Log in

View Full Version : Atlas Shrugged


ComradeAsh
2008-10-08, 17:56
...is a good book.

I just finished reading it then and I must say that I'm surprised I had the concentration to stick with it all the way, but it was such a brilliant book.

That's all really, what did you guys think of it?

Euda
2008-10-08, 23:46
I enjoy the book, though it falls into a woeful state of diatribe more than a few times.

What did you like about it?

ComradeAsh
2008-10-09, 06:36
I guess its the uncertainty that follows everything that the characters do, a bit like a mystery and how it manages to convey the declining state of the country.

Its a bit hard to say, but you know how with some books you just don't really want to put them down?

That 55 page speech was a touch excessive, though.

lan_rogers_book
2008-10-09, 07:01
if its anything like fountain head I would give it a 2 out of 5. Ayn Rand's characters seriously lacked any depth. The philosophy that was being conveyed was legitimate but I could write a 10 page paper and cover it in more detail. Of coarse this is assuming Atlas Shrugged is anything like her other works.

SurahAhriman
2008-10-10, 00:22
if its anything like fountain head I would give it a 2 out of 5. Ayn Rand's characters seriously lacked any depth. The philosophy that was being conveyed was legitimate but I could write a 10 page paper and cover it in more detail. Of coarse this is assuming Atlas Shrugged is anything like her other works.

It's a similar tone, but it's much better written than the Fountainhead. She called it her mangum opus for a reason. My favorite book.

Irregular
2008-10-10, 23:22
gave up around page 400, about the time i realized that love was worth sacrificing yourself and your dreams for

Blanko
2008-10-11, 00:09
atlas shrugged: or how to act like a total douche for three weeks after finishing.

ChickenOfDoom
2008-10-11, 00:37
gave up around page 400, about the time i realized that love was worth sacrificing yourself and your dreams for

Scary shit

never
2008-10-11, 23:09
Brilliant novel, I couldn't agree with her philosophy anymore if I wanted to.

McFly
2008-10-14, 01:00
I read to about page 200 then quit.

Heck_Tate
2008-10-15, 12:13
Possibly one of the most boring books ever written. It's the same thing throughout the entire book. Here's my summary:

"O no everyone's a dumb fucking commie, what will we do? Wait, how about we just do things like we would if we were capitalists and make some money? Nobody likes us at all anymore but at least we have money."

Aimrehtopyh
2008-10-21, 03:06
Social Darwinists are full of shit.

Grow a conscience, expand your monkeysphere. Empathy is what makes us human.

Social Darwinism does the opposite. It turns you into a consumerist exploitation machine and invites the morality of the savanna into your living room.

Fossil fuels have rewarded the worst of our expansionist rapist-nomad nature for at least 200 years now. The "pinnacle of human achievement" stands on a mountain of slippery effluent and bloody corpses.

crazy hazy vermonter
2008-10-21, 04:26
atlas shrugged: or how to act like a total douche for three weeks after finishing.

LOL! Most insightful thing said so far.

And I do truly love Atlas Shrugged and everything else I've ever read by Rand. I had to definitely work to read through Galt's radio address because it didn't flow like the rest of the book, but I did seriously feel like a douchebag towards not only my friends and family and anyone who needed me for weeks if not months afterwards, I felt no sympathy for Darfurian refugees, Iraqi babies, victims of Robert Mugabe's torturous regime, murdered journalists in Russia, and Tibetan political prisoners in China.

lan_rogers_book
2008-10-21, 05:58
Possibly one of the most boring books ever written. It's the same thing throughout the entire book. Here's my summary:

"O no everyone's a dumb fucking commie, what will we do? Wait, how about we just do things like we would if we were capitalists and make some money? Nobody likes us at all anymore but at least we have money."

^I lol-ed at this

Aimrehtopyh, that's some deep shit, more so then I expected this thread to produce

ComradeAsh
2008-10-21, 07:23
, I felt no sympathy for Darfurian refugees, Iraqi babies, victims of Robert Mugabe's torturous regime, murdered journalists in Russia, and Tibetan political prisoners in China.

That could be why I liked it so much.

But I already didn't give a shit because it had nothing to do with me and took up my time having to listen about it.

Danny JMC
2008-10-21, 09:11
But I already didn't give a shit because it had nothing to do with me and took up my time having to listen about it.

That's cool, man. When something totally out of your control completely fucks your entire life up, nobody will have to listen to you either.

ComradeAsh
2008-10-21, 09:53
That's cool, man. When something totally out of your control completely fucks your entire life up, nobody will have to listen to you either.

You've missed the point.

They've nothing to do with me...at all.

They're not my friends, they're not my friends friends nor are they family.

Whats the point of weighing yourself down with something elses baggage.

Danny JMC
2008-10-21, 13:29
You've missed the point.

They've nothing to do with me...at all.

They're not my friends, they're not my friends friends nor are they family.

Whats the point of weighing yourself down with something elses baggage.

I haven't missed your point, you've just portrayed a pretty negative image of yourself (in my opinion). 'Out of sight, out of mind' right? I think it's a positive human trait to be empathetic of someone else's situation, it's what separates us from most of the animal world. If you can't see outside your own world, how do you expect other people to view or enter your own?

The point of weighing yourself down with someone else's 'baggage' is to offer a hand up in times of need. What satisfaction is there in ignoring problems just because they don't affect you?

Aimrehtopyh
2008-10-21, 14:49
^I lol-ed at this

Aimrehtopyh, that's some deep shit, more so then I expected this thread to produce

Thanks. The Monkeysphere (http://www.cracked.com/article_14990_what-monkeysphere.html) seldom fails to impress.

ComradeAsh
2008-10-22, 03:38
The point of weighing yourself down with someone else's 'baggage' is to offer a hand up in times of need. What satisfaction is there in ignoring problems just because they don't affect you?

What satisfaction is there in failing at a futile undertaking?

Danny JMC
2008-10-22, 10:11
What satisfaction is there in failing at a futile undertaking?

Ask that question to people who have been helped out by humanitarian aid organisations. Ask that question to any person who has their life saved by NGO's such as Amnesty International. Ask that to every child that has a bite to eat thanks to the donations of empathetic people with money to spare.

Are you fucking serious? How old are you? 10?

ComradeAsh
2008-10-22, 13:18
Ask that question to people who have been helped out by humanitarian aid organisations. Ask that question to any person who has their life saved by NGO's such as Amnesty International. Ask that to every child that has a bite to eat thanks to the donations of empathetic people with money to spare.

Are you fucking serious? How old are you? 10?

Good for them. As I previously stated, not my problem, care or concern, at least, no further than a possible tax break.

lan_rogers_book
2008-10-22, 19:09
Thanks. The Monkeysphere (http://www.cracked.com/article_14990_what-monkeysphere.html) seldom fails to impress.

Thanks for the link, I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Danny JMC
2008-10-23, 04:50
Good for them. As I previously stated, not my problem, care or concern, at least, no further than a possible tax break.

Fair play, man. To each their own lifestyle. I don't mean to sound like a prick (well, kind of), I just find it frustrating when intelligent people just choose to look the other way. I'm a member of Amnesty International and we have a hard time raising the money to help out those who can't do it themselves, only because people choose to not care.

crazy hazy vermonter
2008-10-30, 04:12
Fair play, man. To each their own lifestyle. I don't mean to sound like a prick (well, kind of), I just find it frustrating when intelligent people just choose to look the other way. I'm a member of Amnesty International and we have a hard time raising the money to help out those who can't do it themselves, only because people choose to not care.

I read Atlas Shrugged and mostly agree with what you've been saying.

Xerxes35
2008-10-31, 22:52
gave up around page 400, about the time i realized that love was worth sacrificing yourself and your dreams for

wow you took away the completely opposite lesson.

SurahAhriman
2008-11-01, 19:06
wow you took away the completely opposite lesson.

Eh, a billion years of evolution ingrained that as an instinct. Your instincts don't care if you ever write a great novel, just that you breed. Unfortunately, those same instincts will likely make him fall out of love in 4-6 years, and spend the rest of his life in miserable regret of having ruined what he really wanted in life in a temporary surge of glandular activity.

SurahAhriman
2008-11-01, 19:09
Fair play, man. To each their own lifestyle. I don't mean to sound like a prick (well, kind of), I just find it frustrating when intelligent people just choose to look the other way. I'm a member of Amnesty International and we have a hard time raising the money to help out those who can't do it themselves, only because people choose to not care.

Personally, I think Amnesty does great work. That doesn't mean I've ever seen a rational defense of a positive duty to help others that didn't assume such a duty in the first place. The Randian position is not that donating, or caring about causes is bad, but that it is not required to be a moral person.

demonicMAGE!
2008-11-02, 20:11
I loved the Fountainhead so I'm gonna have to read this :)

Irregular
2008-11-02, 20:45
Eh, a billion years of evolution ingrained that as an instinct. Your instincts don't care if you ever write a great novel, just that you breed. Unfortunately, those same instincts will likely make him fall out of love in 4-6 years, and spend the rest of his life in miserable regret of having ruined what he really wanted in life in a temporary surge of glandular activity.

you're probably right, but i lack common sense and would rather love for a month and hurt for a year than just fade away with my feelings of lethargy and apathy

what can i really do if the only thing that saves me from apathy is love?