LeVig
August 4th, 2004, 09:08 PM
http://thm-ar1r2.search.vip.scd.yahoo.com/image/499510966
I find it fascinating that in 1943, while having its cities bombed daily, suffering from severe food and materiel (not even enough bullets) shortages, losing entire armies and retreating on at least three fronts--Russian, Italian, North African--Germany had the wherewithal and the spirit to produce an epic film about the Titanic. I haven’t seen it yet, but I like this Amazon reviewer’s “Wagnerian” comments and 5-star rating. His vote count is already suffering because–gasp–he openly states that the German version is vastly superior to any of the shlock, million-dollar Hollywood versions, all of which stole liberally from it.
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
NOTHING CHEESY HERE...., July 25, 2004
Reviewer: Ben (Universal City, CALIFORNIA USA) - See all my reviews
Wouldn't it be fun to run a retrospective on this old tub, since we seem to have all of the major flicks about the old gal available? From this version through the Barbara Stanwick/Clifton Webb, to "A Night to Remember" - WHO shall we say borrowed a bit here and there from this one? Drifting slightly into "Molly Brown" then to the Cameron saga?]
ANYHOW, this one's fun shall we say - since it is basically a propaganda machine from "You know Who's" boys during WW11.
Standard fare - but with this twist - they're all basically there - except for Winslet and Di Caprio - or are they the manicurist and her boyfriend .... ? Just kidding.
The faces are extraordinary - great female beauty as well as superb period costumes [THEN?] Looks like their movie Industry didn't hit a dent at that time.
AND naturally it's all about Greed, Speed, Greed and more greed and pushing the envelope just for one's own ego [Ismay ....] at the risk of so many lives.
NO a great deal can be learnt from this neglected treasure ~ quite Wagnerian if you look closely - almost the final act of the Ring cycle here.
EXCELLENT documentaries attached re "Titanic" and the "Olympic" -more or less a commercial for crossing the pond in comfort.
This one's possibly the definitive version .... pre the the 'disaster' movies of the '70 ties.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0002CHI3S/104-0220115-6673503
I find it fascinating that in 1943, while having its cities bombed daily, suffering from severe food and materiel (not even enough bullets) shortages, losing entire armies and retreating on at least three fronts--Russian, Italian, North African--Germany had the wherewithal and the spirit to produce an epic film about the Titanic. I haven’t seen it yet, but I like this Amazon reviewer’s “Wagnerian” comments and 5-star rating. His vote count is already suffering because–gasp–he openly states that the German version is vastly superior to any of the shlock, million-dollar Hollywood versions, all of which stole liberally from it.
1 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
NOTHING CHEESY HERE...., July 25, 2004
Reviewer: Ben (Universal City, CALIFORNIA USA) - See all my reviews
Wouldn't it be fun to run a retrospective on this old tub, since we seem to have all of the major flicks about the old gal available? From this version through the Barbara Stanwick/Clifton Webb, to "A Night to Remember" - WHO shall we say borrowed a bit here and there from this one? Drifting slightly into "Molly Brown" then to the Cameron saga?]
ANYHOW, this one's fun shall we say - since it is basically a propaganda machine from "You know Who's" boys during WW11.
Standard fare - but with this twist - they're all basically there - except for Winslet and Di Caprio - or are they the manicurist and her boyfriend .... ? Just kidding.
The faces are extraordinary - great female beauty as well as superb period costumes [THEN?] Looks like their movie Industry didn't hit a dent at that time.
AND naturally it's all about Greed, Speed, Greed and more greed and pushing the envelope just for one's own ego [Ismay ....] at the risk of so many lives.
NO a great deal can be learnt from this neglected treasure ~ quite Wagnerian if you look closely - almost the final act of the Ring cycle here.
EXCELLENT documentaries attached re "Titanic" and the "Olympic" -more or less a commercial for crossing the pond in comfort.
This one's possibly the definitive version .... pre the the 'disaster' movies of the '70 ties.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B0002CHI3S/104-0220115-6673503