View Full Version : Can Jew Mises be Baptized?
Mike Parker
July 20th, 2009, 10:09 AM
Sunday, November 09, 2008
Can Mises be Baptized?
There is no doubt that the Catholic Church supports the idea of a just social order, and has expounded on that order in the great Social Encyclicals. However, and despite more than 100 years of constant Papal teaching on this subject, the average Catholic—indeed, the average Bishop—is confused about it meaning or even unaware of its existence. Most preaching concerns personal sin without ever considering the social implications or connecting sin to a violation of a just social order. And yet, this is strange, since what makes a sin sinful is that it violates what the right order between a person and his neighbor and his God. Without a violation of this order, a thing cannot be sinful. This is expressed negatively in the Ten Commandments (“Thou shalt not kill, steal, covet, etc.”) and positively in the Sermon on the Mount (“do good to those who harm you...” etc.) However, rather than stress the social damage that sin causes, preaching most commonly connects it only with our ultimate destiny to heaven or hell. And while this is legitimate in itself, it strips Catholic teaching of its more immediate values.
Church teaching does not, by itself, dictate a particular social or economic system; it only lays down the criteria by which any social or economic system is to be judged. It is up to the laity to devise systems in their own social and historical context that meet with the criteria. Most often, this task is refused. It is not that Catholics are not heavily involved in the political and social life of the nation. But often that involvement is disconnected with their religious beliefs and with Church teaching. Many such examples can be found on the left, but the greatest example can be found on the right, specifically the attempt to baptize the essentially pagan economics of Ludwig von Mises and the Austrian School.
Much of the Catholic intelligentsia has surrendered to this doctrine. The Austrian Catholic right boasts names like Michael Novak, George Weigel, Thomas Woods, Murry Rothbard, to name but a few. Further, these scholars are supported by well-funded institutes such as the Acton Institute, the American Enterprise Institute, the Ethics and Public Policy Institute, the Liberty Foundation, and a host of others. Money flows like water for these people, usually corporate money, water largely used in an attempt to baptize Mises. Still, there is one scholar who was absolute in his opposition to such a notion, who declared, over and over again, the fundamental opposition between the Austrian School and any genuine understanding of Christianity.
That scholar was Ludwig von Mises.
Mises recognized that Austrian order and Catholic order would always be at odds. “A living Christianity,” said Mises, “cannot exist side by side with, and within, Capitalism” (Quoted in Jorg Guido Hulmann, Mises, the Last Knight of Liberalism, p. 982). Later in his career, Mises would allow that Christianity could exist within capitalism, but only if the Christians kept their opinions to themselves, only if they were marginalized and kept apart from the political and economic orders. As Murry Rothbard admits, Mises considered himself a “man of 1789, an heir of the Enlightenment, (http://www.lewrockwell.com/rothbard/rothbard169.html),” that is, a man of the French Revolution. And the great advantage of the French Revolution was that it destroyed the older social order in general and the social authority of the Church in particular. As Mises himself put it, “for us and for humanity there is only one salvation: return to the rationalistic liberalism of the ideas of 1789.”
Mises's antipathy towards Christianity begins with his disdain for its founder.
[Jesus] rejects everything that exists without offering anything to replace it. He arrives at dissolving all existing social ties…. The motive force behind the purity and power of this complete negation is ecstatic inspiration and enthusiastic hope of a new world. Hence his passionate attack upon everything that exists. Everything may be destroyed because God in His omnipotence will rebuild the future order…. The clearest modern parallel to the attitude of complete negation of primitive Christianity is Bolshevism. (Socialism, p. 413)
Another thing about Jesus that rankles Mises is his attitude towards the Rich:
Jesus's words are full of resentment against the rich, and the Apostles are no meeker in this respect. The Rich Man is condemned because he is rich, the Beggar praised because he is poor…. In God's Kingdom the poor shall be rich, but the rich shall be made to suffer. Later revisers have tried to soften the words of Christ against the rich … but there is quite enough left to support those who incite the world to hatred of the rich, revenge, murder and arson…. This is a case in which the Redeemer's words bore evil seed. More harm has been done, and more blood shed, on account of them than by the persecution of heretics and the burning of witches. They have always rendered the Church defenceless against all movements which aim at destroying human society. The church as an organization has certainly always stood on the side of those who tried to ward off communistic attack. But it … was continually disarmed by the words: “Blessed be ye poor; for yours is the Kingdom of God.” (Socialism, p. 420)
Mises rejects Christian love as the basis of social order, and reduces it to self-interest and the fear of violence:
Social cooperation has nothing to do with personal love or with a general commandment to love one another… [People] cooperate because this best serves their own interests. Neither love nor charity nor any other sympathetic sentiment but rightly understood selfishness is what originally impelled man to adjust himself to the requirements of society…and to substitute peaceful collaboration to enmity and conflict. (Human Action, p. 168-9)
Now, one may agree or disagree with Mises in all of this, but in either case it simply cannot be reconciled with Catholic Social Teaching. It is not even, as Murray Rothbard notes, conservative in any possible meaning of that term. It is, rather, the quintessence of Enlightenment Liberalism, the French Revolution continued in our day.
The surrender to the Enlightenment among Catholic intellectuals on the right is more or less complete. For example, Michael Novak, a nominal Catholic, notes that an attempt “to try to run an economy by the highest Christian principles is certain to destroy both the economy and the reputation of Christianity” (The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism, p. 70). For Novak, there is no sacred canopy that covers society, but only an “empty altar” in which each man places the idols of his own choosing. Religion in this case is not really the repository of truth, but merely a consumer product giving the purchasers whatever satisfactions they desire; theology gets replaced by marketing. This narrowing of the sacred, Novak tells us, requires “not only a new theology but a new type of religion” (Novak, p. 69). Not that Christianity would be done away with; it would be allowed to modify itself to conform to the new ideology:
Yet if Jewish and Christian conceptions of human life are sound, and if they fit the new social order of pluralism, the widespread nostalgia for a traditional form of social order may be resisted…For the full exercise of their humanity, being both finite and sinful, free persons require pluralist institutions (Novak, p. 69-70).
For this “new theology” and “new religion,” Novak finds it necessary to drain Christian dogmas of their original meaning and convert them into mere supports for corporate capitalism. The Trinity, for example, is only a “symbol,” since “no one has ever seen God” (Novak, p. 337). The point of this symbolic Trinity is to teach us about pluralism. The Incarnation is the sign of religious futility: it is no longer the salvific act of a loving God but the ultimate demonstration of the futility of good intentions.
The point of the Incarnation is to respect the world as it is, to acknowledge its limits… and to disbelieve any promises that the world is now or ever will be transformed into the City of God. If Jesus could not effect that, how shall we? ...The world is not going to become—ever—a kingdom of justice and love (Novak, p. 341).
I might point out to Mr. Novak that Jesus isn't dead yet, or rather, he isn't dead again, despite the neoconservative attempts to kill him off. He lives on in his Eucharist and in His Church, but the life of His Church waxes and wanes with the faith of His followers, and with their ability to transform the gospel from the printed page to the social order. But this is not likely to happen so long as the Austrian neoconservatives have such sway in Catholic intellectual circles. What is needed is a revolt of the masses in favor of the Mass, and for making the Eucharistic vision a part of social, economic, and political life. What is needed is what Benedict XVI calls Eucharistic consistency. For this we have a model. Not indeed a modern model, but an effective one nevertheless. She was not an intellectual; indeed she was a mere peasant girl. But she was given, in a single instance, a vision of the full meaning of the Incarnation and its social implications. She gave full answer to the neoconservatives, to both Mises and Marx. Her words were:
My soul magnifies the Lord, my spirit rejoices in God my savior.
For he has looked with favor on his lowly servant.
Behold! From this day all generations will call me blessed; The almighty has done great things for me and holy is his name.
He has mercy on those who fear him in every generation.
He has shown the strength of his arm, he has scattered the proud in their conceit.
He has cast down the mighty from their thrones and lifted up the lowly.
He has filled the hungry with good things while the rich he has sent away empty.
He has come to the help of his servant Israel, for he has remembered his promise of mercy, the promise he made to our fathers, to Abraham and his children forever.
On their best days, neither Mises nor Marx wrote anything this good. All the money in corporate capitalism cannot buy a single drop of holy water with which to baptize Ludwig von Mises, and Mises would be the first to agree. The attempt to do so has made the Catholic politics of the right incoherent and therefore rendered it impotent; at best account, it is a mere appendage to corporate capitalism.
Posted by John Médaille at 11/09/2008 10:23:00 AM
http://distributism.blogspot.com/2008/11/can-mises-be-baptized_09.html
Curious
July 20th, 2009, 12:28 PM
Ludwig von Mises: the kosher Nietzsche. Here is the nexus between WN/NS and Conservatism.
BTW, how does Distributism prevent 'degeneration' into feudalism, capitalism or socialism? I mean, suppose the crops of the family farm fail, can the homesteader sell his farm to a rich farmer, and become a farmhand, or can he expect a handout from the government?
Alex Linder
July 20th, 2009, 01:16 PM
All the soul-saving done by Catholics over 2,000 years never produced 1/1000th the solace provided by the greed-driven corporate selfishista who invented the air conditioner.
All the market needs is the restraint of a racial nation, to be redundant. Within that context, the Catholics can go off and found their own communities, if they wish to live as serfs and monks. Me, no thanks. I'm willing to fight not to live in a Catholic nation. Get your jeboo off my property or I'll turn the hose on it.
Alex Linder
July 20th, 2009, 01:17 PM
Everybody wants to distribute, nobody wants to produce.
Alex Linder
July 20th, 2009, 01:20 PM
Capitalism worked just fine up until 1965 when the jews overturned immigration law. At the very height of capitalism, in the 20s, before all the socialism set in, there were no capitalist firms at all puling for open borders at the Congressional debate - there were only kikes fresh off the boat sneering at nativists who succeeded in keeping the US White for another forty years. Blaming capitalism for failed politics is exactly like blaming guns instead of niggers. Capitalism is an engine. It can be constrained to power a weedeater or a world empire. All depends what the people in charge want.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 20th, 2009, 01:32 PM
Here is a working link for the Rothbard article:
http://www.lewrockwell.com/rothbard/rothbard169.html
What is the complaint? Those wanting to renounce, to live on voluntary communes will be free to do so. Nothing, including capitalism, markets, fractional reserve, or religion will be crammed down anyone's throat.
btw Austrian economics was founded by (Gentile) Carl Menger:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Menger
Rick Ronsavelle
July 20th, 2009, 01:57 PM
October 21-24, 2009
Salamanca, Spain
Supporters Summit 2009 and Awarding of Schlarbaum Prize for Lifetime Achievement in Liberty
"One of the great discoveries of the 20th century concerns the origins of economic science in the late middle ages in Spain and Italy. Long before Adam Smith wrote, many scholastics from the 14th through the 17th centuries were writing systematic economic theory.
No spot on the planet was as fruitful as the School of Salamanca in Spain. Here was the world center of economic research. The writings by the intellectuals gathered here explained price, value, money and its function, saving, entrepreneurship, inflation, contract and exchange, and so much more - and they closely engaged the modern world that was being born at that time, providing at theory and a rationale for the rise of prosperity.
As Murray Rothbard demonstrated in his tremendous treatise on the history of thought, these thinkers were the predecessors to modern Austrian School theory.
What's more, the late scholastics of the School of Salamanca agreed on the damage that government intervention did in the course of economic affairs. They saw the blessings of liberty as an extension of the blessings of God. Therefore, there is a sense in which Salamanca is also the origin of modern libertarian theory."
http://mises.org/events/118
Mike Parker
July 21st, 2009, 08:27 AM
NS, Catholic distributism and Islamic Sharia all have similar views on usury and financial speculation. These are very different systems of ideas but what they have in common is that their societies stress the community over the individual. If you look at the ideas and societies that favor usury and speculation, you find: diaspora Jews like Mises, who use them as weapons of ethnic warfare; Calvinists, who emulated Jews as a function of their religion; and today's secular liberalism, in which people emulate Jews as a function of the Jewed culture.
Alex Linder
July 21st, 2009, 10:14 AM
The Nazis were wrong on speculation. Speculation is precisely what you need to develop minds sharp enough to defeat the jews. Speculation makes sharp minds because they must be completely attuned to reality, whereas the religious mindset weakens minds because it keeps them floating in fantasy.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 10:42 AM
"...stress the community over the individual. . ."
This means state coercion is stressed over the individual. This derives from the anti-rational epistemology of socialism.
Anti-individual means anti-reason, and anti-reality. The Nazis openly attack reason.
Alex Linder
July 21st, 2009, 11:27 AM
"...stress the community over the individual. . ."
This means state coercion is stressed over the individual. This derives from the anti-rational epistemology of socialism.
Anti-individual means anti-reason, and anti-reality. The Nazis openly attack reason.
It's easy to let what exists blind us to what could be. The technology we now have, combined with the economic and racial knowledge we now have, points out what is entirely possible - whites living in small, independent states, federalized for racial defense.
The religious faith in regulation will not bear intellectual scrutiny any more than the Jesus myth.
WN who want totalitarianism are as uninterested in economic laws as libertarians are uninterested in racial laws.
Alex Linder
July 21st, 2009, 11:44 AM
WN divides into those with a loser mentality and those with a winner mentality.
The loser mentality wants the same kind of government we have now, without the jews and the niggers they privilege.
The winners don't want that. They recognize that government is demonstrably defective every single one of its functions, hence close to unnecessary. White men + freedom + technology = no need for government. All we need from federal or national government is racial defense. Below that, the form that fits white men is decentralization. Let them pick the kind of state they want to live in. Let the losers set up a microstate in which they duplicate the failed 'public schooling' + democracy we enjoy now. I and many others will go the other way - no welfare, no government schools, no million regulatory bodies, no taxes.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 12:28 PM
Actually, no economy can run without speculation. Some Soviet economists came to the 'Kwa in the sixties, saying that they could not allocate (ration) crops over the year, and that they wanted to know how we did it.
And the answer is- futures markets.
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 12:54 PM
Capitalism worked just fine up until 1965 when the jews overturned immigration law. At the very height of capitalism, in the 20s, before all the socialism set in, there were no capitalist firms at all puling for open borders at the Congressional debate - there were only kikes fresh off the boat sneering at nativists who succeeded in keeping the US White for another forty years.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the "Asian Exclusion Acts" that were passed in the U.S. and Canada in the early 20th Century were enacted under pressure from socialist groups and parties, who were concerned that letting Asians in would make it impossible for white workers to earn decent living wages. It was the capitalists (for lack of a better word) who were bringing the Asians here for cheap labor.
Not that different to the situation today with Mexicans being brought in for cheap labor (though with "free trade," companies can just move their operations offshore and don't have to bother bringing people in anymore).
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 01:00 PM
btw Austrian economics was founded by (Gentile) Carl Menger:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Menger
I'm starting to wonder if jews have ever been given credit for an idea that wasn't taken from a gentile.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 01:21 PM
I've wondered the same. The second Austrian was goy Eugen von Bohm-Bawerk-
"The first volume of Capital and Interest, which Ludwig von Mises decreed as "the most eminent contribution to modern economic theory", titled History and Critique of Interest Theories (1884), is an exhaustive study of the alternative treatments of interest: use theories, productivity theories, abstinence theories, and so on."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugen_von_Böhm-Bawerk
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 01:25 PM
Got the dates wrong in my previous post; those acts were passed in the late 19th Century, not the early 20th. :o
From Wikipedia (bearing in mind that Wikipedia has an anti-white bias):
The Chinese Exclusion Act was a United States federal law passed on May 6, 1882, following revisions made in 1880 to the Burlingame Treaty of 1868. Those revisions allowed the U.S. to suspend immigration, and Congress subsequently acted quickly to implement the suspension of Chinese immigration, a ban that was intended to last 10 years.
The Chinese came to America in larger numbers during the 1848 California Gold Rush and in the 1860s when the Central Pacific Railroad recruited large labor gangs to build its portion of the Transcontinental Railroad. Large-scale immigration continued into the late 1800s, with 123,201 Chinese recorded as arriving between 1871 and 1880, and 61,711 arriving between 1881 and 1890.
At first, when surface gold was plentiful, the Chinese were well tolerated and well-received.[1] As gold became harder to find and competition increased, animosity to the Chinese and other foreigners increased. After being forcibly driven from the mines, most Chinese settled in enclaves in cities, mainly San Francisco, and took up low end wage labor such as restaurant work and laundry. With the post Civil War economy in decline by the 1870s, anti-Chinese animosity became politicized by labor leader Dennis Kearney and his Workingman's Party[2] as well as by California Governor John Bigler, both of whom blamed Chinese "coolies" for depressed wage levels. Another significant anti-Chinese group organized in California during this same era was the Supreme Order of Caucasians with some 64 chapters statewide.
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 01:30 PM
It's no doubt a great embarrassment to socialists and leftists today that the original socialists/labor movements were racist as hell, just as it no doubt embarrasses modern feminists that most of the "first wave" feminists were racist. Didn't Karl Marx have some unkind things to say about niggers as well?
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 01:41 PM
This is why I was confused about the dates:
The Chinese Immigration Act, 1923, known in the Chinese Canadian community as the Chinese Exclusion Act,[1] was an act passed by the federal government of Canada, banning most forms of Chinese immigration to Canada. Immigration from most countries was controlled or restricted in some way, but only the Chinese were so completely prohibited from immigrating.
Prior to 1923, Chinese immigration was already heavily controlled by the Chinese Immigration Act of 1885, which imposed a hefty head tax on all immigrants from China. After various members of the federal and some provincial governments (especially British Columbia) put pressure on the federal government to discourage Chinese immigration, the Chinese Immigration Act was passed.
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 01:47 PM
There's a booklet by Robert Jarvis called The Workingman's Revolt: The Vancouver Asiatic Exclusion Rally of 1907, and a few years ago there was an excellent article on this subject by Paul Fromm in Ed Field's newspaper. Haven't had any luck finding copies online, though.
Alex Linder
July 21st, 2009, 02:27 PM
Actually, no economy can run without speculation. Some Soviet economists came to the 'Kwa in the sixties, saying that they could not allocate (ration) crops over the year, and that they wanted to know how we did it.
And the answer is- futures markets.
Yes.
The illusion of knowledge, as someone called it, if I remember correctly, is especially popular. Generally speaking, the dumber the man, the more certain he is that a thing can be done easily.
Alex Linder
July 21st, 2009, 02:37 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the "Asian Exclusion Acts" that were passed in the U.S. and Canada in the early 20th Century were enacted under pressure from socialist groups and parties, who were concerned that letting Asians in would make it impossible for white workers to earn decent living wages. It was the capitalists (for lack of a better word) who were bringing the Asians here for cheap labor.
Not that different to the situation today with Mexicans being brought in for cheap labor (though with "free trade," companies can just move their operations offshore and don't have to bother bringing people in anymore).
There will always be those will put money ahead of their race. But if those who put their race first are in power, and if the penalties are severe enough, the minority of business owners willing to sell out its community will constrain its activity. What I guess most here or many here don't understand is that there are iron laws of economics/business like anything else. You simply cannot stay in business once a globalized environment has been created or allowed by the powers that be. Either you adjust or die. Then we have guys pointing to businesses following, rather than driving, the globalization as the main cause of the problem. It is not so. The cause of the problem was jews who wanted to supplant the white population with coloreds. They took full power in the sixties and promptly opened the borders, but not just that, remade the entire social and legal environment, pushing globalization and diversity. Corporate America is forced to go along with that, whether it likes it is or not. I mean that literally and legally.
As for pre-1900 stuff, remember that there were very few people in the U.S. There was great desire for labor of any kind, low cost or otherwise. But yes, at that time, there was still enough White sentiment to force certain employers to put their country ahead of their profits. My understanding is those White forces were led by Irish, and those Irish themselves were newcomers to the US, most of them.
Business will adapt itself to whatever rules the rulers set down. What makes it possible, nay, inevitable that business take a huge hand in politics is precisely the expansion of government until it takes up 50% of the economy and there is no way for business not to be involved with it. That's when the lobbies start up and you get the revolving door.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 03:10 PM
Chinese workers were needed on this GOVERNMENT project:
"The Pony Express from 1860 to 1861 was to prove that the Central Nevada Route across Nevada and Utah and the sections of the Oregon Trail across Wyoming and Nebraska was viable during the winter. With the American Civil War raging and a secessionist movement in California gaining steam, the apparent need for the railroad became more urgent.
In 1861 Curtis again introduced a bill to establish the railroad, but it did not pass. After the secession of the southern states, the House of Representatives on May 6, 1862, and the Senate on June 20 finally approved it. Lincoln signed it into law on July 1. The act established the two main lines -- the Central Pacific from the west and the Union Pacific from the mid-west. Other rail lines were encouraged to build feeder lines.
Each was required to build only 50 miles (80 km) in the first year; after that, only 50 miles (80 km) more were required each year. Each railroad was subsidized $16,000 per mile ($9,940/km) built over an easy grade, $32,000 per mile ($19,880/km) in the high plains, and $48,000 per mile ($29,830/km) in the mountains. To allow the railroads to raise additional money Congress provided additional assistance to the railroad companies in the form of land grants of federal lands. They were granted 400-foot right-of-ways plus ten square miles of land (ten sections) adjacent to the track for every mile of track built. To avoid a railroad monopoly on good land, the land was not given away in a continuous swath but in a "checkerboard" pattern leaving Federal land in between that could be purchased from the government. The land grant railroads, receiving millions of acres of public land, sold bonds based on the value of the lands, sold the land to settlers, used the money to build their railroads, and contributed to a rapid settlement of the West. [6] The race was on to see which railroad company could build the longest section of track and receive the most land and subsidy."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroad
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 05:10 PM
You simply cannot stay in business once a globalized environment has been created or allowed by the powers that be. Either you adjust or die.
I recognize that some businessmen are good, ethical people, while others are amoral scumbags. Some businessmen pushed for "free trade," while others avoided going offshore as long as they could. I guess what differentiates me from the typical modern leftist is that I don't consider businessmen to be inherently evil, and I don't subscribe to this dichotomy of "government = good" and "private sector = evil." There was nothing severely wrong that I can see with American-style capitalism until the 60's, when everything started being pushed offshore.
I'm not a big supporter of socialism or of government regulation or intervention in the markets (though explaining that to people, especially women, is an uphill struggle which often seems hopeless -- try explaining to a Frenchman, a Briton, or a Canadian why their "free" healthcare system is bad and see how far you get), but I do think that socialism (or more accurately, the labor movement) at one time may have been a necessary counterweight to "corporate" power. If it weren't for the labor movement, wouldn't we still have 7-year-olds working 14 hour shifts in factories under deplorable conditions (kinda like in the Third World today)?
Much of this is a moot point now, though, since eventually it's going to be cheaper and yield higher quality to build everything using computerized robots than to employ humans, even at slave wages. Once that happens, the world's going to have an awful lot of "useless eaters" on its hands.
Igor Alexander
July 21st, 2009, 05:26 PM
Here are two hypothetical scenarios that I'd be curious in hearing a response to from those who think government has no business regulating or interfering in anything:
1. A factory is dumping highly toxic chemical by-products into a nearby river, polluting it and harming the wildlife. The factory is legally allowed to do this because the government doesn't have the authority to interfere in its affairs. A citizen's group mounts a boycott of the factory's products, and though the boycott has an impact, there are still too many people buying the products to persuade the factory to stop doing this.
2. Some greedy fishermen, more interested in short-term profit than in the long-term viability of their trade, decide to fish until certain fish stocks are completely depleted.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 05:28 PM
"try explaining to a Frenchman, a Briton, or a Canadian why their "free" healthcare system is bad and see how far you get)"
>>"Six per cent of people in a large survey in England said they had to treat their own dental problems themselves, because they could not get professional treatment - this included pulling out their own teeth."
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/85552.php
"So the people have not yet said: socialized medicine is obviously a political program, not a health program, that was imposed on Canadians by fiscal bribery of the provinces and legal trickery (health care is constitutionally off-limits to the feds).
Nor have they said: the consequent waiting lists for services, the many thousands tripping to the U.S. for care that isn't available here, the closing of whole hospital wings despite high demand, the selective care now in place (we'll treat young, not old, this illness, but not that), the "delisting" of formerly covered services - all this results in a system which is profoundly immoral because it converts the ethic of direct Hippocratic medicine (by which formerly free physicians would do their utmost to heal all patients) into a veterinary ethic by which the quality and amount of care and resources available is now controlled by a master. A political master. In a crunch, we end up with the medical freedom of animals."
http://www.williamgairdner.com/the-failure-of-socialized-medi/
"If it weren't for the labor movement, wouldn't we still have 7-year-olds working 14 hour shifts in factories under deplorable conditions (kinda like in the Third World today)?"
No.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 21st, 2009, 05:48 PM
1. A factory is dumping highly toxic chemical by-products into a nearby river, polluting it and harming the wildlife. The factory is legally allowed to do this because the government doesn't have the authority to interfere in its affairs. A citizen's group mounts a boycott of the factory's products, and though the boycott has an impact, there are still too many people buying the products to persuade the factory to stop doing this.
2. Some greedy fishermen, more interested in short-term profit than in the long-term viability of their trade, decide to fish until certain fish stocks are completely depleted.
This is tragedy-of-the-commons. Who owns the river?
Dumping would be viewed as a rights violation of the owner. The government in the 19th century allowed this- they were wrong.
Fishing rights should sold to highest bidder. The fishing areas would be viewed as a capital asset. If all the fish are gone, the asset value goes to zero, giving incentive not to over-fish.
Lots and lots of information is available on these matters. Garrett Hardin is the father of tragedy of the commons idea.
http://www.garretthardinsociety.org/articles/art_who_benefits_who_pays.html
Curious
July 22nd, 2009, 03:57 AM
October 21-24, 2009
Salamanca, Spain
Supporters Summit 2009 and Awarding of Schlarbaum Prize for Lifetime Achievement in Liberty
"One of the great discoveries of the 20th century concerns the origins of economic science in the late middle ages in Spain and Italy. Long before Adam Smith wrote, many scholastics from the 14th through the 17th centuries were writing systematic economic theory.
No spot on the planet was as fruitful as the School of Salamanca in Spain. Here was the world center of economic research. The writings by the intellectuals gathered here explained price, value, money and its function, saving, entrepreneurship, inflation, contract and exchange, and so much more - and they closely engaged the modern world that was being born at that time, providing at theory and a rationale for the rise of prosperity.
As Murray Rothbard demonstrated in his tremendous treatise on the history of thought, these thinkers were the predecessors to modern Austrian School theory.
What's more, the late scholastics of the School of Salamanca agreed on the damage that government intervention did in the course of economic affairs. They saw the blessings of liberty as an extension of the blessings of God. Therefore, there is a sense in which Salamanca is also the origin of modern libertarian theory."
http://mises.org/events/118
Those scholastics didn't understand that the very notion of Economic Laws is at odds with Free Will. Maybe those scholastics were Marranos:)
The Nazis were wrong on speculation. Speculation is precisely what you need to develop minds sharp enough to defeat the jews. Speculation makes sharp minds because they must be completely attuned to reality, whereas the religious mindset weakens minds because it keeps them floating in fantasy.
There is no reason to make a principled distinction between speculation and other economic activities. Alex Linder is right in that, and NS wrong.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 08:51 AM
"try explaining to a Frenchman, a Briton, or a Canadian why their "free" healthcare system is bad and see how far you get)"
>>"Six per cent of people in a large survey in England said they had to treat their own dental problems themselves, because they could not get professional treatment - this included pulling out their own teeth."
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/85552.php
"So the people have not yet said: socialized medicine is obviously a political program, not a health program, that was imposed on Canadians by fiscal bribery of the provinces and legal trickery (health care is constitutionally off-limits to the feds).
Nor have they said: the consequent waiting lists for services, the many thousands tripping to the U.S. for care that isn't available here, the closing of whole hospital wings despite high demand, the selective care now in place (we'll treat young, not old, this illness, but not that), the "delisting" of formerly covered services - all this results in a system which is profoundly immoral because it converts the ethic of direct Hippocratic medicine (by which formerly free physicians would do their utmost to heal all patients) into a veterinary ethic by which the quality and amount of care and resources available is now controlled by a master. A political master. In a crunch, we end up with the medical freedom of animals."
http://www.williamgairdner.com/the-failure-of-socialized-medi/
Rick: My point was that government health care programs have tremendous popular support, not that they are the best way of providing health care. That is a political reality, whether you like it or not. Seriously, try talking to some Canadians, especially the roughly 50% of the population that don't have penises between their legs. Most of them would sooner die than give up these programs. If anything, European countries are worse in this regard.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 08:55 AM
Fishing rights should sold to highest bidder.
Sold to the highest bidder by whom?
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 09:00 AM
This is tragedy-of-the-commons. Who owns the river?
That doesn't really answer my question. If your answer is that government shouldn't allow this sort of thing to go on, then you have right there admitted that in some cases government should interfere in how people conduct business.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 09:15 AM
"If it weren't for the labor movement, wouldn't we still have 7-year-olds working 14 hour shifts in factories under deplorable conditions (kinda like in the Third World today)?"
No.
LOL. Care to be more specific? What brought an end to child labor practices in the West if not pressure from the left (the old-school left, not the Cultural Marxism that passes for leftism these days)?
Alex talks a lot about distinguishing WN from conservatism, and yet I'm finding his (and your) stance on economics almost indistinguishable from conservatism/libertarianism.
Just to be clear, I consider myself to be neither a conservative nor a leftist on economic matters; I am a nationalist. I think economic policies should be subjugated to the national interest (and my brand of nationalism, obviously, takes race into account and is not just the empty wordism of the patriotards). That should be the guiding principle behind everything.
I'd also like to throw out the following ideas:
1. That capitalism and a free market are not necessarily the same thing.
2. That what we have now is to a large extent what one could call monopoly capitalism, and is not a free market at all (I acknowledge that Alex already touched on this by mentioning the "revolving door"; what most leftists don't get is that Big Business wants government regulation, at least when it works in its favor).
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 09:46 AM
BTW, I don't see why we're even having this debate. Alex's vision, if I understand it correctly, is to have a very limited central government, and let communities govern themselves however they see fit.
That way, if a community wants to try an Adam Smith economy, it is free to do so. If it wants high taxes, a large, intrusive government bureaucracy, and lots of public services, it is also free to do so. To each his own.
The important questions, then, are how much power a central government should have, and what its areas of authority should be. Alex mentioned defense. Is there anything else?
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 10:19 AM
The Global Financial Crisis and the Vindication of Economic Nationalism (http://bnp.org.uk/2008/10/the-global-financial-crisis-and-the-vindication-of-economic-nationalism/)
There was also a really good article published at the Occidental Observer sometime last year which set forth economic nationalist principles for dealing with the American car industry, but I haven't been able to find it.
George Witzgall
July 22nd, 2009, 10:35 AM
BTW, I don't see why we're even having this debate. Alex's vision, if I understand it correctly, is to have a very limited central government, and let communities govern themselves however they see fit.
That way, if a community wants to try an Adam Smith economy, it is free to do so. If it wants high taxes, a large, intrusive government bureaucracy, and lots of public services, it is also free to do so. To each his own.
The important questions, then, are how much power a central government should have, and what its areas of authority should be. Alex mentioned defense. Is there anything else?
alex doesn't even think government should be funding science. TLibertardB
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 10:36 AM
Could someone here explain to me what would be the advantage of privatizing a local fire department or water works? I don't know if Alex or Rick go as far as advocating that, but Murray Rothbard certainly did.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 22nd, 2009, 10:41 AM
"Those scholastics didn't understand that the very notion of Economic Laws is at odds with Free Will."
You means economic laws are a form of determinism?
>>In Defense of Child Labor>>
"Just the other day, hard-eyed federal cops descended on young lawbreakers all across America. Their crime wasn't drugs or gang warfare or even shoplifting. It was work.
Given the number of bums infesting our cities, one might assume a Republican administration would not attack work. One would be wrong.
Labor Secretary Elizabeth Dole – wife of Senator Bob (R-IRS) – is a pal of big labor, an institution which really ought to be called big anti-labor. Unions use violence and government- granted privileges to get more money for less work. As part of this effort, they seek to outlaw the competition – newer people who might work harder or for market wages.
At the behest of Mrs. Dole and the unions, President Bush and Congress raised the minimum wage. This abolished entry-level jobs suitable for kids ill-educated in the government schools. Now Mrs. Dole, with White House support, is usurping parental rights with a union-inspired attack on "child labor." Like the minimum wage increase, it does great harm.
After her Labor police investigated and fined a legion of businesses in Operation Child Watch, Mrs. Dole said: "I want to deliver a clear message to employers, parents, and youth. The cop is on the beat."
Some cop. These 14 and 15-year-old kids hold part-time jobs because they need the money, but it's illegal for them to work more than three hours a day, later than 7:00 pm, or more than 18 hours a week. Thus if a teenage busboy works three and a half hours, or until 7:15prn, he's guilty, and his boss can be fined $100,000 and sentenced to six months in prison.
What's wrong with hard work? And why should the federal government, not exactly an expert in hard work, stick its nose in? The Constitution doesn't appoint Mrs. Dole as Big Mother.
Can a youngster work too many hours? Sure, just as he can play too many hours. But in a free and decent society, decisions about these matters are for parents, not bureaucrats. Mrs. Dole not only violates the free market, she usurps the authority of fathers and mothers.
How dare she close off these kids' opportunities? A teenager's job is not only gainful, it's a school for life. And it is the most important school many kids attend. The government wants to kick them out.
This is made easier by what Ludwig von Mises identified as the "anti-capitalistic mentality" of politicians and intellectuals, and the long history of socialist propaganda on this subject.
Youth labor is the "most widely misrepresented aspect of the history of capitalism," says Robert Hessen of the Hoover Institution.
We're told that capitalism put young people to work in the English factories of the 1700s and 1800s that were little better than concentration camps. As usual, the left has got it exactly backwards.
In 1697, before the Industrial Revolution, John Locke urged families to put their children to work at age three. Otherwise, they would have only "bread and water, and that very scantily too." And many would not have even that.
By 1830, the life expectancy of children had vastly increased, thanks to the most explosive growth in living standards in history. Before capitalism, "these children were destitute," said Mises. "Their only refuge was the factory," which "saved them from death by starvation."
The work was hard, as life was hard, but it was not abusive. The real maltreatment took place in the English welfare system. The government placed orphaned and deserted children in horrendous establishments.
When youth factory work was restricted by an unholy combination of upper-class bleeding hearts and socialists, it was the kids who suffered. Since they had to live, and since they would do anything to avoid the social workers, the youngsters were forced to look for usually lower-paying and more dangerous work in the countryside. Many ended up, says Mises, "vagabonds, beggars, tramps, robbers, and prostitutes."
Youth labor was not abolished by Parliament, says Hessen, any more than it could be legislatively eliminated today in Bangladesh or Ghana. Only when "the income of parents became sufficient to support them" did it cease. The "emancipators and benefactors for these children" were "manufacturers and financiers," not politicians.
Twice during the Progressive Era (the regressive era that gave us the Federal Reserve, the income tax, and World War I), Congress tried to restrict youth work, but both times it was stymied by a Supreme Court that followed the Constitution.
Liberals and unions proposed a constitutional amendment to ban child labor; but it too failed. Only Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, which subverted the Supreme Court and exalted unions, could have enacted the union-inspired Walsh-Healey Act of 1936, ordering government contractors to fire young people, cut working hours, and pay above-market union wages. The so-called Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 extended these principles to the whole economy, and gave us the first minimum wage.
Northeastern Congressmen saw the legislation as a way to attack the lower-cost, non-union Southern states. A conservative Republican-Southern Democrat alliance tried to stop the laws, but unfortunately to no avail. Anti-market legislation is always harmful, but these laws threw people out of work during the Great Depression.
The power of Labor unions has faded since those dark days, and few people (outside of university economics departments) believe in Marxist exploitation theories anymore, but we are still saddled with anti-work laws that stunt young people's lives.
Instead of harassing small businesses, I have a better idea. Let's raid the Department of Labor and toss the slothocracy out on the street. Maybe they can get some real jobs in fast-food restaurants. . . as long as they're willing to compete with America's young people newly enfranchised by the repeal of all child-labor laws."
http://www.lewrockwell.com/archives/fm/05-90.html
Who do they buy the fishing rights from? I knew you would ask. I actually paced the floor last night, thinking on this.
The owner of a fishing area would want to protect it.
Here is a ton of information about fishing rights:
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&safe=off&q=fishing+rights+market&btnG=Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi=
". . .That what we have now is to a large extent what one could call monopoly capitalism. . ." We have the corporate state, public/private partnerships, same as advocated by Mussolini. It is fascism. All monopolies are from the state (government). Big business absolutely hates laissez-faire.
The new deal didn't start socialist- the first order of business was the Swope plan, to cartelize business. Named after GE CEO Gerald Swope:
(I'll put the whole thing here. Long, but very important as to how we got here.)
>>Appendix A The Swope Plan
1. All industrial and commercial companies (including subsidiaries) with 50 or more employees, and doing an interstate business, may form a trade association which shall be under the supervision of a federal body referred to later.
2. These trade associations may outline trade practices, business ethics, methods of standard accounting and cost practice, standard forms of balance sheet and earnings statement, etc., and may collect and distribute information on volume of business transacted, inventories of merchandise on hand, simplification and standardization of products, stabilization of prices, and all matters which may arise from time to time relating to the growth and development of industry and commerce in order to promote stabilization of employment and give the best service to the public. Much of this sort of exchange of information and data is already being carried on by trade associations now in existence. A great deal more valuable work of this character is possible.
3. The public interest shall be protected by the supervision of companies and trade associations by the Federal Trade Commission or by a bureau of the Department of Commerce or by some federal supervisory body specially constituted.
4. All companies within the scope of this plan shall be required to adopt standard accounting and cost systems and standardized forms of balance sheet and earnings statement. These systems and forms may differ for the different industries, but will follow a uniform plan for each industry as adopted by the trade association and approved by the federal supervisory body.
5. All companies with participants or stockholders numbering 25 or more, and living in more than one state, shall send to its participants or stockholders and to the supervisory body at least once each quarter a statement of their business and earnings in the prescribed form. At least once each year they shall send to the participants or stockholders and to the supervisory body a complete balance sheet and earnings statement in the prescribed form. In this way the owners will be kept informed of the conditions of the business in such detail that there may be no criticism of irregularity or infrequency of statements or methods of presentation.
6. The federal supervisory body shall cooperate with the Internal Revenue Department and the trade associations in developing for each industry standardized forms of balance sheet and income statement, depending upon the character of the business, for the purpose of reconciling methods of reporting assets and income with the basis of values and income calculated for federal tax purposes.
7. All of the companies of the character described herein may immediately adopt the provisions of this plan but shall be required to do so within 3 years unless the time is extended by the federal supervisory body. Similar companies formed after the plan becomes effective may come in at once but shall be required to come in before the expiration of 3 years from the date of their organization unless the time is extended by the federal supervisory body.
8. For the protection of employees, the following plans shall be adopted by all of these companies:
(A) A WORKMEN'S COMPENSATION ACT, which is part of the legislation necessary under this plan, shall, after careful study, be modeled after the best features of the laws which have been enacted by the several states.
(B) LIFE AND DISABILITY INSURANCE. All employees of companies included in this plan may, after two years' service with such companies, and shall, before the expiration of five years of service, be covered by life and disability insurance.
(1) The form of policy shall be determined by the association of which the Company is a member and approved by the federal supervisory body. The policy will belong to the employee and may be retained by him and kept in full force when he changes his employment or otherwise discontinues particular service as outlined later.
(2) The face value of a policy shall be for an amount approximately equal to one year's pay, but not more than $5,000, with the exception that the employee may, if he desires, increase at his own cost the amount of insurance carried, subject to the approval of the Board of Administrators, later defined.
(3) The cost of this life and disability insurance shall be paid one half by the employee and one-half by the company for which he works, with the following exception: the company's cost shall be determined on the basis of premiums at actual age of employees less than 35 years old and on the basis of 35 years of age for all employees 35 or over and shall be a face value of approximately one-half a year's pay but limited to a maximum premium for $2,500 of insurance. An employee taking out insurance at age 35 or over will pay the excess premium over the amount based upon age 35. This will remove the necessity for restriction against engaging employees or transferring them from one company to another because of advanced age, as it will place no undue burden of high premiums upon the company.
(4) The life and disability insurance may be carried by a life insurance company selected by the trade association and approved by the federal supervisory body or may be carried by a company organized by the trade association and approved by the federal supervisory body, or a single company may be formed to serve all associations.
(5) The administration of the insurance plan for each company shall be under the direction of a Board of Administrators consisting of representatives, one-half elected by the employee members. The powers and duties of the Board for each company will be to formulate general rules relating to eligibility of employees, etc., but such rules shall be in consonance with the general plan laid down by the General Board of Administration of the trade association of which the company is a member, and approved by the federal supervisory body.
(6) Provision for the continuation of a policy after an employee leaves one company and goes to another in the same association, or goes to a company in another trade association; continuance of the policy after retirement on pension; provisions with regard to beneficiaries; total or partial disability; method of payment of premiums by payroll deductions or otherwise, weekly, monthly
or annually, shall be embodied in the plan formulated by the trade association, with the approval of the federal supervisory body.
(7) If an employee leaves a company to go with one which is not a member of the trade association; if he engages in business for himself; or if he withdraws from industrial or commercial occupation, he may elect to retain the portion of the policy for which he has paid, in whole, or in part, by the continued payment of the proportional full premium costs, or he may receive a paid up policy, or be paid the cash surrender value for the part for which he has been paying the premiums. The cash surrender value of that portion of the policy paid for by the company will be paid to the company which paid the premiums.
(C) PENSIONS. All employees of companies included in this plan shall be covered by old age pension plans which will be adopted by the trade associations and approved by the federal supervisory body. The principal provisions will be as follows:
(1) All employees may, after two years of service with a company coming within the scope of this plan, and shall, before the expiration of five years of service, be covered by the old age pension plan.
(2) All employees after two years' service may, and after five years' service shall be required to, put aside a minimum of one per cent of earnings, but not more than $50 per year, for the pension fund. The employee may, if he desires, put aside a larger amount, subject to the approval of the Board of Administrators.
(3) The Company shall be required to put aside an amount equal to the minimum stated above, namely one per cent of earnings of employees, but not more than $50 per year per employee.
(4) The above minimum percentage shall be the same for all employees who are less than 35 years of age when payments begin and the minimum percentage for these employees shall remain the same thereafter. The percentage to be set aside by employees coming into the pension plan at 35 years of age or over shall be so determined that it will provide a retiring allowance at age 70 the same as though they had begun one per cent payments at the age of 35. These provisions enable employees to go from one company to another in the same association or to different associations at any age with provision for retiring allowances which will be not less than the minimum rate of an employee who entered the pension plan at age 35.
(5) The amounts set aside by the employee and the company with interest compounded semiannually at five per cent until retirement at age 70, for a typical average employee, would provide an annuity of approximately one-half pay.
(6) The administration of the pension plan for each company shall be under the direction of a Board of Administrators, consisting of representatives, one-half appointed by the management and one half elected by the employee members. The powers and duties of the Board for each company will be to formulate general rules relating to eligibility of employees, conditions of retirement, etc., but such rules shall be in consonance with the general plan laid down by the General Board of Administration of the trade association of which the company is a member, and approved by the federal supervisory body.
(7) The amounts collected from the employees and the companies shall be placed with the pension trust organized by the association, the management of which shall be under the direction of the General Board of Administration referred to hereafter. In no case shall such funds be left under the control of an individual company.
(8) The Pension trust shall invest all funds and place them to the credit of the individual employees, including the income earned by the trust. If an employee goes from one company to another in the same association, the funds accumulated to his credit shall be continued to his credit with proper record of transfer. If an employee goes to a company in another association, the funds accumulated to his credit shall be transferred to his credit in the pension trust of the association to which he goes. If an employee goes to a company which does not come under these provisions or which is not a member of a trade association; goes into business for himself; or withdraws from an industrial or commercial occupation, the amount of his payments plus the interest at the average rate earned by the funds shall be given to him. If an employee dies before reaching retirement age, his beneficiary will receive the amount of his payments plus interest at the average rate earned by the funds. When an employee reaches retirement age, the entire amount accumulated to his credit, including his own payments and those of the company, plus accumulated interest, will be given to him in the form of an annuity. If an employee goes to a company which does not come under these provisions or which is not a member of a trade association; goes into business for himself; or withdraws from industrial or commercial occupation, he may elect to let the amount to his credit (namely, his own payments plus those of the company and the
accumulated interest) remain with the pension trust for transfer, if he should return to the employ of any company coming within the provisions of this plan. If he does not return to the employ of a company coming under these provisions, he may at any time thereafter withdraw the amount of his own payments plus interest at the average rate earned by the funds up to that time. Company contributions and accumulated interest credited to employees who die, or for reasons indicated above, receive or withdraw their own contributions and interest, shall be returned to the employer or employers who made the contributions.
(9) The rules governing the payments of pensions on retirement and all other rules governing its continuance shall be made by the trade association, approved by the federal supervisory body, and observed by the General Board of Administration and the Boards of Administration of the member companies.
(D) UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE. All employees on piece work, hourly work daily, weekly, or monthly work, with normal pay of $5,000 per year or less (approximately $96.15 per week) shall be covered by unemployment insurance.
(1) All such employees may, after two years of service with a company coming within the provisions of this plan, and shall, after five years of service, be each required to put aside a minimum of one per cent of earnings, but not more than $50 per year for an unemployment insurance fund.
(2) The company shall be required to put aside an amount equal to that put aside by the employees, as set forth above, namely one per cent of the earnings of each employee, but not more than $50 per year for each such employee.
(3) If a company regularizes and guarantees employment for at least 50 per cent of the normal wage paid each year to such employees, the company assessment for employees covered by such guarantee need not be made, but the employees will pay in a minimum of one per cent of earnings, but not more than $50 per year, into a special fund for their own benefit.
If such an employee leaves the company, dies or retires on pension, the amount to his credit in the special fund plus interest at the average rate earned by the special fund, shall be given to him or to his beneficiaries or added to his pension.
(4) If a company so plans its work that it is able to reduce unemployment, when the amount of such company's credit in the normal unemployment fund is equal to but not less than 5 per cent of the normal annual earnings of the employees covered, the company may cease making payment to the fund. Employees' payments will continue. The company will resume payments when its credit in the normal unemployment fund falls below 5 per cent of normal annual earnings of the employees covered.
(5) When the weekly payments made from the fund for unemployment benefits amount to 2 per cent or more of the average weekly earnings of participating employees, the company shall declare an unemployment emergency, and normal payments by the employees and the company shall cease. Thereafter all employees of the company (including the highest officers) receiving 50 per cent or more of their average full-time earnings shall pay 1 per cent of their current earnings to the unemployment fund. A similar amount shall be paid into the fund by the company. The unemployment emergency shall continue until normal conditions are restored, which shall be determined by the Board of Administrators of each company. Thereupon normal payments will be resumed.
(6) The main provisions for the distribution of the funds shall follow along these lines, unless modified by the Board of Administrators as set forth in Section D, paragraph 7 hereof. A certain small percentage of the normal payments of the employees and the company may be considered as available for helping participating employees in need. A larger percentage of such normal payments may be considered as available for loans to participating employees in amounts not exceeding $200 each, with or without interest as may be determined by the Board. The balance of the funds shall be available for unemployment payments. Unemployment payments shall begin after the first two weeks of unemployment and shall amount to approximately 50 per cent of the participating employee's average weekly or monthly earnings for full time, but in no case more than $20 per week. Such payments to individual employees shall continue for no longer than ten weeks in any twelve consecutive months unless extended by the Board. When a participating employee is working part-time because of lack of work and receiving less than 50 per cent of his average weekly or monthly earnings for full time, he shall be eligible for payments to be made from the fund, amounting to the difference between the amount he is receiving as wages from the company and the maximum he may be entitled to as outlined above.
(7) The custody and investment of funds and administration of the unemployment insurance plan for each company shall be under the direction of a Board of Administrators consisting of representatives, one-half appointed by the management and one-half elected by the employee members. The powers and duties of the Board shall be to formulate general rules relating to eligibility of employees, the waiting period before benefits are paid, amounts of benefits and how long they shall continue in any year, whether loans shall be made in time of unemployment or need, whether a portion of the funds shall be placed at the disposal of the Board for relief from need arising from causes other than unemployment, etc., but such rules shall be in consonance with the general plan laid down by the General Board of Administration of the trade association of which the company is a member, and approved by the federal supervisory body.
(8) If an employee leaves the company and goes to work for another company coming within the provisions of this plan, the proportionate amount remaining of his normal contributions, plus interest at the average rate earned by the funds, shall be transferred to such company and to his credit. If he leaves for other reasons, dies or retires on pension, the proportionate amount remaining of his normal payment, plus interest at the average rate earned by the funds, shall be given to him, or to his beneficiary, or added to his pension. When such employee's credit is transferred to another company, or paid to the employee or to his beneficiary under this provision, an equal amount shall be paid to the cooperating company.
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION. Each trade association will form a General Board of Administration which shall consist of nine members, three to be elected or appointed by the association, three to be elected by the employees of the member companies, and three, representing the public, to be appointed by the federal supervisory body. The members of the General Board, except employee representatives, shall serve without compensation. The employee representatives shall be paid their regular rates of pay for time devoted to Board work, and all members shall be paid traveling expenses, all of which shall be borne by the trade association. The powers and duties of this General Board shall be to interpret the life and disability insurance, pension and unemployment insurance plans adopted by the trade association and approved by the federal supervisory body, supervise the individual company Boards of Administration, form and direct a pension trust for the custody, investment, and disbursements of the pension funds, and in general supervise and direct all activities connected with life and disability insurance, pension and unemployment insurance plans."
George Witzgall
July 22nd, 2009, 10:42 AM
Could someone here explain to me what would be the advantage of privatizing a local fire department or water works? I don't know if Alex or Rick go as far as advocating that, but Murray Rothbard certainly did.
private companies look out for the public interest better than government. just look at how Enron stepped up to the plate when california deregulated its power.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 10:52 AM
alex doesn't even think government should be funding science. TLibertardB
I'm not too hot on government-funded science most of the time either. It too often results in fraudulent or politicized science, like AIDS or "climate change" (formerly "global warming") research, or the dumping of fluoride in our water.
I'm a little more sympathetic to government grants for the arts, as long as what's being funded is something the entire public can enjoy and reflects something about our heritage or national values (in other words, as long as the grants aren't given to kikes who immerse crucifixes in urine and call it "art"). If it were all up to capitalism, it'd be Britney Spears everywhere, all the time.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 11:07 AM
Rick: you're still not getting my point. I am not saying that unions are perfect angels, that they always do good, and that businessmen are all evil swine always out to screw the little man. I am not even saying that children should not be allowed to work -- in fact, I am against forcing kids to stay in school if they don't want to be there and have better things to do (like work).
What I am saying is that businessmen are not always perfect little innocent angels either, and it's as ridiculous to argue that they should be given unlimited power to do as they please as arguing that the government should. You want to give control of our oceans to private corporations -- are you nuts? How would that benefit the little guy, the little fisherman?
What I am saying is that the working class at one time had valid complaints against their employers, and that much of the progress that was brought about by the labor movement is being taken for granted today by guys like you. I can't believe anyone would think it was a good idea to return to the types of working conditions that existed 100+ years ago in the name of some libertarian ideal.
What I am saying is that there are many socialist institutions, like municipal fire departments, that most people take for granted today, that are good. There is no advantage to privatizing something like a fire department, especially in an urban or suburban environment where if my neighbor's house catches on fire, there's a good chance mine will as well. I'd rather not leave it to my neighbor to decide whether he should pay into the services of a private fire department or not.
I'm becoming convinced that hardcore libertarians are just as tardy and out of touch with reality as the Marxists.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 11:15 AM
private companies look out for the public interest better than government. just look at how Enron stepped up to the plate when california deregulated its power.
Someone living in California told me that after deregulation, the cost of power to consumers tripled.
Mike Parker
July 22nd, 2009, 11:28 AM
The winners don't want that. They recognize that government is demonstrably defective every single one of its functions, hence close to unnecessary. White men + freedom + technology = no need for government.
Winners favor heathy paternalism. They have the biggest stake in a cohesive society. It's middling types--lawyers, intellectuals--who harbor resentments and make trouble.
Mike Parker
July 22nd, 2009, 11:33 AM
I'm becoming convinced that hardcore libertarians are just as tardy and out of touch with reality as the Marxists.
Exactly. Frankfurt School, "Austrian" School, government always bad, government always good...all Jewish revolutionary dogmas.
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 11:49 AM
Could someone here explain to me what would be the advantage of privatizing a local fire department or water works? I don't know if Alex or Rick go as far as advocating that, but Murray Rothbard certainly did.
Do you know anything about the way fire departments operate these days?
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 11:59 AM
BTW, I don't see why we're even having this debate. Alex's vision, if I understand it correctly, is to have a very limited central government, and let communities govern themselves however they see fit.
That way, if a community wants to try an Adam Smith economy, it is free to do so. If it wants high taxes, a large, intrusive government bureaucracy, and lots of public services, it is also free to do so. To each his own.
The important questions, then, are how much power a central government should have, and what its areas of authority should be. Alex mentioned defense. Is there anything else?
Racial dictatorship at the top - a one-function government, but that one function, defense, construed to include trade. Certainly no companies will be allowed to undermine the racial basis of the state by hiring nonwhites at low wages, nor by trading freely with foreigners using slave labor.
Beneath the national level, I propose that whites arrange themselves as they see fit, into states. The smaller the better, in many cases. I will live with those who want close to zero government, the losers can join communities that want government to supply schools, welfare, health care, and "safety" regulation. When those things produce the results they always do, only those who chose to live in the state will suffer. As it is now, with a collectivized, centralized government, everybody is subject to the costly panaceas of the morons.
In the state I envision, the only thing denied white men, because of my beliefs, is his ability to live around niggers. I'm willing to kill over that because if I'm not, the mixer's choices will render my country unlivable. Absolutely no nonwhites will be allowed in the new state, save tourists, on terms set by the Defenders, the ones running the national government.
As for those socialist health care countries, you're correct, most people in them will defend their system. Right up until they need to use it. Then they'll sneak down to the US because they're sick of suffering or the treatment they want isn't on the approved list. Don't listen to what they say, watch what they do.
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 12:11 PM
Igor, I have a half-fleshed out vision, and I will lay it out in the forum I created for the purpose as soon as I have the energy. The basics of it are this:
1) national/federal/overstate government. One function, construed as broadly as need be: defending the White racial basis of the state from all enemies, intellectual, economic, and military. History shows that Germanic peoples are capable of running essentially competent civil services, but there needs to be an admixture of holiness. How best to infuse this I'm still considering. Dual approach of spirit and stick will provide the best outcome, understanding that all people are corrupt, and no system devised by humans cannot be subverted. It is the job of each new generation to understand the tradition it inherits, to preserve and burnish it, if it can, or to go another way, if need be.
2) states/micro-states/city-states/communities beneath the Defender umbrella. One size does not fit all with white men. For Whites to flourish, they need freedom. They can only be white men if they are forced to rely on their own resourcefulness, and any government that binds this strength and cunning in the name of safety is anti-White.
With dozens or hundreds of different states/communities to choose from, Whites can group themselves as they see fit. And if the model they choose doesn't work, they can relocate to another, if it will have them. In this way those I designate losers, roughly the left half of the bell curve, can join together and have their micro-state "save" them from those evil pill manufacturers, and ward off their 1001 little-man fears. They can employ their obese sisters and retarded mothers in the "public schools" and recreate the kind of moronic robots we see today. The winners, roughly the right half of the bell curve, who just need government to leave them alone, can go their own way. They can form communities with minimal government, and take advantage of all the economic laws astute economists and historians have discovered but never been able to put into practice given the nature of the System we labor under today.
What I lay out is a mixture of new and old. It's not utopian, as best I can tell. It's an attempt to fit the best of White into some new forms made possible by genuine intellectual discoveries we will only be able to apply after the Jewish Tyranny is destroyed.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 22nd, 2009, 12:22 PM
"What I am saying is that the working class at one time had valid complaints against their employers, and that much of the progress that was brought about by the labor movement is being taken for granted today by guys like you. I can't believe anyone would think it was a good idea to return to the types of working conditions that existed 100+ years ago in the name of some libertarian ideal."
Elephant shit. I call it The Tragic Correlation:
A kike named Richard Goodwin, associated with the New Frontier and Great Society exclaimed "we created the middle class."
Look at the standard of living- compare today with 150 years ago. Higher? Yes, that is true. The question is- how did this happen?
Three things can be charted on a graph, over 150 years:
1. Rise in living standards
2. Rise in "for the people" legislation
3. Rise in productivity due to technological innovation
All are correlated over time. But we all know that correlation doesn't prove causation. The left says 2. caused 1.
ELEPHANT SHIT
In fact, 3. caused 1. The left says if 2. were removed, the standard of living would be the same as 150 years ago
ELEPHANT SHIT
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 12:27 PM
If it weren't for the labor movement, wouldn't we still have 7-year-olds working 14 hour shifts in factories under deplorable conditions (kinda like in the Third World today)?
You're taking one particular point in the development of industry and identifying it with an -ism you want to criticize. That makes no sense. We started from almost nothing in 1800 - to where we are today, 200 years later. Capitalism, or the market, is very fast moving, this is its glory, compared to the lazy sinkholes of communism, nescience and fart-gas that constitute academia. The remarkable thing is not that there were difficult conditions along the way, but how quickly they gave way to better conditions.
We hear about evil corporations dumping and polluting. If you think about it, the real horrors are what governments do: burning down Yellowstone, murdering the Aral Sea, bombarding its own people and foreigners with radioactive material. Anything private is far more likely to be well maintained than anything public.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 12:30 PM
Absolutely no nonwhites will be allowed in the new state, save tourists, on terms set by the Defenders, the ones running the national government.
It goes without saying that allowances should also be made for diplomats and travelling businessmen.
As for those socialist health care countries, you're correct, most people in them will defend their system. Right up until they need to use it. Then they'll sneak down to the US because they're sick of suffering or the treatment they want isn't on the approved list. Don't listen to what they say, watch what they do.
No argument here. Canada's health care system is trash and is falling apart, just as many of the ones in Europe are. Certainly non-white immigration (i.e., muds using the system but not paying into it) is a contributing factor, but socialized health care isn't a good idea to begin with.
It's not just patients that go South for teatment; Canada has a hard time keeping doctors and medical staff onboard because they all go work in the States (higher salaries).
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 12:51 PM
You're taking one particular point in the development of industry and identifying it with an -ism you want to criticize.
No, no, no. I am pointing out that "capitalism" has its faults. That's all.
Honestly, I think you and Rick are far too eager to attribute to capitalism things that might have other causes. There was lots of technological innovation in the Third Reich, and the Third Reich did not have a capitalist economy. Even the Soviet Union made its share of innovations.
Technological innovation is a product of race, not of economics.
The remarkable thing is not that there were difficult conditions along the way, but how quickly they gave way to better conditions.
Yes, but how did they give way to better conditions? Rick says the labor movement had nothing to do with it. Well if not the labor movement, then what? Neither you nor Rick have answered that.
We hear about evil corporations dumping and polluting. If you think about it, the real horrors are what governments do: burning down Yellowstone, murdering the Aral Sea, bombarding its own people and foreigners with radioactive material. Anything private is far more likely to be well maintained than anything public.
I think either have the potential for good or evil. I don't want big business intruding in my life anymore than I want big government intruding into it.
And the stereotypes about evil corporations aren't always unfounded. I could tell you some stories about my phone company.
I'd also be curious to hear yours and Rick's take on issues like GMOs and DNA patenting.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 12:54 PM
Do you know anything about the way fire departments operate these days?
No. What's wrong with them, other than that they're forced to hire muds?
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 01:10 PM
In this way those I designate losers, roughly the left half of the bell curve...
And also the female side of the sex divide. Females tend to gravitate towards safety, even if it's only the illusion of safety, while men tend to gravitate towards freedom even at the expense of safety.
Why are women such big fans of socialized health care? Because they like to go to the doctor for every little ache and blemish. Men are the opposite; they refuse to go see a doctor even when reason tells them they should.
A community devoid of socialism necessarily entails stripping women of political power.
Igor Alexander
July 22nd, 2009, 01:21 PM
Look at the standard of living- compare today with 150 years ago. Higher? Yes, that is true. The question is- how did this happen?
Three things can be charted on a graph, over 150 years:
1. Rise in living standards
2. Rise in "for the people" legislation
3. Rise in productivity due to technological innovation
All are correlated over time. But we all know that correlation doesn't prove causation. The left says 2. caused 1.
ELEPHANT SHIT
In fact, 3. caused 1. The left says if 2. were removed, the standard of living would be the same as 150 years ago
ELEPHANT SHIT
The left may say that, but I never did. You still haven't answered the question (unless your inclusion of #2 on this list is an admission that the labor movement did, in fact, play a role in improving working conditions for the lower classes).
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 01:58 PM
No, no, no. I am pointing out that "capitalism" has its faults. That's all.
They're only faults if there was a choice to do otherwise. Just because one condition looks bad doesn't mean there were better alternatives.
Yes, but how did they give way to better conditions? Rick says the labor movement had nothing to do with it. Well if not the labor movement, then what? Neither you nor Rick have answered that.
The ordinary man today has access to things that kings didn't have two hundred years ago. That's not due to labor, that's for darn sure. It's due to profit-motivated developers and manufacturers, not governments and labor.
I think either have the potential for good or evil. I don't want big business intruding in my life anymore than I want big government intruding into it.
Do you not perceive the difference between being offered something and being forced to do something at gunpoint? That's the difference between a corporation and a government.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 22nd, 2009, 03:17 PM
"Do you not perceive the difference between being offered something and being forced to do something at gunpoint?"
The left doesn't know, and doesn't want to know. The companies are oppressive, the state liberating. "Satanic inversion." Or, orthodox Marxism.
>>The subject of zero-sum economics needs to be broached. As far as I can fathom, all socialists believe in one central idea- that is, that the gain of one comes at the expense of the other, and that there is only a fixed amount of wealth to go around. An example is from Catholic Social Teaching: "All the goods were placed on Earth by G$d for the use of all of the people." Therefore, all deserve an equal share.
It's like a lifeboat, where there is truly is fixed supply of goods. Let's say one person on such a boat hides food while others are asleep. This leads to starvation of at least one other. The person that hoarded the food represents the capitalist screwing of the others. . .The capitalist gets an unfair share, causing misery and poverty. This has to be remedied by Robin Hood type programs. . .This is the class struggle of Marx. . .
Let us discuss.
Hunter Wallace
July 22nd, 2009, 05:56 PM
John Médaille was a notorious anti-racist at Takimag. I remember arguing with him on a number of occasions.
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 08:45 PM
Winners favor heathy paternalism. They have the biggest stake in a cohesive society. It's middling types--lawyers, intellectuals--who harbor resentments and make trouble.
Paternalism can just as often be racially destructive - what were the plantation owners if not destructive? What are the Bushes? Both were paternalists, both were racially destructive.
Alex Linder
July 22nd, 2009, 08:48 PM
Exactly. Frankfurt School, "Austrian" School, government always bad, government always good...all Jewish revolutionary dogmas.
Nah, it's demonstrable government is lousy at everything, has nothing to do with jews, who benefit exclusively from centralization and collectivization. If you disagree, list one thing government is good at.
richyrichard
July 22nd, 2009, 09:41 PM
The ordinary man today has access to things that kings didn't have two hundred years ago. That's not due to labor, that's for darn sure. It's due to profit-motivated developers and manufacturers, not governments and labor.
Can you not say that both groups are contributors to our success? Where would the coal mine be without the miner? Where would the skyscraper be without the welder on the 12th floor I-beam?
It is also true that inventors and developers have access to things today because labor works the assembly line to put the stuff together.
And who makes this land secure for all of us if not the working class that makes up the millions of front-line soldiers who fight on the battlefields while the bourgeois sit in the bleachers counting their war profits?
And do you really believe that if the government had no fair labeling laws that some business tycoon wouldn't sell mule meat in a can labeled "beef stew"?
Its all about balance. At some point individualism and collectivism must come together to form a complimentary whole, rather than remain as a conflicting pair of opposites.
Mike Parker
July 23rd, 2009, 05:23 AM
Nah, it's demonstrable government is lousy at everything, has nothing to do with jews, who benefit exclusively from centralization and collectivization.
The Jew benefits from things being centralized under Jew control. The Jew benefits most from white individualism. The Jew did not prosper under German NS.
If you disagree, list one thing government is good at.
Hitler's government shut down the Institute for Social Research (of the Frankfurt School) within 6 weeks (IIRC) of taking power. The capitalist Kwa welcomed those neo-Marxists with open arms and they remain highly influential today in our marketplace of ideas even after being thoroughly refuted.
I'll take the Austrian Hitler over the Austrian Mises, and Lincoln Rockwell over Lew Rockwell.
Mike Parker
July 23rd, 2009, 05:26 AM
Everybody wants to distribute, nobody wants to produce.
That's a good way of putting it. What do Goldman Sachs, Blackstone, PIMCO and McKinsey produce? Finance capitalism is distributism for the rich.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 10:43 AM
The Jew benefits from things being centralized under Jew control. The Jew benefits most from white individualism. The Jew did not prosper under German NS.
Not under it, but certainly from it.
The thousand-year Reich lasted 12 years. Hitler was not good at running a dictatorship, was he?
Hitler's government shut down the Institute for Social Research (of the Frankfurt School) within 6 weeks (IIRC) of taking power. The capitalist Kwa welcomed those neo-Marxists with open arms and they remain highly influential today in our marketplace of ideas even after being thoroughly refuted.
So instead of ending kikes as a threat to our race, Hitler flushed them, and allowed them to become a problem for others. The irony is that the things Hitler is famous for doing are exactly what he didn't do but should have done.
I'll take the Austrian Hitler over the Austrian Mises, and Lincoln Rockwell over Lew Rockwell.
The only thing Whites need collectivized is racial defense. Collectivization beyond that reduces white men to the status of white ants.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 10:55 AM
Third Reich did not have a capitalist economy. Even the Soviet Union made its share of innovations.
Technological innovation is a product of race, not of economics.
No, it's a product of both. The Third Reich was, for the most part, a capitalist economy. Hitler combined all the labor unions and dictated the use of raw materials he needed for war, but beyond that he did not attempt to create giant state enterprises like the communists did. There's a thread on this in the 'Nazis: the facts' subforum, guy wrote a long paper on it.
Hitler's uneconomic ideas were more from his private tastes - he wanted every big city to have a giant opera house and didn't care where the funds came from. None or very few were built, but that was how he thought. It is clear he was never troubled in the slightest by forcing others to pay for his private whims.
Yes, but how did they give way to better conditions? Rick says the labor movement had nothing to do with it. Well if not the labor movement, then what? Neither you nor Rick have answered that.
Have unions ever come up with new products or innovations? Heck, no. Unions are all about getting their members more for less. What actually improves conditions for people is the thinking set figuring out how to produce X or Y more efficiently or cheaply. That's where the real benefits come in for the rest of us, that's what raises the general material level of society.
And the stereotypes about evil corporations aren't always unfounded. I could tell you some stories about my phone company.
Yeah, see, the difference is you can choose another phone company if you're unhappy; I can't choose a different central government. Government never goes out of business though it fails at everything it does.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 11:04 AM
What I am saying is that the working class at one time had valid complaints against their employers, and that much of the progress that was brought about by the labor movement is being taken for granted today by guys like you. I can't believe anyone would think it was a good idea to return to the types of working conditions that existed 100+ years ago in the name of some libertarian ideal.
Straw man not worth responding to.
What I am saying is that there are many socialist institutions, like municipal fire departments, that most people take for granted today, that are good. There is no advantage to privatizing something like a fire department, especially in an urban or suburban environment where if my neighbor's house catches on fire, there's a good chance mine will as well. I'd rather not leave it to my neighbor to decide whether he should pay into the services of a private fire department or not.
There are very few fires. Mostly firemen just sit around and figure out how they can sleep with their buddy's wife. When they're not doing that, they count the years until they can retire with a ridiculous pension, drawn off the public teat, of course. Beyond that, they try to take over the local ambulance business because there aren't any real fires to fight, and like all incompetent bureacracies, they want to expand their range. The only other thing they have to do is figure out how best to plead for a new fire station and new equipment, even though they don't need it.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 11:06 AM
That's a good way of putting it. What do Goldman Sachs, Blackstone, PIMCO and McKinsey produce? Finance capitalism is distributism for the rich.
They're able to do what they do because financial and other powers are consolidated in the national government, just as you advocate. If the feds had hard money and allowed monetary competition, which they do not, none of the thievings and bailouts would be possible. Decentralization of power is always the answer, except for defense. Not only that, it's the only arrangement that fits the nature of White men - they are thinking individuals who can come up with and act on their own plans, without needing authority.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 11:12 AM
No argument here. Canada's health care system is trash and is falling apart, just as many of the ones in Europe are. Certainly non-white immigration (i.e., muds using the system but not paying into it) is a contributing factor, but socialized health care isn't a good idea to begin with.
Socialized medicine is a demonstrable failure everywhere it's been tried, but far too many people are dumb enough that they fall for the old "free and universal" lie.
The average person believes in magic, not evidence and logic. It is the tragedy of the west that Christianity became the dominant religion, since it perverts faith into the service of magic and the supernatural rather than reason and reality.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 11:50 AM
"Do you not perceive the difference between being offered something and being forced to do something at gunpoint?"
The left doesn't know, and doesn't want to know. The companies are oppressive, the state liberating. "Satanic inversion." Or, orthodox Marxism.
It's a lack of imagination and respect. The left wants to act as though all the good material things in this world were preexisting, and some how da ebil white man capitalists got there first and grabbed them all, and only the strivings of the heroic laborites and commies got any back fo' da po' folks.
The fact is, material progress that benefits everybody, comes out of the head of a tiny, creative minority, a delicate flower the mass cattle and the demagogues stampeding them are only too likely to trample.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 12:09 PM
It's like a lifeboat, where there is truly is fixed supply of goods. Let's say one person on such a boat hides food while others are asleep. This leads to starvation of at least one other. The person that hoarded the food represents the capitalist screwing of the others. . .The capitalist gets an unfair share, causing misery and poverty. This has to be remedied by Robin Hood type programs. . .This is the class struggle of Marx. . .
This mentality is common to all too many among the non-productive classes: NEA teachers, Catholics leftists, commies - anyone who can't produce anything anyone else actually wants is likely to hold these views. They will be found using phrases like "giving back" to the community. It's a combo of greed combined with lack of imagination: a lot of these white nitwits are essentially niggers. Niggers believe government is omnipotent. They believe it can produce money and goods at will. The only reason government doesn't make every nigger a millionaire is "racism." These beliefs sound ridiculous when you spell them out, but they are what niggers actually think. And pretty close to half of white people think more or less the same as niggers.
Capitalism is not a zero-sum game. A guy invents, say, an air conditioner. Whether he did it for Jesus, Satan, or love of profits he thought he would make from it, we all enjoy the benefits. For, say, $200 a unit, we get the solace of chilled air courtesy of an appliance not one of us ever could have devised. Instead of showing gratitude for the inventor and the market that distributed his wares, the leftist feels only anger that some people have bigger and better air conditioners than, say, the average Eskimo.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 23rd, 2009, 12:20 PM
"Can you not say that both groups are contributors to our success? Where would the coal mine be without the miner? Where would the skyscraper be without the welder on the 12th floor I-beam?"
>>"Marxism is the name for a set of political and economic ideas. The base of these ideas comes from the works of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. They have had a lot of influence in many countries. Very often, both authors are named, as it is difficult to say which of the two wrote what piece of the theory.
From Marxist thought, other political views came to be, such as Social Democracy and Reformist Socialism (both believe that the ideas that Marx and Engels portrayed can be achieved through what Marx called 'Bourgeois Democracy.')
Many Marxists say that modern "Communism" is not Communism at all. That nations such as the U.S.S.R, The People's Republic of China, Venezuela, Cuba, Vietnam etc are different forms of Capitalism, often with heavily "nationalized" industries. One of the biggest proponents of these ideas in Marxist thought was Tony Cliff, who wrote that states like the U.S.S.R and Communist China (before 1980) were "State-Capitalist." Not all Communists, Socialists or Marxists agree on this question, but many hardened Marxists generally agree that Socialism is workers' democratic control over economic decisions and social justice, while production is based on what people need, and that Socialism will wither away into Communism when Capitalism is defeated. With that idea in mind, Marxists have a tendency to discredit most of the listed regimes.
Modern Communism claims to be based on Marxist ideas, but many Marxists disagree about whether Communist countries have understood Marxism correctly.
[change]
The working class and the capitalist class
Marxism says that people in the world are organized into different groups or classes based on their relationship to how things are made. Most people are called "workers" because they work in factories or offices or farms for money. They belong to the "working class" (or "proletariat"). Another group, who are not as big as the working class are "capitalists", because they own the factories, land and buildings that the workers have to work in and also own all of the tools the workers have to use. Marx calls Capitalists the "Ruling Class" because they live off of the work of all the workers. He also says that the Capitalists own the government, army and courts. In Marxist views, Capital is the "means of production" and money which the Capitalist can invest in different places of business so that they can "profit" or gain more Capital.
Most workers work for companies owned by Capitalists or "Petite-bourgeois" (small business owners). The capitalist pays a wage to the worker in exchange for the worker's time. The capitalist has bought a period of time from the worker which the worker must then use to labor for the Capitalist, which according to marxist economic thinking is the only thing that can create value in a commodity, and then exploits the time of the worker as much as they can. The capitalist amasses capital by paying the worker less wealth than they make for the Capitalist. Marxism says that commodities (products) have different values. One value is called "use-value" which changes from person to person. Use-value is determined by whether something is useful. "Exchange-value" is the value of a commodity when compared to other commodities. For example if 10 nails are traded for 10 boot laces, the exchange value of the nails is 10. Finally, "Labor Value" or Value, is determined by the amount of labor needed to create a product. Value is created by adding work to something. A products Value is determined by the average work needed to create the product for the market. Value can be described as the amount of labor time used to create a commodity.
As an example: Peter and Bob and Carl are all shoe makers. It takes Peter half a day to make 20 shoes, and it takes Bob half a day to make 20 shoes and it takes Carl half a day to make 20 shoes. The average labor-time to make the shoes is half a day, and that means each shoe contains half a day's labor value.
Peter, Bob and Carl now work for James. James owns a shoe factory that can make 60 shoes in half a day. Between Peter, Bob and Carl, 60 shoes are made. Peter, Bob and Carl are paid only as much as they need to live at socially accepted standards. Peter, Bob and Carl each get 20 dollars a day in wages, however James sells the shoes for 2 dollars each. 120$ is made and James pays the workers (Peter, Bob and Carl) their wages. The remaining wealth is called "Profit" or "Surplus Value." In other words, Peter, Bob and Carl earn enough to provide for themselves within half of their working day. The rest of the day they are creating profit for their boss, James, which is called Surplus Value.
It is this Surplus Value, or Profit, which Marxism thinks as an exploitation of labor. This exploitation allows the smaller class (Capitalists) to live without laboring, while the bigger class (Workers) have to work for the Capitalists to survive.
Marxism says that Factories, tools and work places cannot create new value on their own. Similar to how a blue berry bush has no value on its own. That value can only be created with the use of labor. For example, someone spends a day picking blue berries. Those blue berries are now able to be traded or eaten because of the invested labor time to pick them.
Marxist thinking claims that Capitalists and Workers are in a constant state of struggle, which they call "Materialist Dialectic." Marxism says that in order for Capitalists to generate profit quickly, and to maximise their rate of profit, they have to exploit the workers as much as possible, and lower their wages as much as possible. Workers, on the other hand, have to struggle to keep their wages up, to keep the "rate of exploitation" low, so that they can live more peaceful lives. This is what Marxism calls "Class Struggle" where Workers and their Bosses fight against each other to gain for themselves.(R.R.- There is the zero-sum idea, that the gain on one comes at the expense of the other.)
Marxists think that all of written human history has been divided by economic classes. They think that the progression of history has been pushed forward by class struggle. Marxism says that it is from this struggle that Capitalism was born and that it is from this struggle that Communism (or Socialism) will be born. For example: Feudal Society (a society controlled by feudal Lords and Nobles) rested its Ruling Class on the labor of peasants (farmers). But, as peasants demanded more and more for themselves small shopkeepers and tradespeople began to appear. Many of these people appeared in Guilds as well, and eventually began to employ workers to independently accumulate wealth. It was this historical progression that created Capitalists/Capitalism.
In the same way, Marxism says that Capitalism will give way to Communism, as the struggle of the workers becomes more and more revolutionary."<<
Let me ask a question. What is the standard of living of a floor sweeper during the middle ages? What is the standard of living of a floor sweeper (recently, in the West)? Higher? Why?
The "labor theory of value" or "exploitation thesis" is the basic underpinning of socialism. It means that those doing the physical labor create ALL value, and that profit comes from underpaying labor. The wage would fall to the subsistence level. Humanitarian laws would stop this stealing from the worker. This is why unions were allowed to use violence and not be prosecuted.
>>Those wanting to combine communism with radical individualism- one side based on force, the other voluntary. What does the force side have to offer? btw It's quite possible to have group activity in a fully free society.
Combining the two is called the third way. We've already got it- it'z the 'Kwa!! Just expels the jews and niggers. . .
These programs like the great society are continuations of the earlier labor movement. . .
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 12:28 PM
Can you not say that both groups are contributors to our success? Where would the coal mine be without the miner? Where would the skyscraper be without the welder on the 12th floor I-beam?
I'm talking about unions, not about workers. Of course the guy who does the physical labor deserves respect.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 12:48 PM
I'm becoming convinced that hardcore libertarians are just as tardy and out of touch with reality as the Marxists.
They're out of touch with racial reality, not economic reality.
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 12:52 PM
Could someone here explain to me what would be the advantage of privatizing a local fire department or water works? I don't know if Alex or Rick go as far as advocating that, but Murray Rothbard certainly did.
I would like to see where he did. I can well believe there's an argument for it, based on what I have observed here locally. From what I have seen, firemen/departments are always:
1) overpaid, with benefits and pensions ridiculously out of line with the private sector;
2) have basically nothing to do since there are few fires
3) are always trying to expand their role into emergency services, putting private ambulance services out of business if possible
4) are always pleading for more money for yet more equipment and bigger, bushier firehouses.
It's very easy to believe private arrangements could perform better than public fire departments for a fraction of the cost.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 23rd, 2009, 01:30 PM
"The northern California city of Vallejo is facing a possible bankruptcy given a massive budget shortfall. According to the LA Times, “Police and firefighters account for 80% of Vallejo’s budget, city officials say, due to ballooning overtime bills and lucrative union contracts that have boosted base salaries, benefits and retirement plans.”
More than 10 fire employees earn more than $200,000, and they receive exceptional pensions. In Orange County, the average pay and benefit package for all categories of firefighter is $175K.
The unions have ratcheted up the pay to unconscionable levels, and the bill for massive pension benefits will be paid by our grandchildren. This is the result of unionization, shameless politicians who curry favor with unions at the expense of taxpayers and a public that is easily bullied by union activists who always play the hero card."
Then, some very apropos blog postings:
"You seen the typical security guard? I wouldn't want those guys protecting my parking space, let alone me and my family.
Yes, damn those unions! Let's go back to the 80 work week at $3 an hour like before they came along. And while we're at it, lets bring back child labor too."
"No problem, here you go.
Look at the numbers they tossed around back when they first declared bankruptcy, then look at their own human resources website. The City Council says they pay firefighters $171K a year in salary and benefits; a fire captain $206K a year; a police captain supposedly gets $306K."
http://forums.mercurynews.com/topic/cops-firemen-bankrupting-vallejo-with-pay-and-benefits
Alex Linder
July 23rd, 2009, 01:48 PM
Name three groups you never see described as greedy and overpaid:
cops, firemen, NEA teachers.
The media flip reality. "Public servants" are the greedy hogs. Private employees are the productive and the useful.
Rick Ronsavelle
July 23rd, 2009, 01:56 PM
I guess Brimelow must have a pretty strong union.
Mike Parker
July 24th, 2009, 11:32 AM
So instead of ending kikes as a threat to our race, Hitler flushed them, and allowed them to become a problem for others.
Hitler ended the German kikes as a threat to Germany. The capitalist, liberal US always gave refuge to Europe's kikes so they could be a threat to Europe and the US. The reason is that liberalism and capitalism are individualistic (and naive). Meaning vulnerable to the Jew. The Jews were liberals before they were Marxists or Zionists. For good reason. The quintessential liberal is Lewpus. The Jews pursue the most brazen, transparent group strategy, and he insists it's not happening, that we're all just individuals.
The only thing Whites need collectivized is racial defense. Collectivization beyond that reduces white men to the status of white ants.
Race, nation, tribe are extended families. When you cooperate with your family you're not supposed to feel like an insect. Tribalism is the answer. Iran doesn't have a big problem with its Jews. They're an annoying minority that's tolerated and even humored, but they don't invent the culture or dictate public policy. The reason is that Iran is what MacDonald calls a "segmentary society," illiberal and clannish. That defeats Jewish crypsis. The Jews have a member of parliament, but he can't pull a Lieberman and pretend to be an Iranian patriot. Now in the unlikely event the "reformers" get their way and bring in capitalism and liberalism, stressing individual rights and absence of coercion, next thing we'll be hearing about "Iranians of the Jewish faith," and soon they'll be running the place. And in the future some of those reformers or their kids, marginalized in their own land, truly ants, will gather on some Farsi VNN and conclude that those nasty, backward Ayatollahs weren't so bad after all.
Mike Parker
July 24th, 2009, 12:13 PM
They're able to do what they do because financial and other powers are consolidated in the national government, just as you advocate. If the feds had hard money and allowed monetary competition, which they do not, none of the thievings and bailouts would be possible.
I don't recall advocating anything, but I didn't say anything about bailouts. I asked about production. I don't see much of it. I see lots of lending, gambling and consulting. They're simply more lucrative than production: a middle manager in manufacturing doesn't get a million dollar bonus. The long-term tendency of capitalism is for the real economy to be dominated by the financial sector, and the financial sector by its most speculative parts. Rothschilds and Lehmans dominated the world's economies under the gold standard, Goldman Sachs and Quantum without it.
Not only that, it's the only arrangement that fits the nature of White men - they are thinking individuals who can come up with and act on their own plans, without needing authority.
Kevin MacDonald is very clear on this. The normal character of white societies is "muted individualism" and "hierarchic harmony."
Rick Ronsavelle
July 24th, 2009, 05:05 PM
"You have reached the blind alley of the treason you committed when you agreed that you had no right to exist. Once, you believed it was “only a compromise”: you conceded it was evil to live for yourself, but moral to live for the sake of your children. Then you conceded that it was selfish to live for your children, but moral to live for your community. Then you conceded that it was selfish to live for your community, but moral to live for your country. Now, you are letting this greatest of countries be devoured by any scum from any corner of the earth, while you concede that it is selfish to live for your country and that your moral duty is to live for the globe."
Care to guess who said that?
vBulletin® v3.8.6, Copyright ©2000-2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.