Which one is better in say graphics and length aswell as replay value?

MC:LA by a country mile.

Thanks i am thinking of getting a new racer. And MC looks alright. Could you tell me about it a bit more?

Have you played any of the other Midnight Clubs?

They're just very solid arcade racers, and this one is no different. The new Need for Speed is fucking garbage, but LA is quite good, it's not really a hard decision.

I played MC 3 at a friends on ps2 but that was only out of pure boredom waiting for him to get back from work to get high. It was pretty fun, so is LA like this or completely different.

It's similar, but better in pretty much every way.

Ok thanks for the help.

NFS is fucking garbage, get Midnight Club. Grid is another good one, as long as you aren't trying to play it with a keyboard.