ufsrj2
07-01-2004, 07:11 PM
Greetings all,
I understand this is my first post here, but I believe I can hold your attention long enough as, this afternoon, I have uncovered some very startling information received during an interview with a Rabbi, particularly regarding the infamous Kosher tax.
I will begin with some background information on the kosher tax itself and then a bit of background information on the interview and the rabbi.
A very informative link to start you off would be courtesy of the Ukrainian archive, http://ukar.org/tax.html, and I suggest anyone with little knowledge of the actual tax read that. Basically, we gentiles knew it prior to today that there would have to be a tax on goods with those symbols on them, but the question was how much? I have, and you will have, learned something pretty important today regarding the actual tax. Prior I assumed it was only fractions of a cent for each item, just watch.
Now, on to the interview, it was courtesy of a web site known as “Askmoses” (http://www.askmoses.com), though I would ask that if you do use this website for interview purposes, please keep it clean and professional or else it will be almost impossible to gain information from them, as if they discover you are not Jewish your cover is blown. The rabbi that I interviewed was a Rabbi Isser Weisberg, who, under the assumption that I was Jewish, seemed to be a somewhat level headed guy with some pure Jewish credentials (Alumni of a Talmudic university, dean of young woman’s Jewish school in Toronto, etc…) and was willing to talk with me and answer my questions. After the interview got somewhat suspicious and I’m sure he began to feel that I was not Jewish the conversation became very different, and he soon copped out.
So, without further ado, the interview;
“Start Time: Mon Jun 28 16:20:38 PDT 2004
End Time: Mon Jun 28 17:02:19 PDT 2004
______________________________________
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: Welcome. I'll be with you in a moment...what's on
your mind?
ufsrj2: Hi
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: hi
ufsrj2: … I recently discovered, interestingly
enough, a tax on food and non-food products in my kitchen for kosher
products... are you familiar with it?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: tax?
ufsrj2: for example, a big one I see where I live in Colorado, is a U
with a circle around it... signifying the Union of Orthodox Jewish
Congregations
…
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: those are the symbols for the various kashrut
supervision agencies
ufsrj2: common food items, but these kosher companies such as orhodox
union, www.ou.org, that make sure regular food items, such Mr. Clean or
Cap'n Crunch are kosher
ufsrj2: so, how much would you say extra we pay for those with kashrut
supervision agencies symbols on them, if any at all?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: it depends how much supervision is necessary
ufsrj2: I see... for example, dairy products may require more, correct?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: it cost mony to hire and pay kashrut supervisers
ufsrj2: I understand
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: but some items need a lot more supervision
ufsrj2: such as dairy products?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: mr. clean may only require a visit 2 times a year
ufsrj2: I see
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: while milk and meat need full time supervisore
ufsrj2: ah, so they of course would require some extra money for
supervision... understood
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: correct
ufsrj2: so, based on your vast experience and knowledge... how much
extra would you say is paid on an item with one of these symbols so that
we can eat comfartably?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: depends which item
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: a bottle of milk could be quarter
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: mr clean
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: maybe a penny
ufsrj2: hmm... so if I made an assumption of, lets say on a 100 dollar
grocery store run, I would perhaps spend about 15-20 dollars on kosher,
overall, would you say that is perhaps correct?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: if it included meat and dairy products
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: yes
…
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: sorry I gtg now
ufsrj2: well thank you for your time sir
ufsrj2: it was very helpful
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: sure,
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: be well
ufsrj2: you too”
-END OF INTERVIEW-
I, of course, eliminated some of the irrelevant things to keep it short and to the point, however anyone wishing to obtain a full copy of the interview can email me for it (marinecorps@cybertown.com)
Now basically what we see here is huge folks! We are paying upwards of 20% on an average grocery run! I know that this upset me to a great extent and all my friends who have found that they are typically paying upwards of 20%, basically contributions, so that 2% of America (most not even practicing, mind you) can sleep happy…
Nice posting finally, and I hope my first post will have significant relevance.
-Robert Billard
I understand this is my first post here, but I believe I can hold your attention long enough as, this afternoon, I have uncovered some very startling information received during an interview with a Rabbi, particularly regarding the infamous Kosher tax.
I will begin with some background information on the kosher tax itself and then a bit of background information on the interview and the rabbi.
A very informative link to start you off would be courtesy of the Ukrainian archive, http://ukar.org/tax.html, and I suggest anyone with little knowledge of the actual tax read that. Basically, we gentiles knew it prior to today that there would have to be a tax on goods with those symbols on them, but the question was how much? I have, and you will have, learned something pretty important today regarding the actual tax. Prior I assumed it was only fractions of a cent for each item, just watch.
Now, on to the interview, it was courtesy of a web site known as “Askmoses” (http://www.askmoses.com), though I would ask that if you do use this website for interview purposes, please keep it clean and professional or else it will be almost impossible to gain information from them, as if they discover you are not Jewish your cover is blown. The rabbi that I interviewed was a Rabbi Isser Weisberg, who, under the assumption that I was Jewish, seemed to be a somewhat level headed guy with some pure Jewish credentials (Alumni of a Talmudic university, dean of young woman’s Jewish school in Toronto, etc…) and was willing to talk with me and answer my questions. After the interview got somewhat suspicious and I’m sure he began to feel that I was not Jewish the conversation became very different, and he soon copped out.
So, without further ado, the interview;
“Start Time: Mon Jun 28 16:20:38 PDT 2004
End Time: Mon Jun 28 17:02:19 PDT 2004
______________________________________
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: Welcome. I'll be with you in a moment...what's on
your mind?
ufsrj2: Hi
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: hi
ufsrj2: … I recently discovered, interestingly
enough, a tax on food and non-food products in my kitchen for kosher
products... are you familiar with it?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: tax?
ufsrj2: for example, a big one I see where I live in Colorado, is a U
with a circle around it... signifying the Union of Orthodox Jewish
Congregations
…
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: those are the symbols for the various kashrut
supervision agencies
ufsrj2: common food items, but these kosher companies such as orhodox
union, www.ou.org, that make sure regular food items, such Mr. Clean or
Cap'n Crunch are kosher
ufsrj2: so, how much would you say extra we pay for those with kashrut
supervision agencies symbols on them, if any at all?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: it depends how much supervision is necessary
ufsrj2: I see... for example, dairy products may require more, correct?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: it cost mony to hire and pay kashrut supervisers
ufsrj2: I understand
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: but some items need a lot more supervision
ufsrj2: such as dairy products?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: mr. clean may only require a visit 2 times a year
ufsrj2: I see
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: while milk and meat need full time supervisore
ufsrj2: ah, so they of course would require some extra money for
supervision... understood
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: correct
ufsrj2: so, based on your vast experience and knowledge... how much
extra would you say is paid on an item with one of these symbols so that
we can eat comfartably?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: depends which item
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: a bottle of milk could be quarter
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: mr clean
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: maybe a penny
ufsrj2: hmm... so if I made an assumption of, lets say on a 100 dollar
grocery store run, I would perhaps spend about 15-20 dollars on kosher,
overall, would you say that is perhaps correct?
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: if it included meat and dairy products
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: yes
…
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: sorry I gtg now
ufsrj2: well thank you for your time sir
ufsrj2: it was very helpful
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: sure,
Rabbi Isser Weisberg: be well
ufsrj2: you too”
-END OF INTERVIEW-
I, of course, eliminated some of the irrelevant things to keep it short and to the point, however anyone wishing to obtain a full copy of the interview can email me for it (marinecorps@cybertown.com)
Now basically what we see here is huge folks! We are paying upwards of 20% on an average grocery run! I know that this upset me to a great extent and all my friends who have found that they are typically paying upwards of 20%, basically contributions, so that 2% of America (most not even practicing, mind you) can sleep happy…
Nice posting finally, and I hope my first post will have significant relevance.
-Robert Billard