PDA

View Full Version : Al Pacino Plays Greedy Bloodthirsty Jew Shylock in "Merchant in Venice"


King_Tiger
09-04-2004, 06:33 PM
http://www.comcast.net/News/ENTERTAINMENT//XML/1402_Movies/51ef2516-88ab-47ae-ba21-71e66950dfc2.html

OR

http://www.reuters.co.uk/newsPackageArticle.jhtml?type=entertainmentNews&storyID=577112&section=news

From the first link:

By TOM RACHMAN, Associated Press Writer

VENICE, Italy - Al Pacino growls, grimaces and demands a "pound of flesh" as Jewish moneylender Shylock in a new version of Shakespeare's "The Merchant of Venice." But the actor argued Saturday that the film successfully addresses long-standing controversy over the work's anti-Semitism.

Director Michael Radford _ speaking to reporters after the film's screening at the Venice Film Festival _ added that his picture shouldn't be seen as a tale just about tensions between Christians and Jews, but as a comment on the very modern problem of two cultures at odds.

Radford's production begins with written titles that give context on persecution of the Jews in 16th-century Venice. It closes with a shot of the broken, tormented Shylock being locked in the ghetto that restricted Jews to a tiny quarter of the city.

Pacino had never thought he would play Shylock. But "I accepted it because I thought that Michael Radford had put together a script that addressed certain issues that were important to deal with," he said.

"I thought it was a character to play that could reflect a human experience. And that to me was more important. Because there's controversy over this type of material throughout the years, and I thought that Michael Radford's script addressed that," Pacino said. "As soon as I read it, I thought, now I can do 'The Merchant of Venice.'"

Shakespeare's play tells of an anti-Semitic merchant (Jeremy Irons) who is bound by contract to give a pound of his flesh to Shylock for failing to repay a loan. However, it is Shylock who ultimately faces ruin when a court rules against him, humiliating and ruining the man.

The play has long sparked debate. It contains Shylock's eloquent expression of the pain of anti-Jewish prejudice _ "If you prick us, do we not bleed?" he asks in a famous soliloquy. It also casts him in the ugly anti-Semitic stereotype of a greedy, bloodthirsty Jew.
..................................................................................

Radford... Jew? Well, either way, I don't see how Shakespeare intended Shylock to be a character that the audience has compassion for, or if he ever suggested that Jews don't deserve to be treated like shit. It seems as though Shakespeare was jew-aware and created such a sinister, vile creature that best represents the international jew that still lives on today. Shylock got what he deserved no matter how you slice it, this is just a stupid new interpretation designed yet again for the audience to pity the jew.

Also, from the Reuters link:Director Michael Radford, best known for the Oscar-nominated Italian drama "Il Postino," ("The Postman") opens the film with a depiction of the ghetto in which Venice's Jews were forced to live and shows Shylock getting slapped by Irons' Antonio -- who eventually begs him for a loan -- for no apparent reason.Lol. That's fuckin sweet.

sean(doc)martin
09-04-2004, 09:23 PM
So in the movie “get Shorty” was John Travoltas character (shylock) Jewish?

N.B. Forrest
09-04-2004, 11:53 PM
Pacino seems to have made a habit of appearing in films that show Schmucky in a less than flattering light: "Godfather 2", "The Merchant of Venice", and another one a while back the name of which escapes me. Just tonight, I saw him in "Carlito's Way", an excellent movie about a Puerto Rican ex-con who tries to go straight, but who is betrayed by his kinky-headed kike lawyer (he gets an appropriate revenge).

Stan Sikorski
09-05-2004, 04:00 AM
fucked up I know but the feeling I get about all this is that Al wants to put it out there, as a respected actor, showing what jews are like, so that we may target them easier. I may be wrong but I havent seen the finished product yet.

Abzug Hoffman
09-05-2004, 11:14 AM
[QUOTE=Stan Sikorski]fucked up I know but the feeling I get about all this is that Al wants to put it out there, as a respected actor, showing what jews are like, so that we may target them easier. I may be wrong but I havent seen the finished product yet.[/QUOTE]

All I need to see is the credits to know what is going on here:

"Radford's production begins with written titles that give context on persecution of the Jews in 16th- century Venice. It closes with a shot of the broken, tormented Shylock being locked in the ghetto that restricted Jews to a tiny quarter of the city."