.
Despite what you're told by the media, most Palestinian resistance groups do not carry out operations outside of settler areas. These are the lands that belong to them according to international law (the pre '67 borders) & are being settled by ultra-right wing hebrew nationalists who cut off their water, take their natural resources, shoot at them when they're pissed at Ariel Sharon (for not supporting them enough, etc. However, this restraint is probably no longer exercised since the illegal killing (without trial) by the state of Israel of Sheikh Yassin (did they really need 3 missiles to kill an old man in a wheelchair?)
For those of you insisting this chick isn't a Jew, she isn't. She is, however, a hebrew nationalist.
Paul
June 23rd, 2004, 03:35 PM
Can't we all just get along?
sixpakistan
June 23rd, 2004, 03:36 PM
http://wordofmessiah.org/from_terrorist_to_zionist.htm
what do you think of this?
I think it's comical that you find an occurrence of a single person (from a "biased kike website" - and point to it gleefully as though it's empirical evidence of something (of what, I'm not sure - that there are Palestinian Quislings & collaborators? *gasp*). Are you aware that the PLO is a secular organization, and that 30% of its membership is Christian? Palestinian Christians harbor strong resentment towards Israel, which treats them the same as it does Muslims. This is a large part of why the Vatican refused to recognize Israel for decades. Try this URL:
http://www.natcath.com/NCR_Online/archives/112202/112202r.htm
Or better yet, forget Christians. Let's talk about Jews:
http://www.netureikarta.org
Even better, Israeli Jews. No, Israeli Jewish soldiers:
http://www.seruv.org.il/english/default.asp
sixpakistan
June 23rd, 2004, 03:37 PM
You mean she's all beef, with no fillers or by-products? :confused:
hah :D
that actually made me chuckle
Franco
June 23rd, 2004, 04:56 PM
Ok-
First of all, Israel did not start the 6 day war. According to the Americans and Europeans, when Egypt closed the straits of Tehran in early June 1967,
that was an act of war. Those straits were essential for Israeli shipping, and according to all Western governments, that was the first salvo in the 6 day war. Prior to that, Egypt had evicted the UN troops in Sinai, that had served as a buffer between Egypt and Israel, and had done many other things that clerarly displayed its' intentions. But, again, according to all, Egypt's closing the straits of Tehran was the first salvo of the 6 day war.
Israel never stole anything. Jews returned to their ancient homeland.The West Bank did not belong to any country. It was administered by the jordanians, but only 2 countries, (Brittain and Pakistan, I believe) recognized
Jordanian control of it. The UN had designated much of the West Bank to be Palestinian, but the Palestinians rejected it in 1947. So the land was as much Israel's as anybody elses, by international law. Historically, the only people who made this area of land their homeland was the Jews. Both Jews and Christians believe that God promised this land to the Jews as well.
Having said all of that, if Israel decides in the name of peace, to cede part of the territory to let the Palestinians have their own country, then Israel deserves all the more respect. There is certainly no international precedent for a country to behave so generously.
Israel struck first in the 1967 war. Any other argument is moot. All wars require a first blow, and Israel struck the first blow.
The Jews were simply returning to their ancient homeland by occupying Palestine? That does not wash with most people.
First, if you have ever seen ancient Palestine on a map, you will see that the areas immediately north of Jerusalem were not occupied by Jews. I have a copy of such a map.
Second, by that way of thinking, America should give the entire Mid-West back to the plains Indians, e.g. Oklahoma and Nebraska, because the Indians 'used to live there.' Do you think the U.S. government will give the entire Mid-West back to the Indians?
The very idea that Jews, having lived in some parts of Palestine 2000 years ago, can have Palestinian land upon demand is truly amazing.
[And I won't even mention the hundreds of Arab villages that no longer exist because Israel bulldozed them and then built fancy Jewish homes upon the rubble via American tax dollars].
------
eskaton
June 23rd, 2004, 05:38 PM
Israel struck first in the 1967 war. Any other argument is moot. All wars require a first blow, and Israel struck the first blow.
Going by that same standard, it was in fact the Germans and not the Jews that started WWII, contrary to established WN 'wisdom'.
Bragi
June 23rd, 2004, 06:22 PM
This goyim doesn't recognize the legitimacy or sovereignty of any nation supposedly called "Israel". There simply is no such place, and most of the United Nations agrees. That region is called Palestine and belongs to the Palestinians who have lived there for thousands of years. Using the Holy Babble as evidence of your claim to the "Holy Land" is akin using Dr. Suess's Green Eggs and Ham as a reason to put green food coloring in your scramble eggs. The Holy Babble is a jew book and jews are full of it. Jesus walked on water and Humpty Dumpty fell of the wall. Jews, can't live with 'em, can't live with 'em.
One more thing kikenstein, the vast majority of jews originated in Eastern Europe as Ashkenazi jews who originated from a tribe called the Khazars who coverted to the nomadic, nonsensical, goatherding religion called Judaism. No modern jew is descended from people who ever lived in the region correctly called Palestine. But I don't expect you to modify your insane beliefs in any way since you are a chosenite and one of the circumsized few.
There is no Israel. It's Palestine and always will be. You kikes are just squatters living off the wealth of other nations financial aid. Jews have no home, never did, and deserve none. The Brits should have given you southern Madagascar as was once planned. That way you'd have a country where only the niggers would be bothered with your noxious presence.
Bragi
June 23rd, 2004, 06:30 PM
Going by that same standard, it was in fact the Germans and not the Jews that started WWII, contrary to established WN 'wisdom'.
Wrong. Wrong. Judea declared war on Germany in 1933. Having no actual military because they had no country, the jews war on Germany took other forms. Boycotts, political manipulation, media propaganda, international banking pressure-you know the only kind of war the kikes can wage since all their power is in banking, politics, and the press. A form of war befitting the surreptitious, conniving, and deceptive nature of the jew who can't actually fight directly. It's called "war by other means" and it was quite effective in ruining Germany despite the fact that actual military casualties were not involved. That came later to the detriment of all the white nations involved. Only the jew won WW2.
eskaton
June 23rd, 2004, 07:57 PM
Judea declared war on Germany in 1933. Having no actual military because they had no country, the jews war on Germany took other forms. Boycotts, political manipulation, media propaganda, international banking pressure-you know the only kind of war the kikes can wage since all their power is in banking, politics, and the press. A form of war befitting the surreptitious, conniving, and deceptive nature of the jew who can't actually fight directly. It's called "war by other means" and it was quite effective in ruining Germany despite the fact that actual military casualties were not involved.
Egypt's closing of the straits of Tehran was also "war by other means". See Yihudi's earlier posts for details.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 02:19 AM
Egypt's closing of the straits of Tehran was also "war by other means". See Yihudi's earlier posts for details.
Nasser closed the straits of Tehran as part of a strategy with Sadat to remove the UNEF from Egypt - it really had little to do with Israel. You can say he probably didn't mind goading Israel; however, you can not say it was 'war by other means.'
Yihudi
June 24th, 2004, 07:19 AM
I have so much to write, I don't know where to begin. People like Bragi don't deserve responses, and I won't waste my time with people like him.
1-The entire western world, and even the UN if I am not mistaken, accepted the fact that by closing the straits of Tehran, Egypt was declaring war on Israel. Egypt closing the straits had nothing to do with the UN.The UN had already accepted Nasser's demands that they evacuate Sinai. Clsoing the straits was completely unrelated to the UN.
2-It may be that the Cananites were in the land of Israel before the Jews. But the Cananite people no longer exist. If there was a people who called themselves Cananites, who spoke Cananite, and had a Cananite culture-then maybe you could argue that they had an earlier claim to the land.But there are no Cananites today.Same with the Philistines, (who actually arrived in the land of Israel after the Jews arrived). But it's not relevant, because the sea-faring Philistines, originally from the greek islands, no longer exist. Now all ethnic anthropologists will tell you that the so called Palestinians are descendants of the Arab invaders into the area in the 6th century AD. That is about 1500 years after the Jews had their kingdoms established. And the Jews never renounced their ties to the land.We were forced off the land bby foreign invaders, but we always intended to return to it.We have. Someone brought up the Indians. I the Indians diud muster up an armed force that reclaimed Nebraska and Idaho from the US-would you hae the audacity to say that the land doesn't belong to them? No-because they were there well before Europeans, and then they won a battle fair and square. Winners keepers, especially when it was your land originally.
3-All credible anthropologists will tell you that Ashkenasi (European) Jews are originally from the land of Israel. How do you explain the amazingly close DNA between Ashkenasi and Sephardi (middle eastern) Jews? Also the development of Yiddish proves that eastern european Jews came from the German lands, and not from the Slavik Khazars.There are virtually no Slavic words in Yiddish, which shows the Jews migrated northward, first from Israel to southern and central Europe, and then from there to Eastern europe.
I have to run. More later
Yihudi
June 24th, 2004, 07:49 AM
Ok, to continue;
4) Sixpakistan-(I like your name)-Quoting religious sources ia a dangerous thing. Because even though it does say, in various sources, that God punished Jews by dispersing them, those same sources say that God will return the jews to their land of Israel . We believe God did that with the creation of the state of Israel.I've got a scoop for you, Even the Koran says that. If you want, I'll supply you with verses.
5)-If,as Antiochus suggests, Jews are all give and no take-why did israel give up the Sinai to Egypt in 78 to establish peace with the Egyptians.Why did Barak offer the Palestinians 97% of the disputed territory, with another 3 percent of israeli proper territory for eternal peace. Because Jews are God loving,a nd the Arabs are war mongers. But it's ok, with God's helo, we'll kick their asses every time.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 08:38 AM
I have so much to write, I don't know where to begin. People like Bragi don't deserve responses, and I won't waste my time with people like him.
1-The entire western world, and even the UN if I am not mistaken, accepted the fact that by closing the straits of Tehran, Egypt was declaring war on Israel. Egypt closing the straits had nothing to do with the UN.The UN had already accepted Nasser's demands that they evacuate Sinai. Clsoing the straits was completely unrelated to the UN.
The entire Western world.. you mean, the US & Britain?
Keeping in mind Oren is a biased Jew writer (who was criticized for being 'sympathetic to Nasser' of all things, in Israel):
Michael Oren: They go up to the northern border; they see that there are no Israeli troop concentrations there but Nasser decides to seize on it anyway for a political purpose, not for a military purpose. He sends his army through downtown Cairo parading--if he wanted to attack Israel, he'd do it quietly. That's what Sadat did in 1973. He parades them to the street, marches them in broad daylight into Sinai. He evicts UNEF. Gets rid of the UN forces.
Peter Robinson: Gets rid of the UN forces, which are embarrassing him.
Michael Oren: He closes the Straits of Tehran, the Arab world goes crazy. They have deified Nasser. It's like the old Nasser's back, the Nasser who once kicked the British out of Egypt, he's back. And he is the hero of the day. And what is the world community doing? The UN backs down. The French who were Israel's major arms suppliers, turn around and say to the Israelis sorry we're now going to support the other side. And that left the Americans--now the Americans had an agreement with the Israelis going back to the '56 war that if Nasser ever closed the Straits of Tehran again, the United States would back Israeli military action to reopen the straits. The Americans--President Johnson say to the Israelis listen, we have this agreement but we're bogged down in Vietnam and we can't risk another foreign event so you're on your own. So from Nasser's perspective, Peter, he has taken these incremental steps and has not had to pay any price for it. He's only gained political benefit. The Israelis look like they're completely backing down. So it's a very logical process for him.
Peter Robinson: So it is rattling a saber for political purposes. He is not thinking of waging war? It's obvious he's not thinking of waging war because he's staging parades. He scorns any element of surprise.
2-It may be that the Cananites were in the land of Israel before the Jews. But the Cananite people no longer exist. If there was a people who called themselves Cananites, who spoke Cananite, and had a Cananite culture-then maybe you could argue that they had an earlier claim to the land.But there are no Cananites today.Same with the Philistines, (who actually arrived in the land of Israel after the Jews arrived). But it's not relevant, because the sea-faring Philistines, originally from the greek islands, no longer exist. Now all ethnic anthropologists will tell you that the so called Palestinians are descendants of the Arab invaders into the area in the 6th century AD. That is about 1500 years after the Jews had their kingdoms established. And the Jews never renounced their ties to the land.We were forced off the land bby foreign invaders, but we always intended to return to it.We have. Someone brought up the Indians. I the Indians diud muster up an armed force that reclaimed Nebraska and Idaho from the US-would you hae the audacity to say that the land doesn't belong to them? No-because they were there well before Europeans, and then they won a battle fair and square. Winners keepers, especially when it was your land originally.
When you are forced off of a piece of land for 2000 years, and it changes hands several times during those 2000 years, each time being won back by the Muslims.. you no longer have any ancestral claim to it. Also, the bloody and deceitful methods you used to return were proscribed to you specifically in the Torah. You didn't "win" the land with the help of God, you murdered, lied, cheated, stealed, and bamboozled Wilson, Balfour, and the UN for it.
3-All credible anthropologists will tell you that Ashkenasi (European) Jews are originally from the land of Israel.
Wrong. There is absolutely no proof to this claim, and all evidence is to the contrary.
How do you explain the amazingly close DNA between Ashkenasi and Sephardi (middle eastern) Jews? Also the development of Yiddish proves that eastern european Jews came from the German lands, and not from the Slavik Khazars.There are virtually no Slavic words in Yiddish, which shows the Jews migrated northward, first from Israel to southern and central Europe, and then from there to Eastern europe.
I have to run. More later
The lack of Slavic words in Yiddish can hardly lead one to the conclusion that they originated from Israel. That's a huge stretch of logic.
From a study done by Abraham Lavander (a Jew):
"Although these five markers go back a number of centuries, the Sephardic pattern bears a striking similarity to that of the haplotype used in this study, and a marked contrast to the Ashkenazic pattern, despite conclusions that both Ashkenazi and Sephardi share Near Eastern origins. It seems to this researcher that several Ashkenazim had a Sephardi genetic pattern, and that several Sephardim had an Ashkenazi pattern, probably due to people being absorbed over time into the other culture through migration and/or marriage. Without these cases, the Sephardi-Ashkenazi distinction would be even greater."
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 09:59 AM
Ok, to continue;
4) Sixpakistan-(I like your name)-
Thanks
Quoting religious sources ia a dangerous thing. Because even though it does
Religious sources are the entire basis for the argument that Israel deserves to exist.
say, in various sources, that God punished Jews by dispersing them, those same sources say that God will return the jews to their land of Israel . We
It says it in the Torah (that God punished Jews by dispersing them). The same source says that God will return Jews to Israel, but that they should not seek to do so by worldly means - military, politically, monetarily, etc, for it would "result in strife."
believe God did that with the creation of the state of Israel.I've got a scoop for you, Even the Koran says that. If you want, I'll supply you with verses.
Actually, the Quran says God will bring the Children of Israel together in one group (when the final prophecy comes to pass); nothing more (you're referring to Ayat 104 from Sura Bani Israel, I'm sure).
104. And we said to the Children of Israel afterwards,
"Go live into this land. When the final prophecy
comes to pass, we will summon you all in one group."
Here're a few other things the Quran says about Jews:
4:153-161
153. The people of the scripture
challenge you to bring down to
them a book from the sky!
They have asked Moses for
more than that, saying,
"Show us GOD, physically."
Consequently, the lightning struck
them, as a consequence of their
audacity. Additionally, they worshiped
the calf, after all the miracles they had seen.
Yet, we pardoned all this.
We supported Moses with profound miracles.
154. And we raised Mount Sinai above them,
as we took their covenant.
And we said to them, "Enter the gate humbly."
And we said to them, "Do not desecrate the Sabbath."
Indeed, we took from them a solemn covenant.
155. (They incurred condemnation) for violating their covenant,
rejecting GOD's revelations, killing the prophets unjustly,
and for saying, "Our minds are made up!" In fact,
GOD is the One who sealed their minds, due to their
disbelief, and this is why they fail to believe, except rarely.
156. (They are condemned) for disbelieving and uttering about
Mary a gross lie.
157. And for claiming that they killed the Messiah, Jesus,
son of Mary, the messenger of GOD. In fact,
they never killed him, they never
crucified him-they were made to think that they did.
All factions who are disputing in
this matter are full of doubt
concerning this issue. They possess
no knowledge; they only conjecture.
For certain, they never killed him.*
158. Instead, GOD raised him to Him;
GOD is Almighty, Most Wise.
159. Everyone among the people of
the scripture was required to
believe in him before his death.
On the Day of Resurrection, he
will be a witness against them.
160. Due to their transgressions, we
prohibited for the Jews good foods
that used to be lawful for them;
also for consistently repelling from
the path of GOD.
161. And for practicing usury, which
was forbidden, and for consuming
the people's money illicitly. We
have prepared for the disbelievers
among them painful retribution.
5:12, 5:13:
12. GOD had taken a covenant
from the Children of Israel,
and we raised among them twelve
patriarchs. And GOD said,
"I am with you, so long as you
observe the Contact Prayers (Salat),
give the obligatory charity (Zakat),
and believe in My messengers and
respect them, and continue to lend
GOD a loan of righteousness.
I will then remit your sins,
and admit you into gardens with
flowing streams. Anyone who
disbelieves after this, has indeed
strayed off the right path."
13. It was a consequence of their
violating the covenant that we
condemned them, and we caused their hearts
to become hardened. Consequently,
they took the words out of context,
and disregarded some of the commandments
given to them. You will continue to witness
betrayal from them, excepting a few of them.
You shall pardon them, and disregard them.
GOD loves those who are benevolent.
5)-If,as Antiochus suggests, Jews are all give and no take-why did israel give up the Sinai to Egypt in 78 to establish peace with the Egyptians.Why did
Because
a) Sinai belonged to Egypt prior to the war, they had to give it back by international law, and they didn't want another "Occupied Territory" on their hands
b) Without giving back Sinai, they wouldn't have gotten passage rights through the Suez Canal, the Gulf of Aqaba, and the Strait of Tiran
Barak offer the Palestinians 97% of the disputed territory, with another 3 percent of israeli proper territory for eternal peace.
With their land broken up by settlements (no contiguity), no autonomy, no rights over their own water and resources, etc. Very big of Barak to offer to create Palestinian bantustans.
Because Jews are God loving,a nd the Arabs are war mongers. But it's ok, with God's helo, we'll kick their asses every time.
Sure, Arabs are warmongers. Jews are the peaceniks who were major instigating forces in both WW1 (an unjust war of aggression against Germany by Britain and France, that Jews bamboozled Wilson into getting involved in) & WW2. They're the peaceniks who slaughtered the villages of Deir Yassin, Khan Younis, laid waste to Jenin. The ones whose state executes "criminals" - without trial - by taking out entire city blocks.
By "God" I'm sure you mean "those suckers in the US."
ReturnToZion
June 24th, 2004, 10:10 AM
Ok, to continue;
4) Sixpakistan-(I like your name)-Quoting religious sources ia a dangerous thing. Because even though it does say, in various sources, that God punished Jews by dispersing them, those same sources say that God will return the jews to their land of Israel . We believe God did that with the creation of the state of Israel.I've got a scoop for you, Even the Koran says that. If you want, I'll supply you with verses.
5)-If,as Antiochus suggests, Jews are all give and no take-why did israel give up the Sinai to Egypt in 78 to establish peace with the Egyptians.Why did Barak offer the Palestinians 97% of the disputed territory, with another 3 percent of israeli proper territory for eternal peace. Because Jews are God loving,a nd the Arabs are war mongers. But it's ok, with God's helo, we'll kick their asses every time.
You tell em, yihudi. I could not have said it better
ReturnToZion
June 24th, 2004, 10:15 AM
We don't subscribe to jew filth like freud round these parts, bitch, I mean, cunt, I mean, Ms. pedestrian. I know you're flirting, but that's all the dirty talk you'll get out of me. Talk to Garrett for more steamy Aryan on ersatz jewess chat room action. Maybe you are a jew after all, borrowing from pee wee herman aka paul reubens...jew "I know you are but what am I?"
Very, very clever. You really keep us on our toes. Carry On.
You still haven't answered as to your slip-up by saying ]"OUR[/U] men". Flirting, with you morons? Puleez. I do however like tripping you people up. It amuses me very much. Kind of like a daily vitamin shot. As for dirty talk, you, garrett and the like know it far better than little 'ole me. No thanks. Again, why the slip up? Answer us, pray tell. Who are you really?
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 10:16 AM
A pre-emptive apology for the pasting of the scripture which made the post so lengthy.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 10:18 AM
You still haven't answered as to your slip-up by saying ]"OUR[/U] men". Flirting, with you morons? Puleez. I do however like tripping you people up. It amuses me very much. Kind of like a daily vitamin shot. As for dirty talk, you, garrett and the like know it far better than little 'ole me. No thanks. Again, why the slip up? Answer us, pray tell. Who are you really?
Maybe it was a typo? Can you respond to anything other than that?
ReturnToZion
June 24th, 2004, 10:23 AM
A single South Korean civilian that was in Iraq as a result of and in support of an occupying force is killed by Iraqi resistance, and that's a bigger outrage than what Israel does to Palestinian children - in their own land - every single day?
I have a feeling you weren't shouting about how all's fair in war when Iraq "conquered" Kuwait (a country that Iraq has a FAR stronger claim to historically than Jews do Israel, considering it was part of Iraq not long ago). You were probably one of the many clamoring for the US to send troops to the Gulf, and criticizing Saddam for not obeying the UN (criticism which is undoubtedly muted when it comes to Israel's invasion of Lebanon).
You know what VNN says. "One standard for Jews.."
actually paki, no. I don't support the gulf war.
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 24th, 2004, 10:53 AM
sitting here watching these semites wrangle is like watching hook-noses argue over the price of a carpet in some dusty bazaar. is there any doubt that they should all be expelled from our homelands? I can just see you guys waving your hands and pulling your beards. Ugh.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 11:18 AM
actually paki, no. I don't support the gulf war.
Neither the first, nor the second?
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 11:19 AM
sitting here watching these semites wrangle is like watching hook-noses argue over the price of a carpet in some dusty bazaar. is there any doubt that they should all be expelled from our homelands? I can just see you guys waving your hands and pulling your beards. Ugh.
Not sure if you were including me in that reference, but just to clarify, nobody from the Indian subcontinent is a "semite."
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 24th, 2004, 11:21 AM
Not sure if you were including me in that reference, but just to clarify, nobody from the Indian subcontinent is a "semite."
yep I was. dravidian, whatever you call yourself.
ARYANOUTLAW S.S.
June 24th, 2004, 12:24 PM
What the .... is this scum bag trying to feed you here.Go back to your dish Sub Human. S.S.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 12:26 PM
What the .... is this scum bag trying to feed you here.Go back to your dish Sub Human.
Go back to your trough, sub-animal.
ARYANOUTLAW S.S.
June 24th, 2004, 12:36 PM
I told you to go lay by your dish Sub human.Your not Aryan you stupid ....!!!! HAIL THE TRUE ARYAN RACE WE DO NOT EXCEPT CHEAP IMITATIONS.--- S.S.
ReturnToZion
June 24th, 2004, 12:47 PM
Neither the first, nor the second?
first yes, second no. no need for it without tangible proof of hussein being involved in 9/11 and his posession of WMDs.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 12:50 PM
I told you to go lay by your dish Sub human.Your not Aryan you stupid ....!!!! HAIL THE TRUE ARYAN RACE WE DO NOT EXCEPT CHEAP IMITATIONS.--- S.S.
I don't think I need to do anything here "accept" quote this.
sixpakistan
June 24th, 2004, 12:52 PM
first yes, second no. no need for it without tangible proof of hussein being involved in 9/11 and his posession of WMDs.
Given the reference to Kuwait, I thought it was clear I was talking about the first Gulf War. I'm glad I sought clarification, and didn't give you enough credit to assume you would realize that.
Antiochus Epiphanes
June 25th, 2004, 11:12 AM
see how the rats scurry from a sinking ship? the only jews speaking out against this trend towards war when it counted were the far lefties like Chomsky or Seymour Hersch and the handful that organized antiwar protests. I somehow suspect with all your likudnik platitudes Retard was not one of them.
vBulletin® v3.8.6, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.